What I like / dislike about Bootstrap v6 #43296
Replies: 2 comments
|
Thanks for the honest feedback, @dagnelies, it's much appreciated 🙏 I can't promise to answer every point. We work on Bootstrap in our spare time, and there's a lot to do on both v5 and v6 right now. Not everything we read gets an answer right away (or at all 🫣), but as you know in our line of work, a lot of it stays in mind and comes back up, sometimes much later. When I can, I'll try to answer one topic per comment, so each topic gets its own thread and the discussion stays readable. |
I had the same feeling but had never checked it. Out of curiosity, I did a quick before/after of every v5 and v6 component, with and without our JavaScript. I haven't checked each one in detail, but I'm fairly confident in the results provided by AI for this kind of stuff. The basic components didn't become more JS-reliant. The ones that changed went the other way, because v6 builds them on native HTML: Full table, component by componentComponents
Forms
In numbers: seven components need less JS than in v5 and 24 are the same, CSS only in both or JS in both. Range is the only one that needs more, and only for the fill and its extras. Without JS it's the same slider as in v5. Part of the feeling might come from having more components. We went from 12 JS plugins to 20, and seven of the new ones are widgets v5 didn't have at all. Most of them fall back to a usable input or a static display without JS. Nav overflow and Combobox don't, and that's a fair point. For component libraries, the basic components should get easier to wrap. A wrapper can drive the standard |
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
This are my own personal opinions, that may diverge from everyone else. I don't care. I'm not a heavy user either, it's just my first impression as a light user.
😃 Good:
.md:col-6instead of.col-md-6. Looks good, more readable/intuitive.🤔 Mixed:
😞 Bad:
You've done a great job maintaining and evolving this lib. Well done. That said, you deserver honest feedback. I also can only speak for myself, and others might diverge by quite a lot. IMHO:
I'm kind of sad this turns out so disappointing as a conclusion. Actually, bootstrap offers a really nice foundation. It would be really nice if it flourishes well.
All reactions