Concepts to represent AI training is Permitted/Prohibited

[coolharsh55]

Following #82 adding ai:ModelTraining additional concepts should be developed to specify whether such training is permitted or prohibited, similar to P7012 concepts representing specific permissions/prohibitions.

[bact]

May related, Creative Commons just recently launched "CC Signals" for review.

From https://creativecommons.org/ai-and-the-commons/cc-signals/implementation/ there are four proposed signals:

• Credit
• Direct Contribution
• Ecosystem Contribution
• Open

The first three looks like obligations (permitted, with these obligations).
While the last one looks like a condition (prohibited, if condition is not met).

[coolharsh55]

@bact interesting - thanks for sharing Art. It doesn't have a way to say "don't use this" though, which is what is needed in this issue.

[bact]

Two IETF drafts updated today may provide few example of prohibited/permitted categories:

This draft provides robots.txt example https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-aipref-attach/:

Content-Usage: train-ai=n
Content-Usage: /ai-ok/ train-ai=y

The train-ai is a vocab from this draft https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-aipref-vocab/ :

      +========================+=============+=============+
      | Category               | Label       | Reference   |
      +========================+=============+=============+
      | Automated Processing   | all         | Section 4.1 |
      +------------------------+-------------+-------------+
      | AI Training            | train-ai    | Section 4.2 |
      +------------------------+-------------+-------------+
      | Generative AI Training | train-genai | Section 4.3 |
      +------------------------+-------------+-------------+
      | AI Use                 | ai-use      | Section 4.4 |
      +------------------------+-------------+-------------+
      | Search                 | search      | Section 4.5 |
      +------------------------+-------------+-------------+

                 Table 1: Mappings for Categories

[bact]

The draft also provides a diagram of relationships between usages:

.-------------------------------------------------.
|                                                   |
|               Automated Processing                |
|                                                   |
|   .-------------------------------------------.   |
|  |                .------------------------.   |  |
|  |               |                          |  |  |
|  |               |                          |  |  |
|  |  AI Training  |  Generative AI Training  |  |  |
|  |               |                          |  |  |
|  |               |                          |  |  |
|  |                '------------------------'   |  |
|   '-------------------------------------------'   |
|                                                   |
|    .----------------.       .----------------.    |
|   |                  |     |                  |   |
|   |                  |     |                  |   |
|   |      AI Use      |     |      Search      |   |
|   |                  |     |                  |   |
|   |                  |     |                  |   |
|    '----------------'       '----------------'    |
|                                                   |
 '-------------------------------------------------'

          Figure 1: Relationship Between Categories of Use

See all IETF AI Preferences activity here: https://datatracker.ietf.org/wg/aipref/about/