Repository navigation
[Expert Review] Payments & Treasury: When is a financial operation truly completed? #36
willgittens
started this conversation in
Ideas
Replies: 0 comments
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
A payment request was sent to a bank. The connection failed before the bank returned a response.
The system does not know whether the payment succeeded.
Should it try again? Wait? Block the operation? Request human investigation?
This scenario illustrates why a successful technical request and a completed financial transaction are not necessarily the same thing.
FinKore is currently exploring cross-domain idempotency and concurrency semantics, including duplicate prevention, conflicting instructions and uncertain completion.
But software engineers alone cannot determine what constitutes finality in real payment and treasury processes.
Questions for payment, treasury and reconciliation specialists
What we want to learn
We want to distinguish universal safety principles from payment-network-specific or provider-specific behavior.
Potential future work may involve payment lifecycle semantics, settlement status, reconciliation evidence and the financial meaning of duplicate operations.
FinKore does not currently claim to implement payment processing or settlement systems.
What is the most dangerous assumption software makes about payment completion?
All reactions