Repository navigation
Bootloaders u boot
Das U-Boot, the dominant embedded bootloader.
| Type | Monolithic bootloader (type3) |
| Upstream | https://github.com/u-boot/u-boot |
| CVEs attributed | 70 |
| Vulnerability-fixing commits | 46 naming a CVE, 428 keyword-matched |
| CVEs with a linked fix | 39 |
SPL performs DRAM and clock init from reset, then full U-Boot loads a kernel, device tree and initrd, with a command shell and scripting throughout.
Type 3: SPL plus U-Boot together take the board from reset to a running OS with no separate firmware layer -- one project spans both roles.
The SoK paper gives a full case study of this bootloader in section 3.7. See Boot-Stages for the eight-stage model these phases map onto.
- SoC ROM code -- OEM code in mask ROM runs from the reset vector and does the minimum needed to load the next image, often from a fixed offset on eMMC or SPI flash.
- TPL -- Optional tertiary program loader: very early hardware setup, used where the ROM can only load a very small image. Loads SPL or VPL.
- VPL -- Optional verification program loader, which selects among multiple verified SPL binaries.
- SPL -- Secondary program loader. Initialises DRAM and loads full U-Boot into it -- or, in Falcon mode, loads the Linux kernel directly and skips the rest.
- U-Boot proper -- The full image: driver model, filesystems, network stack, environment and the command shell.
- bootdev -- Abstracts the device that may hold an OS -- MMC, USB, NVMe, network.
- bootmeth -- Defines how each bootdev is searched for a valid boot configuration -- extlinux.conf, an EFI application, a script.
- bootflow -- The concrete sequence produced by a bootmeth on a bootdev. The first valid one found is used by default.
Because the stages are separate images built from one tree, U-Boot passes state forward explicitly: SPL hands U-Boot a struct spl_image_info, and where the same information must survive from before DRAM exists it travels in a bloblist -- a relocatable container that also carries ACPI tables, the device tree and SMBIOS data between stages. The persistent interface is the environment: a key-value store in flash (bootargs, bootcmd, fdt_addr) readable and writable from the shell and by scripts, which is how a bootflow is altered without rebuilding. U-Boot can also present itself as UEFI, publishing Boot and Runtime Services so a standard distribution loader runs unmodified.
The OS is started with the architecture's boot protocol, and the important thing passed is the flattened device tree: U-Boot may fix it up first -- inserting the MAC address, memory size, or kernel command line -- so the kernel sees a description matched to the actual board. An extlinux.conf-driven bootflow supplies the kernel, the command line, the device tree directory and the initrd, as in the paper's Listing 2. Changing anything more than the bootflow generally means reflashing.
| Surface | CVEs | |
|---|---|---|
SAS2 |
Persistent data source (software) | 20 |
SAS1 |
Remote access (software) | 6 |
HAS2 |
External hardware (hardware) | 1 |
HAS1 |
Invasive hardware (hardware) | 1 |
| CWE | CVEs |
|---|---|
| CWE-190 | 6 |
| CWE-329 | 2 |
| CWE-122 | 2 |
| CWE-798 | 2 |
| CWE-20 | 2 |
| CWE-120 | 2 |
| CWE-284 | 1 |
| CWE-77 | 1 |
Detected in its build configuration and source:
- fortify
- measured boot
- rollback protection
- secure boot
- signature verification
- stack protector
See Security-Mechanisms for how these are detected and what a detection does and does not prove.
Each of these resolves to a fixing commit and to the parent revision that still contains the bug:
| CVE | Fix | Vulnerable revision |
|---|---|---|
| CVE-2017-3225 | 5eb35220b2 |
0683fb7242 |
| CVE-2017-3226 | 5eb35220b2 |
0683fb7242 |
| CVE-2018-18439 | 9cc2323fee |
e3b4fc9598 |
| CVE-2018-18439 | 67bb984249 |
1a4af5c562 |
| CVE-2018-18439 | e964df1e2a |
aac0c29d4b |
| CVE-2018-18439 | a156c47e39 |
a85c213f47 |
| CVE-2018-18440 | e964df1e2a |
aac0c29d4b |
| CVE-2018-18440 | aa3c609e2b |
4cc8af8037 |
| CVE-2019-13103 | 232e2f4fd9 |
1493b140e4 |
| CVE-2019-13104 | 878269dbe7 |
6e5a79de65 |
| CVE-2019-13105 | 6e5a79de65 |
232e2f4fd9 |
| CVE-2019-13106 | e205896c53 |
084be43b75 |
| CVE-2019-14192 | fe7288069d |
12c2a310e8 |
| CVE-2019-14193 | fe7288069d |
12c2a310e8 |
| CVE-2019-14194 | aa207cf3a6 |
741a8a08eb |
| … and 24 more |
git -C oss-bootloaders/type3/u-boot checkout <vulnerable revision>git -C oss-bootloaders submodule update --init type3/u-boot
./scripts/analysis/run-tool.sh codeql u-bootSee Tools for what each tool applies to.