Repository navigation
Bard Plane of Sky Quest "Mask of Song" requires "Light Woolen Mantle"… #139
|
Bard Plane of Sky Quest "Mask of Song" requires "Light Woolen Mantle" not "Light Woolen Mask" as shown in the quest tracker on EQBuddy. EQBuddy 1.77.0 · Windows 26200 |
Replies: 6 comments
|
Fixed for the next update - and your hand-in caught something better than a typo: EQBuddy's data MATCHES the community wiki here, which means the wiki's bard table has the two boss items swapped and your first-hand turn-in outranks both. Mask of Song now asks for the Light Woolen Mantle (Isle 4: Keeper of Souls), and Mantle of the Songweaver takes the Light Woolen Mask (Isle 3: Gorgalosk) - the drop sources travel with the items. If you (or any bard reading) can confirm the mirror half - that Mantle of the Songweaver really wants the MASK - that pins the swap completely; and if someone with a wiki account fixes the Plane of Sky bard table, the whole community's copy gets right too. One more thing your report improved: Sky checklist corrections now propagate to existing installs automatically (they used to only reach fresh ones). Any tick you already made stays. Thanks n3cr0nk1tt3n, and welcome to the board. |
|
Now live in v1.79.0 - Mask of Song asks for the Mantle, Mantle of the Songweaver asks for the Mask, and your existing ticks survived the correction. Thanks again n3cr0nk1tt3n - and the offer stands: if the mirror half reads wrong in game, one line here fixes it. |
|
A follow-up you deserve to hear from us rather than notice in a changelog. In v1.83.0 we have moved these two back to the wiki's pairing — Mask of Song ← Light Woolen Mask, Mantle of the Songweaver ← Mantle — reversing the change your report prompted in v1.79.0. This is not us deciding you were wrong. A second player (#150) has since reported the crossed version as incorrect, and neither report includes a decisive turn-in. With the evidence genuinely split, EQBuddy's rule from now on is to match the wiki when a conflict can't be settled — not because the wiki is more likely right, but because being wrong the same way as the shared reference is recoverable, while being uniquely wrong leaves players with no way to tell who to believe. If you did watch Cilin Spellsinger take the Mantle for the Mask quest — actually hand it over and see it accepted — say so and it goes straight back, wiki or no wiki. A confirmed turn-in outranks the policy; that's what the policy is a substitute for. Thanks for reporting it in the first place. First-hand corrections are exactly what we want, and this one has made the project's rule for handling conflicting evidence explicit, which it wasn't before. |
|
Adding the same offer here, since you're the one with the first-hand account. If your hand-in went the way you reported — Cilin Spellsinger taking the Mantle for the Mask quest — then the wiki is the thing that's wrong, and correcting it there fixes this permanently rather than leaving EQBuddy as the lone dissenting voice: That's a better outcome than us carrying a divergence: it helps every player and every other tool, and it removes the ambiguity that made two people report opposite things in the first place. It also comes back to us automatically now. Our weekly wiki refresh flags catalogs whose source pages changed, and I extended it this evening to cover the sky quest data — which it had been blind to, so a correction upstream would previously have gone unnoticed on our side. That gap is closed. No pressure at all, and no need to re-litigate it here. Your report was taken seriously enough that we shipped it; if it holds up at the turn-in, the wiki is where it belongs. |
|
I was incorrect, the Mask of Song should ask for the Light Woolen Mask and the Mantle of the Songweaver should ask for the Light Woolen Mantle (two very similar item names with two similar turn in component names). |
|
Thank you for coming back to correct this — that takes more character than the original report did, and it settles something that had been genuinely unresolved. Your correction matches what shipped in v1.83.0. Mask of Song takes the Light Woolen Mask (Isle 3, Gorgalosk); Mantle of the Songweaver takes the Light Woolen Mantle (Isle 4, Keeper of Souls). So EQBuddy is now right, and your two reports between them are the reason. I want to be clear that the first one wasn't a wasted contribution. We had crossed those two entries in v1.79.0 on the strength of your report, deliberately going against the community wiki, because a first-hand turn-in should outrank a wiki page. That was the right call on the evidence available. When knaackville reported them wrong the other way (#150) we had two conflicting first-hand accounts and no way to settle it — and that's what produced a rule EQBuddy now follows generally:
Your correction is now the decisive evidence that rule was waiting for, pointing the same way. Two very similar item names with two similar turn-in components is exactly the trap that catches careful people; I'd have made the same mistake. Marking this resolved. If you ever hit another quest entry that looks off, please do report it the same way — the first report being wrong cost nothing and the follow-up was worth a lot. |
Thank you for coming back to correct this — that takes more character than the original report did, and it settles something that had been genuinely unresolved.
Your correction matches what shipped in v1.83.0. Mask of Song takes the Light Woolen Mask (Isle 3, Gorgalosk); Mantle of the Songweaver takes the Light Woolen Mantle (Isle 4, Keeper of Souls). So EQBuddy is now right, and your two reports between them are the reason.
I want to be clear that the first one wasn't a wasted contribution. We had crossed those two entries in v1.79.0 on the strength of your report, deliberately going against the community wiki, because a first-hand turn-in should outrank a wiki page. That was the right c…