Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Is this project maintained? #1011

Closed
Brian-McBride opened this issue Dec 18, 2020 · 21 comments
Closed

Is this project maintained? #1011

Brian-McBride opened this issue Dec 18, 2020 · 21 comments

Comments

@Brian-McBride
Copy link

The last release: Sep 22, 2019

Anyone know if this is maintained or maybe there is another project that picked up where this one left off?

@fourlincoln10
Copy link

Wondering the same thing myself

@XVincentX
Copy link
Member

Hey,

as I have already clarified in other occasions, the project is not actively maintained anymore.

I have put a significant amount of effort into this, but unfortunately:

  • I haven't been able to find external contributors
  • Not a single big company using the project (including Dell, BBVA and FIFA by the way) have been either willing to give a testimonial or fund the project somehow.

Sometimes it's mature to realize that a project is a failure — and ultimately (and unfortunately), Express Gateway was one of these.

@fourlincoln10
Copy link

Completely understand Vincenzo. Thank you for the work you've done!

@marcosalpereira
Copy link

I hope that some company will review its position and help the project

@XVincentX
Copy link
Member

Nothing as changed so far @marcosalpereira

@tagkiller
Copy link

It is sad, if I had a bit more time on my hand I'd gladly have offered my help as a contributor. Anyway thanks for the great work @XVincentX !

@akira28
Copy link

akira28 commented Mar 5, 2021

thanks for your work @XVincentX ! Sorry to ear it was a failure :(
Right now we are planning to build an api gateway for our services, do you have any suggestion which project should we look at? Thank you very much

@XVincentX
Copy link
Member

There's a number of mature project you can take a look at. If you want to play safe, Kong, Tyk and WSO2 are all good solution.

Cheers!

@adhisimon
Copy link

Is there any recomendation for an alternative? We need API Gateway based on node.js (especially express.js) like EG.

@scampiuk
Copy link

Always sad to hear, but a sensible approach. If you're not actively maintaing, would you still be reviewing PRs?

May I recommend that you mention this on the website also. I've spent a day or so playing around, just to run into issues I know now most likely won't be fixed :(

Shame, this did exactly what we needed :(

@KaiSchwarz-cnic
Copy link
Contributor

You should add this information at the top of the README to provide that information immediately to the public.

@XVincentX
Copy link
Member

You should add this information at the top of the README to provide that information immediately to the public.

PR welcomed :)

@KaiSchwarz-cnic
Copy link
Contributor

voilà!

@fvastu
Copy link

fvastu commented May 17, 2021

There's a number of mature project you can take a look at. If you want to play safe, Kong, Tyk and WSO2 are all good solution.

Cheers!

To me, the project was really good and I hope it will gain more attention and support in the future. However, as adhisimon said, can you suggest a good solution that integrates with the current express ecosystem? ExpressGateway was the perfect solution (Free, Integrated with express, easy to use..).

@Brian-McBride
Copy link
Author

There's a number of mature project you can take a look at. If you want to play safe, Kong, Tyk and WSO2 are all good solution.
Cheers!

To me, the project was really good and I hope it will gain more attention and support in the future. However, as adhisimon said, can you suggest a good solution that integrates with the current express ecosystem? ExpressGateway was the perfect solution (Free, Integrated with express, easy to use..).

It has a price tag, but Apigee offers extensibility via NodeJS following the Express pattern.. That is the only one I can think of off the top of my head.

If you are doing microservices and not using zero scale (your nodes are always on) then check out Molecular.js Is a little lacking in the typescript support, but it has some cool ideas. If I were to run my own on-prem service cluster, I would seriously consider picking it up. It has a gateway that can be used to provide a RESTful layer.

If your are deploying into a cloud provider, you might just try and use theor PaaS services.

@gyj1278
Copy link

gyj1278 commented Jun 4, 2021

我正在搞express的API网关,结果不维护了,不知道该用啥了

@adhisimon
Copy link

Just for information, in the end, I use krakend (written in golang) as express-gateway replacement.

@codezilla91
Copy link

Is this the official Express Gateway that will no longer be maintained? I do not see any public notice on the official website, can i still use it or rather look at alternatives?

@MiquelMarinoColvin
Copy link

Thanks for your effort. We were currently using this marvelous framework to build an API gateway. Unfortunately we will change to other framework given the circunstancies 😢
Thanks to @XVincentX and the rest of the community for your incredible effort and great idea 😄

@cingaldi
Copy link

Hey,

as I have already clarified in other occasions, the project is not actively maintained anymore.

I have put a significant amount of effort into this, but unfortunately:

  • I haven't been able to find external contributors
  • Not a single big company using the project (including Dell, BBVA and FIFA by the way) have been either willing to give a testimonial or fund the project somehow.

Sometimes it's mature to realize that a project is a failure — and ultimately (and unfortunately), Express Gateway was one of these.

late message but let me say it's very sad to know that this promising project has come to an end, thanks for your effort!

@remvee
Copy link

remvee commented Mar 28, 2022

Hi all,

First of all thank you to @XVincentX and the rest of the community for building EG. We've been using it for a project and have been pretty happy with it because of the ease of extending EG. We came a little late to the EG party and maintenance was dropped just as we finished our first EG-based project. :-( So.. we decide to fork and make a "lite" edition dropping all the stuff we don't need, in an effort to reduce the amount of dependencies thus making it easier to maintain.

If anybody is interested: https://github.com/jomco/express-gateway-lite

Cheers,
R.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests