Repository navigation
Releases
FOQA-Sim 0.13.0
The landing score is now landing-4, the same in the app, the tablet, the in-sim panel, challenges and the leaderboards. Your past flights are scored again with it, so their grades may change.
It says what it could not measure
- A flight that stayed below the approach window used to be graded against the wrong speed without a word (a C172 against 52 kt). The speed now comes from your flaps as you landed, and anything that could not be graded is listed on the landing.
- A ranked attempt with missing data does not count.
Fairer limits
- Touchdown speed, light aircraft: touching down near the stall now loses points. The stall speed follows your weight.
- Very hard landings: without a published limit from the manufacturer, a touchdown past the top level for its class (2.6 g for light aircraft) is held to 39.
- Approach speed, light aircraft: anywhere in the handbook's range is ideal.
- Touchdown point, light aircraft: you aim at the runway's own aiming point, not 150 m on every runway.
- Drift is graded as an angle, so it no longer depends on your speed.
- A small skip is no longer a bounce, and a flat touchdown is no longer graded as nose first.
- Jets and turboprops: touchdown speed allows for the wind additive.
Aircraft data
- 737-800: Vref from the Boeing QRH for flaps 15, 30 and 40.
Good to know
- Many limits are our own estimates, and they are marked as such in the method. Jet and turboprop limits have only been tried on synthetic flights.
- A310, ATR 72, Bonanza, PC-12, PC-24 and Saab 340 still have no reference speed: speed items are not graded on them, and the landing says so.
SHA-256 of FOQA-Sim_x64-setup.exe: 7fc20b8402486837b8b9aa90e2ec7edbb320cfbdd2b74998225f7e641883d886
FOQA-Sim 0.12.0
Challenge starts
- The start holds itself until you take it. The app holds the challenge's speed with the throttle and level flight with the pitch trim. Move the throttle and it is yours; move the yoke or the trim and the trim is yours. Both are yours at the gate at the latest, so everything scored is flown by hand.
- Mixture and trim start sensible: full rich and a light nose-up trim, not wherever you last left them.
- Weather and time are part of the challenge. A challenge can set the sky (clear to thunderstorm, or snow), its wind, and the date and local time at the airport. Every attempt and every restart loads the same ones.
Fixes
- A challenge at another airport now starts there. The sim moved the aircraft back to the runway your flight began on and closed the attempt; a crash then did not restart it. The clean start now departs from the challenge's runway.
Good to know
- The hold has only been flown in the C172 so far. Keep the wings level yourself: it does not touch the ailerons.
SHA-256 of FOQA-Sim_x64-setup.exe: e8f385c597e52df7b5c18956efc7ceb8c43e1f081765afcb95b412d73d8d26c7
FOQA-Sim 0.11.5
0.11.5 lets a challenge author try a draft in the sim before publishing it, and makes a wrong runway name easy to fix.
Challenges
- A wrong runway names the right ones. When a challenge asks for a runway the sim does not have, the message now lists those it has: "LTFJ has no runway 06 in the sim, only 06L, 24R".
- Test flights. A Pilot Aptitude admin can open a draft challenge from the site and fly it in the sim before publishing. It is flown as practice and never reaches a leaderboard.
SHA-256 of FOQA-Sim_x64-setup.exe: bafa9c100a2891cba42a9e60eb9b0efbd1c9834f2a915e7b86fed871975a7fe6
FOQA-Sim 0.11.4
0.11.4 ties FOQA-Sim to Pilot Aptitude, the site its landing challenges come from. There is no address to type: Pilot Aptitude is already under Challenges → Sites, and you only press Sign in.
Challenges
- Pilot Aptitude is built in. It is in the Sites list from the first start and can't be removed (you can still sign out). "Add site" is gone.
- “Fly this challenge” works from Pilot Aptitude. As in 0.11.3, the button on Pilot Aptitude puts you on final once you are signed in. Links from any other website are not opened: FOQA-Sim says it opens challenge links from Pilot Aptitude only.
- Before challenges open there, the Sites list says "Challenges aren't open on Pilot Aptitude yet." FOQA-Sim checks again when you open the Challenges screen or press Sign in, and once they are open everything works without a restart or an update.
SHA-256 of FOQA-Sim_x64-setup.exe: 6c11c826f2305d18106848dd1b83cf2f5975300867840261e6d3f549da2408ed
Also in this release (0.11.3, not published on its own)
0.11.3 makes a landing challenge a single click: "Fly this challenge" on a site puts you on final in an undamaged aircraft with no traffic around, a crash puts you back there by itself, and the attempt ends and uploads once you stop. It also fixes localizer and glideslope findings on approaches flown without that runway's ILS.
Challenges
- “Fly this challenge” on your own site puts you on final. From a site you are signed in to, the app no longer asks or stops at the briefing: it takes the challenge, places the aircraft and starts the ranked attempt. If something is red in the pre-flight check (no flight loaded, another aircraft), it shows the briefing with what to fix. Links from other sites still ask first. An attempt still open from earlier makes way for the new one.
- Every attempt starts from the same clean start. The first attempt saves the start as a clean flight; every attempt then loads it back, waits for the sim to settle, and places you at the start, so a crash or damage never carries into the next attempt. It takes about 15 seconds and is shown in the attempt log. If the sim does not finish loading within a minute, nothing is placed and the attempt asks you to fly again, rather than leaving you where the sim later moves you.
- No other aircraft during a challenge. The clean start has the sim's AI air traffic off, so no airliner crosses your final and leaves its wake behind.
- NAV1 is tuned to the runway's ILS when you are placed, if that runway has one.
- A challenge flight starts at the challenge start. Placing you on final now ends the flight you were in (kept as its own flight, or dropped if it was only a few seconds) and starts a new one on final; the attempt, its debrief and its analysis all use that one, with no takeoff that never happened.
- A crash flies you again by itself. The sim does not report a crash to other apps, so FOQA-Sim reads the impact: a touchdown at 4 g or 2,000 fpm or more ends the attempt and starts reloading the clean start a second after the impact.
- Wing, propeller and nose strikes are crashes. A landing that ends with a wingtip or the propeller on the runway (a ground loop or nose-over, or touching down with a wing too low) no longer scores: the attempt ends as a crash and Fly again starts by itself, the attempt log says what struck, the grade is held at zero and the debrief shows it as a high-level event. FOQA-Sim tells it from the attitude on the ground (more than 12° of bank in a light aircraft, 8° in an airliner, or the nose more than 5° down, for half a second).
- A challenge finishes when you stop. Once the aircraft has come to a stop after the landing (under 2 kt for 3 seconds), the attempt is graded and uploaded at once; no need to press Finish or wait two minutes.
- Every challenge is graded the way the debrief grades the landing. A challenge file may name an older scoring method (landing-1, landing-2); it is now always graded with the current landing assessment, so the attempt's score and the debrief's never disagree. The briefing shows the method actually used.
- Signing in to a challenge site works with sites that route in the page address (like Pilot Aptitude): the sign-in request now reaches the page.
ILS deviations
- Deviations count only when you land on the runway the ILS belongs to. With another runway's ILS tuned (a parallel runway, the opposite end, another airport) the needles still move, often to full scale, but say nothing about your approach, so localizer and glideslope findings are left out there, as a real FDM program does.
- How FOQA-Sim tells: the recorder now records the localizer's course. The ILS belongs to the runway you landed on when that course points along the runway and the localizer needle is near the middle as you touch down on the centreline. The opposite end points the other way; a parallel runway's localizer points the same way but reads near full scale when you are on this runway's centreline. The sim does not report reliably which airport and runway the ILS serves, so the course and the needle are what is used.
- If you retune on the way, only the part flown on the landing runway's ILS counts.
- Flights recorded before 0.11.3 have no localizer course, so their localizer and glideslope findings are left out entirely: no finding is better than a wrong one. The same goes for the approach before a go-around, which lands on no runway to compare with.
Localizer and glideslope findings may disappear from flights you already recorded; they are analysed again after the update.
FOQA-Sim 0.11.2
0.11.2 changes what counts as a go-around, after a circuit flight with a go-around and a touch-and-go showed one missed and one that never was.
Go-arounds
- A go-around from high on final is found. Going around from 800 ft or higher, the climb passed 1000 ft before it had risen enough to count, so the flight showed no go-around at all. The climb is now followed past 1000 ft, as long as it lasts.
- A dive away from the field is not a go-around. An approach now has to close on a runway: a descent below 1000 ft and climb while flying away from every runway stays en route, even near an airport recorded without runways, such as a heliport.
- Levelling off at circuit height is not one either: the approach has to come down by at least 200 ft first, to more than 50 ft under 1000 ft.
- The in-sim panel agrees: its live phases use the same rule. A go-around from high on final shows there once its climb has risen 200 ft.
Go-arounds and the phases around them may change in flights you already recorded; they are analysed again after the update.
SHA-256 of FOQA-Sim_x64-setup.exe: 2b83e9481a16c3797d3e7fbb60faf3409da7f3aae389e5fa4ba270eeabf2bf4f
FOQA-Sim 0.11.1
0.11.1 fixes the flight list that some of you could not open after 0.11.0, and lets you look at what you flew by hand apart from what the autopilot flew.
Fixes
- The flight list opens again. Ending a flight back to the main menu, or a reload or slew after a landing, could leave a flight that stopped the whole list from loading ("Could not read the flights"). Those flights now analyse normally and come back in the list.
- One bad flight no longer hides the others: if a flight still cannot be analysed, it is left out and the rest of the list shows.
- The in-sim panel's last landing no longer flickers: a touchdown that the flight's analysis later drops, such as a wheel hop on the takeoff roll, stops showing instead of coming and going every few seconds.
Autopilot or hand-flown
- Autopilot strip on the timeline: under the phase bar you see where the autopilot was engaged, and a tick marks where it came off before the landing.
- Events say how you were flying: each event is tagged AP or Hand-flown, and the list can show only one of them.
- Ride quality, split: switch the card between the whole flight, the part on the autopilot and the part flown by hand.
- "Hand-flown" instead of a dash: when the autopilot was off through the whole approach, the Automation card says so, and Hand-flown final shows the approach's time.
Replay
- Flight display, map and charts in view together: on a wide window the flight display sits over the map, and the charts get the wide column beside them, so one cursor shows where you were, what the instruments read and every parameter at once. The events list moved into a tab next to the charts.
SHA-256 of FOQA-Sim_x64-setup.exe: 0f220c23a9829950b812ef46b184ee3fea58aaae7c23ce65bd1a98571bd000ad
FOQA-Sim 0.11.0
0.11.0 is a quality release. It keeps your flights when things go wrong, and it makes the analysis read more like an airline's flight data review.
Recording you can trust
- A sim crash no longer loses the flight: if MSFS crashes or is closed from Task Manager, the flight is saved and analysed, and FOQA-Sim waits for the sim again instead of saying "Recording" forever.
- Quitting during a pause saves the flight too.
- No flight while you sit in the main menu: opening FOQA-Sim with MSFS already in the main menu no longer starts recording; the flight starts when you start one.
- A full disk or a locked folder no longer drops the open flight: what was recorded is kept, the tray says which folder could not be written, and FOQA-Sim retries calmly instead of every two seconds.
- Flights cut off by a crash are recovered at the next start, up to where the recording ends.
- One flight, one aircraft: changing aircraft, loading another flight, or teleporting from the world map now ends the flight and starts a new one.
- A log file: FOQA-Sim now keeps a log in its app data folder, and if it cannot start it says why instead of disappearing.
Landings, judged more fairly
- Hard landings are measured like a flight data recorder measures them, at 16 samples a second, so a single noisy sim frame no longer turns a firm landing into a hard one.
- Taking a high-speed exit is not a runway excursion. Turning off onto a rapid-exit taxiway at up to 50 kt is normal technique.
- Light aircraft aim where light aircraft aim: 150 m past the threshold, not an airliner's 400 m aiming point. Threshold crossing height now compares wheels with wheels.
- Slew, teleports and flight reloads are not landings, and they don't spoil the approach that follows them.
- A displaced threshold no longer leaves a landing unscored; touching down before it counts as short.
- Autobrake, reversers and prop beta count as starting to slow down.
- A crash during the landing now scores 0.
- Heights are measured from the airport you are flying to, also for a go-around or a low approach somewhere else, and flight phases no longer run across a slew or teleport.
- Crab angle uses the true heading, so magnetic variation no longer skews it.
New and corrected events
- Rejected takeoffs are recognised as their own phase (RTO), with the speed they were rejected at.
- Takeoff events: rotation rate, flaps retracted too early, and bank close to the ground after liftoff.
- Gear not down at 500 ft now applies to every retractable aircraft, not only airliners.
- Stall warnings at liftoff and, for airliners, in the flare are no longer ignored.
- Light-aircraft approaches get sink-rate and bank events from 1000 ft, not just at 500 ft.
- One event, not several: a value hovering at a limit gives one event, and the gear is read the way a recorder stores it.
More aircraft, judged as what they are
- Approach speeds for the airliners: the A320 family, 737, 747-8 and 787 now carry approach speeds from the manufacturers' airport-planning data, so speed-high and speed-low events finally fire for them.
- New aircraft: A320ceo, 777-300ER, 777-200, Cessna 152 and Piper Archer.
- Better recognition: an aircraft is matched by its type, then by the names add-ons and liveries use, then by what the sim says about it (engines, gear, category, weight). The debrief says how it was recognised, and when no profile matched, which checks were therefore off.
- Helicopters and gliders are no longer scored as if they had landed an airliner on a runway.
- New events: Mach above Mmo, and landing above the maximum landing weight.
Lighter next to the sim
- Far less memory in the tray: closing the window now frees it; FOQA-Sim waits in the tray using about a tenth of the memory it used to.
- Less work while you fly: the in-sim panel's live analysis runs only while the panel is open, the recorder waits for the sim instead of checking a thousand times a second, reads fewer frames in cruise (every frame near the ground), and writes to disk once a second.
- Re-analysing your flights after an update runs at background priority, so it doesn't compete with the sim.
- A faster app: screens load when you open them, and debrief playback no longer redraws the whole page each step.
A friendlier app
- Getting started in four steps: a fresh install shows the way to your first debrief, in-sim panel, sim connected, fly, debrief, with each step live and the one thing that moves it on.
- Your latest flight, in context: the flight list opens with your newest flight and how it compares with your own recent landings in that type, once you have a few.
- A flight list for hundreds of flights:
- Search, filters and scroll are kept when you come back from a debrief.
- Filter by aircraft, airport, tag and dates.
- Recordings that were never a flight are hidden.
- Select many to move to the trash or export.
- Every delete can be undone; the trash empties itself after 30 days.
- Titles, notes and tags for every flight, written in the debrief and searchable in the list.
- A clearer debrief:
- What changes how to read the score comes first, with the events worth a look right under it.
- Older and newer flight buttons (J / K).
- Aviation terms explain themselves when you point at them.
- A tick shows your own median sink rate and load on the gauges.
- The layout works from the smallest window up, and stays still as you move the pointer over the track and charts.
- Settings: fuel in kilograms or pounds, runway distances in metres or feet, UTC or local time, and your date and number format. Altitude and speed stay in feet and knots, as in every cockpit.
- Easier to read and use:
- Stronger colours for the light theme.
- Notices with a button stay until you close them.
- Tooltips on every header button.
- A skip-to-content link, and calmer motion when Windows asks for it.
- Setup reads as steps, and says what is required and what is optional, also for MSFS 2020. Challenges show where you are in the flow, and Trends fill wide windows.
Landing method landing-3
- The landing assessment is now
landing-3: the fixes above change what a landing scores, and a published method never changes. Challenge attempts you already flew keep the method and score they were graded with.
Smaller fixes
-
In-sim, the panel needs reinstalling once from the Setup screen so its live tabs keep working.
-
Replacing a challenge with a newer copy now really replaces it.
-
A broken link no longer blanks the window; a failing panel shows a message with a way out.
-
In the debrief, Space and the arrow keys work on the focused button again instead of moving the playback.
-
The app no longer shows one challenge's briefing on another after a quick switch.
SHA-256 of FOQA-Sim_x64-setup.exe: 5c431d9777eea9dfb2aed3a30fcfd60e3893f03cb760f503fe580cb4c2aa7a5a
FOQA-Sim 0.10.2
0.10.2 keeps the flight list for flights, and makes updates finish where you can see them.
Changed
- No more empty recordings: a recording that holds under 10 seconds, or never left the sim's menu position, is no longer kept. Ending one from the panel now says there was nothing to save instead of "Flight saved". Recordings you already have are left as they are; delete them from the list if you like.
- The window opens after an update: FOQA-Sim starts in the tray, so after an update it used to reopen out of sight. Now it opens its window, and the update card says "Installing… FOQA-Sim will restart" before the installer takes over.
- Flights in the header: the flight list has its own button next to Trends and Challenges.
- The version is shown next to the name; click it for what's new.
SHA-256 of FOQA-Sim_x64-setup.exe: 030aa811c06ee20a00ecab236c705de1d32ff38d809d825475d7c42428399a10
FOQA-Sim 0.10.1
0.10.1 makes Trends count what an airline counts: flights flown, not every time the sim was open.
Changed
- Only real flights count: a recording counts as a flight when the aircraft spent at least a minute and a mile in the air at flying speed. A takeoff or a landing is not needed, so a challenge that starts on final or a flight you ended in the air still counts.
- What was left out is said plainly: under the figures, Trends tells you how many recordings were not counted and why (never left the ground, or too short to be a flight), and how many counted flights started or ended in the air.
- Hours flown: the hours are now time in the air, not time with the sim open.
- Slew is not flying: in Trends, time moved in slew mode no longer counts as time in the air.
SHA-256 of FOQA-Sim_x64-setup.exe: f5ea1959d5ec5859831cc6df9fa4ae280e39aa44846e40e1cde2daf7ecec3040
FOQA-Sim 0.10.0
0.10.0 is the first version anyone can download from GitHub, and the last one you install by hand: from here on FOQA-Sim updates itself.
New
- Automatic updates: when a new version is out, FOQA-Sim tells you with its release notes. Choose Install and restart and it updates in a small window and opens again. It never installs while a flight is being recorded.
- Check for updates on the What's new screen, whenever you like.
- Signed updates: every update is signed with the project's key, and the app refuses one that does not match.
- Download page: the installer is on GitHub, with its SHA-256 in each release.
Note
- The installer is not code-signed yet, so Windows SmartScreen may warn the first time: choose More info, then Run anyway.
SHA-256 of FOQA-Sim_x64-setup.exe: 9e0dd4d997c60609d70f4ee91a2b1816884a328dffdfa8086a2dc0809c2052bc