Skip to content

5. PRODUCT ARCHITECTURE

SupreetPalankar edited this page Jun 22, 2022 · 10 revisions

PUGH CHART FOR ALTERNATIVE DESIGN

Design Objectives Weights Design 1 Design 2 Design 3 Design 4
Good grip to hold object 8 - -- 0 DATUM
cost 4 + -- + DATUM
Speed to pick and place 6 -- + - DATUM
Aesthetic 7 - 0 0 DATUM
Strength to robotic arm 8 - 0 - DATUM
Score(+)   4   4 4 0
Score (-)   35  24 14 0
Total   -31 -20 -10 0

JUSTIFICATION FOR SCORE

Design No. Objective Score Allocated Justification for the Score
1 good grip to hold object -8 grip was not as strong as datum
cost 4 low budget model than datum
speed to pick and place -12 had low speed to pick and place as compared to datum
aesthetic -7 model is not easy to use for the user
strength to robotic arm -8 robotic arm was not as strong as compared to datum
2 good grip to hold object -16 vaccum grip not as strong as 2 jaw gripper in datum
cost -8 high budget then datum
speed to pick and place 4 high efficiency and speed than datum
aesthetic 0 equally asthetic as datum
strength to robotic arm 0 equal strenght of arm
3 good grip to hold object 0 grip was as strong as datum
cost 4 less budget model as compared to datum
speed to pick and place -6 had slow speed to pick and place as compared to datum
aesthetic 0 model is equally aesthetic as compared to datum
strength to robotic arm -8 robotic arm was not as strong as compared to datum
4 good grip to hold object datum as a reference
cost datum as a reference
speed to pick and place datum as a reference
aesthetic datum as a reference
strength to robotic arm datum as a reference

FUNCTIONAL CLUSTERING

image

SUBSYSTEM LIST

SL. No. Subsystem
  1. | Picking
  2. | Placing
  3. | Indication

INTERACTION DETAILS

Picking Placing Indication
Spatial no no
Data yes yes
Material no no
     
     
Placing Picking Indication
Spatial no no
Data yes yes
Material no no
     
Indication Picking Placing
Spatial no no
Data yes yes
Material no no

Clone this wiki locally