Skip to content

An ontological rabbit hole

Dimo Markov edited this page Aug 21, 2024 · 2 revisions

Noun

death (countable and uncountable, plural deaths)

  1. The cessation of life and all associated processes; the end of an organism's existence as an entity independent from its environment and its return to an inert, nonliving state. quotations ▼
    The death of my grandfather saddened the whole family.

    1. Execution (in the judicial sense). quotations ▼
      The serial killer was sentenced to death.
  2. (often capitalized) The personification of death as a (usually male) hooded figure with a scythe; the Grim Reaper. quotations ▼
    When death walked in, a chill spread through the room.

  3. (preceded by the) The collapse or end of something. quotations ▼
    England scored a goal at the death to even the score at one all.

    1. (figuratively, especially followed by of-phrase) A cause of great stress, exhaustion, embarrassment, or another negative condition (for someone).
      This bake sale is going to be the death of me!
  4. (figurative) Spiritual lifelessness.

Problem

There are some problems with this seemingly simple thing:

  1. Death isn't really something that happens through a single action. It is a consequence of bodily functions systemically failing due to various reasons. It can occur without warning or anticipation throughout the Flow-Unit-Organism simulation - like from old age for example, or because of a complex avalanche of factors.
  2. Flow-Unit-Mind will account for death only if witnessed - a Mind can't directly interface the main (the omniscient god-mode) flow.
  3. Witnesses might have limited tools to decide if someone is dead. Their observational capabilities might be extended by tools (like a brain scanner), and every Mind can have different Flow-Trait-History of what happened. So we can't just check Flow-Trait-Health directly - that's cheating! Instead, we should continuously probe the participators for their ability to perform the actions we associate with life (the verbs reflected by Flow-Unit-Organism, which we can observe.

Let's observe the following Mind History sequence, perceived by an agent:

// We saw something initiated the cannonball's continuous movement forward at time '1'
// with large magnitude - very dangerous to organisms
#cannonball move *200 @1 Force(forward)
//...4 units of time pass...

// The simulation just ticks without anything emitted until the cannonball hits the organism
// at time '5', which transfers a bit of kinetic energy to the organism, damaging its organs
// The following verbs are emitted through the simulation:
// 1. The cannoball hits the organism with a huge force
#cannonball touch*200 #organism
// 2. The cannoball deflects a bit according to the surface it hits
#cannonball move @5 Force(backward+up)
// 3. The organism suffers damage and moves depending on where the ball hits
#organism move @5 -Force(backward+up)
// 4. Other events might happen too, like sounds, particles, 
// verbal responses from the organism signaling pain, etc...
//...1 unit of time passes...

The simulation leads the organism to die @ time 6, but we don't know that yet. So how do we detect it?

Realistic Detection

The detection of death will be registered on two occasions:

  1. When the observer's Mind component updates its model of the surroundings
  2. When an external force queries the observer's Mind about death in some way.

Via provocation

We can poke the organism with a stick (both figuratively and literally) and check its response (assume the organism is reachable, and that we are holding a stick). If the organism is alive, the simulation will respond with more than the initial push with a delay.

#stick move @7 Force(forward)
//...1 unit of time passes...

// If dead, the organism just responds immediately with a ragdoll movement - no added effort
#organism move @7 Force(forward)

// If the organism was just sleeping, we would likely startle it, and it will jump
// thus adding a lot more energy to our initial poke, and react a bit slower than just
// an immediate transfer of kinetic energy, showing "aliveness"
#organism move *10 @8 Force(forward)

Here's another "poke" through a different verb:

#me say @7 "Hey, are you alive?"
//...1 unit of time passes...
#organism say @8 "I respond, therefore I am!"

// Not responding will mean that the organism no longer supports the "say" verb. It wouldn't
// mean they're dead per se, but if we know the organism have failed other pokes in the
// past, then it might be just enough.

In any case, after a provocation has been dispatched, all we can do is just wait and observe.

Via observation

By sampling the state of the organism in various ways:

  • has the destroy verb been called on it?
  • is it actively fighting gravity by standing up? - usually depicted by a repeating move opposite to the direction of gravity. Undoubtedly, standing up is a very good indicator of life.
  • is it breathing; can you hear a heartbeat; does your ECG display brain function? - all are observable actions produced by the organism unit.
  • did it react to a "poke"? - simply log the last time the thing did any verb.
  • has it been X years since its last action? - was the last thing they did way beyond the expected lifespan?
  • is it buried underground in a coffin with a named gravestone on top? - basically, the idea of the thing has been associated with the idea of death already.
  • does it smell funky? - olfactory cues.
  • is its head missing; color is off; guts are spilled across the floor? - visual cues.
  • and many, many more...

Detecting death is a whole science, and its definition has changed a number of times throughout our history. Remember in The Expanse, when Miller and Holden entered a room full of bodies and got a deadly dose of radiation in a split second, stating "I think we just died". A Mind has to collect data about what leads to death, what are its symptoms - the idea will change throughout the Minds journey in time. And yet, they didn't die at the end, because they were able to make it to a health station - something that is possible only in a future where such tech exists.

Additionally, the ability to associate a visual trait with death is a high-level function. Small children and animals have trouble recognizing death when they see it (they often have no use for the idea either way). Usually they come to the conclusion much later due to (a priori known) bad smell, rigidity, lack of warmth, etc. And even these can be considered high-level functions when we talk about the cellular world, where organisms are in constant tug of war due to their inability to be both "away from the danger which made someone's juicy insides spill", while "basking in the tasty glory of free food" at the same time.

Realistic definition

So, having all these things considered, how do we define death? Since we're working on an ontology here, let's constrain ourselves to the modern day human definition only. Animals will likely just use a subset of the conditions we impose here. #todo

##death = {
	##not(##stand(??))
	and
	##not(##breathe(??))
	and
	... // many more...
}

// "Is he dead?" - collect history of 'him' and test against our idea of death. If at least
// one of the branches passes, then we have a death.
// If 'he' is around and we have nothing more important to do - our mind will "poke" them
// automatically to update its representation, by provoking its way into a new 
// historical entry for the object (if it reacts in any way) - this will simply make
// the history more relevant.
##death(?.History.#he) != null

Reductionistic definition and detection

Now, obviously, constantly surveying the environment for complex event patterns is costly. It is a task as complex as general purpose computer vision for self-driving cars. Hence, since we have complete control of the world simulation, we can reduce the problem by just emitting and detecting the emitted event:

##death = ?.Events::Death

We must keep in mind, that this doesn't allow for lying or mistakes, which considerably reduces the variety and complexity of the world. We could approximate that by introducing chance at emitting/detecting. If you want a realistic handling, you can simply disable the events from Mod-Life.

Clone this wiki locally