Repository navigation
How to configure a 2nd floor that is partly within the roof space #147
|
Firstly thanks for this frankly amazing add-on! Apologies if I've missed or misunderstood, but I'm struggling with how to configure our 2nd floor as it sits 'within' the roof partly. We have a single 45 degree gabled roof over the entire 2nd floor. The 'outer' walls of this floor are 'shorter' in height, ~1.5m, but the 'inner' walls are full height, 2+ meters. As I added the roof last, I had already defaulted all walls to the standard height of 2.5m. I then 'lowered' them all to 1.5m and reconfigured to roof to sit at this height. I now need to reconfigure the inner walls to their correct height, and (if possible) represent the walls that slope down from full height along the roofline. There are also french doors at either end that are full height, but when I reduced the wall height these too reduced to 1.5m. Is this possible, or does it require future enhancement? Many thanks once again! |
Replies: 15 comments 4 replies
|
@twynne Thanks! The trick is to not lower the walls – keep the floor's room height at the full 2.5 m and let the roof cut them. In the Roof tool select the gable section and set its wall top (eaves) to 1.5 m (the height where your outer walls end). NeonPlan then cuts every wall of that floor against the roof: the outer walls end at 1.5 m, the walls under the ridge stay at full height, and the walls running towards the gable get the sloped top you drew. Windows and doors keep their own height and are clamped to the slope only where the roof is lower, so your full-height French doors in the gable ends stay full height. Manual chapter 4.19, "Roof slopes (knee wall)". If the roof is a separate section over a part of the floor, give that section the lower wall top and the rest keeps the ceiling. |
|
Thank you, but I now can't seem to get the wall height back to standard (even having removed the roof). They keep going back to 1.5m after changing to 2.5m. Is there some easy way without rebuilding this floor from scratch? |
|
Got a bit further.. realised I had to go back to the floor config and set wall height back to 2.5m. That's worked, but I've now ended up with walls going through the roof. |
|
@wouter-b Walls are cut only where a roof section covers them and that section's wall top sits below the floor's ceiling. In your picture the walls stand full height through the slopes, which usually means one of two things: (1) the section's wall top (eaves) still equals the room height – lower it (e.g. 1.2 m with 2.5 m rooms) and the cut appears; or (2) parts of those rooms lie outside the section rectangle (a wing reaching past the gable) – enlarge the section or add one for the wing, since walls outside every section keep their height. If both are set and it still does not cut, export the plan (Editor → Backup → "Share as template", no entities inside) and attach it here; then I can see what the roof does with it. |
|
I've tried checking what you've suggested, but I'm either missing a setting or misunderstanding. I've attached the template and would hugely appeciate any pointers. One note is that as this is the 2nd floor, the 'eave' and 'top of walls' appears to need to be cumulative from the floors below. I've tried fiddling with these values, but they result either in the roof returning to the top of the full wall height, or cutting off the french doors. |
|
@twynne @wouter-b Thanks for the templates, they made it easy to find. You both did it right; NeonPlan had a gap: a floor was only cut when the section's top of walls lay below that floor's ceiling, while the eaves were ignored. In both your plans the eaves are lower than the ceiling (7 m eaves over a 2nd floor up to 8 m; 1 m eaves over a single 2.5 m floor), so nothing was cut. This is fixed: a low eave now cuts the walls below, so with your current settings the 2nd floor walls follow the slopes. It comes with the next small update (1.12.2). Until then, a workaround: set Top of walls a bit below the ceiling of the floor that should be cut (e.g. 7.9 instead of 8). |
|
Great that you were able to find the issue. As for the workaround, I can't get it to work but maybe I'm not understanding. You're suggesting to select the 2nd floor, select the Roof tool, select the roof section, and set 'top of walls' to 7.9m? For me that still shows the walls 'through' the roof. If I lower the 'top of walls' figure further, the roof starts to cut into features below (french doors for ex) and doesn't seem to impact the walls going through the roof. |
|
@twynne I think I found the real reason: your installation is still on NeonPlan 3D 1.9.0 (see your report #218). Walls cut by the roof slopes only arrived in 1.10.0, so on 1.9.0 no setting can make it work, which is why the workaround did nothing. Please update to the latest version (HACS › NeonPlan 3D › ⋮ › "Update information" › "Download", restart Home Assistant, reload the page with Ctrl+F5). With 1.12.1 set Top of walls to 7.9 (just below your 2nd floor ceiling at 8.0) and the walls follow the slopes. From the next update (1.12.2) on, your original settings work as they are. |
|
@twynne @wouter-b 1.12.2 is out: a roof section whose eaves lie below a floor's ceiling now cuts that floor's walls, so your settings work as they are. (twynne: first update from 1.9.0, as written above.) Update via HACS, restart Home Assistant, reload with Ctrl+F5. |
|
Closing as solved with 1.12.2 – thanks to both of you for the templates, they made the fix easy. Open a new one anytime if something still looks off. |









@twynne @wouter-b 1.12.2 is out: a roof section whose eaves lie below a floor's ceiling now cuts that floor's walls, so your settings work as they are. (twynne: first update from 1.9.0, as written above.) Update via HACS, restart Home Assistant, reload with Ctrl+F5.