Repository navigation
Companion note, version 1.35
tex/diaz_prove2me.tex, 43 pages. The PDF is attached as diaz_prove2me-v1.35.pdf.
New: Proposition 5.29(e) and (f), and the agreement with Theorem E proved. Version 1.34 left three caveats on
Theorem F (Proposition 5.29(c)). Six results of 23 October 2026 settle them.
- Agreement with Theorem E (Remark 5.30). Let z be a Laurent polynomial in v = u/s, s² = uū, with dim W_z = 5.
Then W_z has one of Theorem F's shapes (D1), (D2a), (D2b) exactly when it is in one of the classes (P), (Q), (R) of
Proposition 5.25 (DiazModulus.laurent_conj_hull_configuration_shape_iff_class).- It is a corollary of 5.25(a) and 5.29(c), so it does not derive 5.25 from 5.29. The criteria of 5.25(b) and (c)
still do not follow from 5.29(c). - The explicit maps:
- a hull of class (P) is (D2a) for the pencil (X², 1) (
DiazModulus.laurent_polynomial_class_conj_hull_two_orbit_form); - the span of class (Q) is (D2b) for the pencil (sX, X² + βs²) (
DiazModulus.laurent_involution_class_space_cyclic_form); - in class (R), the triple (u⁻¹, 1, g) gives (D1) (
DiazModulus.laurent_real_pencil_class_space_u_multiplier_triple).
- a hull of class (P) is (D2a) for the pencil (X², 1) (
- It is a corollary of 5.25(a) and 5.29(c), so it does not derive 5.25 from 5.29. The criteria of 5.25(b) and (c)
- (e) Uniqueness in Theorem NF. In the setting of 5.29(a), with h = p(u)/q(u), the f ∈ W with hf ∈ W are exactly
span(x₁y₁, x₁y₂, x₁y₃). So W ∩ h⁻¹W has dimension 3, and the span of the products depends only on W and h
(DiazModulus.degree_two_configuration_multiplier_space_eq). This is the uniqueness half of the research notes'
normal form, which (a) leaves out. - (f) At a candidate. Under Roy's theorem, no z ∈ Q̄(u) whose hull meets the criterion of (c) lies in ℒ̃
(DiazModulus.candidate_rational_conj_hull_criterion_not_mem_logAlgTilde). Each instance is one substitution in Roy's
theorem, as in Proposition 5.25(d).
All six are routine, and none was found in the sources read.
Remark 5.30 also says which source on scrolls was read: a textbook chapter, which prints the ingredients of the bundle
proof but not the three shapes. A printed form of the bundle statement may exist in the specialist literature, which
was not read.
Appendix A. One new row with six identifiers; 219 identifiers in all. The mirror holds 503 results, all building in
CI on Lean's three standard axioms.