Repository navigation
Major and avoidable accessibility and usability downgrade in latest version; the copy username/password function #7946
Unanswered
robw-ddsn
asked this question in
Bitwarden Clients Q&A
Replies: 1 comment 2 replies
As noted in a number of places, the Vaultwarden team is not responsible for the behavior of the clients (including the web vault), except for the minimal changes required to make the web vault compatible with Vaultwarden. |
2 replies
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment

Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Firstly please allow me to thank all Vaultwarden contributors and Daniel especially for the hard work and success in creating a wonderful platform, and giving it to the world without forcing a payment. You are honourable and valiant leaders. Respect!
I posted this feedback as a discussion rather than a bug because it addresses matters of professional judgement, not fundamental flaws.
The latest version we installed (1.37.5) changed the way primary options are accessed via the kebab menu:
As a UX professional, for now let me suspend my disdain for the kebab menu generally. Now that many people in the world (but not everyone, and not many you'd expect, and not some of those most in need) have learned what the obscure visual prompt means, let's agree for the moment to accept the kebab menu design compromise despite it's many and major flaws.
In prior versions of Vaultwarden, all of the options for item management were available in the kebab menu.
In the latest version, some of the most commonly accessed options (e.g. 'copy username' and 'copy password') have disappeared from the kebab menu. They are now invisible, and magically appear when you roll over an item. Then they disappear if you move to another item, click on the kebab menu, or inadvertently bump your input device outside the item hover zone. If you click on the kebab menu dot-dot-dot, the most commonly used options (e.g. 'copy username' and 'copy password') are not visible in the dropdown options, and the previously visible additional buttons from the item rollover motion become permanently hidden (even if you move your mouse around and try to roll over the item again), and it's not possible to bring them back without actively clicking outside the kebab menu dropdown options box.
Additionally there are now multiple dropdowns on each item, increasing the cognitive load to work out what the rules might be, even for advanced users.
The label on the new 'copy username'/'copy password' dropdown is "Copy", which in most software systems refers to making a copy of the associated item.
The icon on the new 'copy username'/'copy password' dropdown is ambiguous: the "two documents" icon is most commonly associated with duplicating documents in most software systems, but in truth many users don't understand it visually at all without a directly associated text prompt, and rightly so because it doesn't mean anything on its own without context.
We watched advanced and high cognition users in our team become overtly frustrated with the interface change, and actively debate whether or not the most important functions had disappeared altogether. Some of them reverted to clicking on the item name to find what they needed.
The worse outcome was for two individual members of our team, one who is mildly motor impaired, and another who is cognitively challenged. The latter person blamed themself and experienced emotional distress for not understanding how to copy passwords to their clipboard as we have previously trained them, and visually documented in our support guides for their daily reference. After support and re-training, they are still struggling after a few days to understand the new approach and which dropdown menu icon to click, and why it's different to other systems,
Respectfully, may I suggest a few things:
Note: I did not address the new "Launch website" button magically appearing/disappearing/sometimes-not-appearing in this article because I thought it more important to address the most critical item without distraction. :)
Cheers,
Rob
All reactions