email return null for public email

[gaurvivek]

it returns email only for sdk registered user and return null for all users even if i login using email.
$response = $fb->get('/me?fields=id,name,first_name,last_name,email,gender,education,birthday,location,picture,link', $accessToken);

but it returns null except my registered account.

[tolbon]

Do you check the user permission "email" ?
You can only access email address of user who accept your app and your permission email.
email is sensible information.

[gaurvivek]

I am doing this
$accessToken = $helper->getAccessToken();
$response = $fb->get('/me?fields=id,name,first_name,last_name,email,gender,education,birthday,location,picture,link', $accessToken);

what should i do now? How to set permission.

[tolbon]

Do you have check email permission in your app dashboard -> app review ?

[gaurvivek]

yes I did. It shows green signal near email.
I am adding here sniffed of my app page review

What else should I do?

[tolbon]

Did you try with your app in Graph API Explorer ?

[gaurvivek]

I am getting my own email not others.
And Graph API Explorer works only for registered api accounts. (As i seen)

[tolbon]

You can only access email address of user who accept your app and your permission email.

[gaurvivek]

But when i log in with another account, it doesn't ask for permission.

[gaurvivek]

Here is sniffed of page when i first time login

this is full list of permission and it doesn't ask for email.

[tolbon]

That's weird, I don't know. But that's the reason why you didn't have email. I prefer you ask on FbDevelopers Groups and close this ticket cause it's not a bug of sdk.

Thanks and sorry for didn't help you :(

[gaurvivek]

Already did.....here
https://developers.facebook.com/bugs/241915622947783/
they recommended to notify here.

[tolbon]

Why you don't say that before ...

[tolbon]

Can you post here the encoded body and decoded body of the request when it's null ?
$response->getBody()

This is for all of your account you test ?

[tolbon]

GET https://graph.facebook.com/USER_ID/permissions?access_token=USER_ACCESS_TOKEN

What the result of that request in curl or php sdk ?

[gaurvivek]

I found the solution. I haven't add proper permissions. Thank you for helping.