Repository navigation
|
Today I learned about DangerZone from https://eclecticlight.co/2026/01/12/how-to-open-a-suspicious-document-or-app It seems to me another use for DangerZone would be for creating redactions of one's personal documents. There are many PDF editors available, but I'm leery of their ability to properly perform redactions. There's been many cases of folks being able to recover data within a supposedly redacted document. Reading that DangerZone is
makes me think this would be fantastic way for anyone to create redacted documents. It has the added bonus of removing meta data as well. Am I missing something? |
Replies: 2 comments 1 reply
|
Oh, that's a nice question! I'm afraid the answer is a bit nuanced, but I'll try my best. You're right that it's very easy to botch a document redaction. Let's take a recent example, the insufficient redaction in some of the Epstein files: https://ici.radio-canada.ca/rci/en/news/2216254/how-internet-sleuths-are-un-redacting-some-of-the-epstein-files There are two classes of redaction errors that happened in this case:
Since Dangerzone is essentially creating a photocopy of the original document (a procedure also called "flattening"), it protects you against the first class of errors. Unfortunately, it can't protect you against the second class of errors. It's just one of the things you need to be aware of. Does that make sense? Check out #763 for a suggestion to add first-class redaction support in Dangerzone, which hasn't materialized yet. |
|
There may be a bit more nuance with redactions. Some of it relies on user properly applying on redactions (e.g. if you redact a signle name, one can guess how many letters it has). And then there may be some cases where compression artifacts may reveal information about what was hidden. But using Dangerzone on top is already much better than the some of the commercial and flawed "redaction" solutions (assuming the large file sizes are acceptable). But I am no redaction expert. |
Oh, that's a nice question! I'm afraid the answer is a bit nuanced, but I'll try my best.
You're right that it's very easy to botch a document redaction. Let's take a recent example, the insufficient redaction in some of the Epstein files: https://ici.radio-canada.ca/rci/en/news/2216254/how-internet-sleuths-are-un-redacting-some-of-the-epstein-files
There are two classes of redaction errors that happened in this case: