Skip to content

Conversation

gitcommitshow
Copy link
Owner

@gitcommitshow gitcommitshow commented Sep 8, 2025

@gitcommitshow
Copy link
Owner Author

@claude what do you think

Copy link

claude bot commented Sep 8, 2025

Claude encountered an error —— View job


I'll analyze this and get back to you.

Copy link

claude bot commented Sep 8, 2025

Claude finished @gitcommitshow's task —— View job


Code Review: Claude Workflow Configuration

Todo List:

  • Read repository CLAUDE.md for guidelines
  • Examine the changed file (.github/workflows/claude.yml)
  • Check git diff to see exact changes
  • Analyze workflow changes and provide review feedback
  • Update comment with final review

Review Feedback

I've analyzed the changes to .github/workflows/claude.yml and here's my feedback:

Summary of Changes:
The PR adds custom claude_args and assignee_trigger configuration to the Claude Code Action, specifically:

  • Custom system prompt instructing Claude to use "claude-agent-" branch prefix
  • Instructions to continue working on existing branches and push changes
  • Setting assignee trigger to "claude-bot"

Positive Aspects:
Addresses the PR title: The system prompt explicitly instructs Claude to "Push your changes to the branch and verify that the branch is found" - this directly addresses the "missing to push the branch to remote" issue
Workflow continuity: The prompt handles continuing work on existing branches, which is good for iterative development
Clear branching strategy: Using "claude-agent-" prefix provides consistent branch naming

Areas of Concern:

🔶 Duplicate configuration: Lines 43 and 48 both set assignee_trigger - the second one (line 48) is commented out but creates confusion. Consider removing the commented duplicate.

🔶 System prompt formatting: The multi-line system prompt has some formatting issues:

  • Missing quotes around the multi-line string
  • Inconsistent indentation
  • The prompt should be properly formatted as YAML

🔶 Missing error handling: The system prompt asks Claude to "verify that the branch is found" but doesn't specify what to do if verification fails.

Suggested Improvements:

  1. Fix YAML formatting:
claude_args: |
  --system-prompt "Use branch prefix: claude-agent-
  If the branch already exists, continue working on it, that means you already worked on this issue, and now continue working on it and making changes and fixes.
  Push your changes to the branch and verify that the branch is found before done.
  I need you to check if the branch is live - no need for PR, make sure the branch you made and committed all the changes to is there"
  1. Remove duplicate assignee_trigger (line 48)

  2. Consider adding branch verification strategy to the system prompt

Overall Assessment:
The changes are functionally sound and address the stated problem of ensuring branches are pushed to remote. The configuration will instruct Claude to be more explicit about branch management and verification. However, some formatting cleanup would improve maintainability.

Recommendation: ✅ Approve with minor formatting fixes suggested above


Job run: https://github.com/gitcommitshow/resilient-llm/actions/runs/XXXXX
Branch: https://github.com/gitcommitshow/resilient-llm/tree/fix-claude-gh

@gitcommitshow gitcommitshow merged commit f2ea3b6 into main Sep 8, 2025
2 checks passed
@gitcommitshow gitcommitshow deleted the fix-claude-gh branch September 8, 2025 02:08
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant