Skip to content

consistency of MOI cone definitions #547

@chriscoey

Description

@chriscoey

to make it easier to remember the order of the variables in the various cone definitions, I think we should follow a convention of (epi/hypograph, perspective, argument(s)). note that a epi/hypograph variable and/or a perspective variable may not be present.

all the cones already follow this convention (though it's not immediately obvious from their names/definitions)

  • SOC: x >= norm2(z)
  • RSOC: x >= y*sumabs2(z/y)/2 (equivalent to current definition but maybe a little clearer)
  • PSD: 0 <= eigmin(Z), Z symmetric
  • Power: x >= y*abs(z/y)^q (equivalent to current definition where q = 1/exponent is positive)
  • Exponential: x <= y*log(z/y), z >= 9
  • RootDet: x <= (det(Z))^1/n, Z PSD
  • LogDet: x <= y*log(det(Z/y)), Z PSD (see logdet cone definition is wrong (needs perspective variable) #546)
  • Geomean: x <= prod(z)^1/n, z >= 0 (perhaps replace with generalized version below)
  • generalized Geomean: x <= prod_i z_i^alpha_i, z >= 0 (for alpha on unit simplex; sometimes called power cone in literature, with x or abs(x) on LHS)

so to make things clear I would recommend

  • noting the (epi/hypograph, perspective, argument(s)) ordering convention in the documentation
  • changing docs to use the less arbitrary descriptions above
  • potentially changing the names or adding name aliases for some cones, like MOI.EpiPerspSquare = MOI.RotatedSecondOrderCone (since this cone is the epigraph of the perspective of the 1/2 square function) and MOI.HypoPerspLog = MOI.ExponentialCone (since it is the (closure of the) hypograph of the perspective of the log function)

I am happy to make these non-breaking changes.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions