Skip to content

Human action 41

Jerry Holland edited this page Sep 29, 2026 · 4 revisions

Supply and review Gate B user evidence

Canonical work item: #41.

When required: Before treating Gate B as satisfied. The issue carries current status, decisions, and completion evidence.

Owner role: Maintainer and participating users.

The maintainer accepted the refreshed standing evidence record after PR #86. The assembly/review item #41 is complete. This acceptance leaves all nine Gate B conditions unproven and downstream store/protocol work gated. The procedure below remains available for future evidence reviews; closing the assembly item does not satisfy its recorded conditions.

Prerequisites: Use the nine conditions in ADR-0014/product §15, actual workflow adoption from #19, and identified hosts including Windows/OneDrive and POSIX.

  1. For each of the nine conditions, identify an actual user/workflow observation or mark the condition unmet. Include schemas, host identity, run links, repository context, outcomes, and limitations.
  2. Collect evidence of user preference, recovered squash causality, useful IDs, forecast accuracy, workspace/checkpoint benefits, safe resolution reuse, real-corpus behavior, portability limitations, and material overhead.
  3. Review the standing evidence table with the maintainer. It distinguishes actual Windows compact delivery, workspace/checkpoint use, and a clean pinned forecast/application from the still-missing sustained, conflicted, and POSIX outcomes. Record either acceptance of the table as the standing record or specific corrections on #41. Accepting a table with unmet conditions does not accept Gate B.
  4. Retain run evidence on the issue or approved artifact store and record the resulting gate assessment. #19 owns participation and user outcomes, #42 owns representative performance/budgets, and #14 owns synced-folder evidence. Do not duplicate their follow-up issues.

Verification: All nine conditions must have adequate evidence before Gate B is treated as satisfied. Documentation of an unmet condition does not clear it.

Failure handling and cleanup: Preserve unmet conditions and keep downstream gates closed. Do not infer adoption or user preference from green tests.

Completion: attach the evidence/decision to issue #41, resolve its human-action label when satisfied, update the private board, and point the Human TODO entry to the completed outcome.

Publish only evidence suitable for the public issue/wiki. Redact private paths, repository content, and credentials from shared output. Sensitive vulnerability findings belong in a draft security advisory.

Back to Human TODO · Benchmark host baselines

Clone this wiki locally