Skip to content

nullius v0.8.0

Choose a tag to compare

@github-actions github-actions released this 11 Sep 06:27
· 56 commits to main since this release

Two broken agents, an eval record that read a failure as green, and a third less prose.

The prose

  • invariants/*.md: 1,933 -> 1,158 words. Every rule survives -- the bold rules were
    diffed before and after, 39 in and 39 out, and the one genuine loss, a reviewer-proof
    paper does not exist
    , was restored. What went is the argument around each rule, which
    WHY.md and algorithms/ already carry. All four tables stay: they are the vocabulary,
    not prose. voice.md lost most (560 -> 262) and had been injecting a reference to prose,
    a command deleted two hours earlier. SessionStart on an empty project: 2,569 -> 1,794
    words
    , below where the day started.
  • README: 4,841 -> 2,542 words, twenty minutes to eleven. Twelve sections argued for one
    mechanism each. They are one table of what refuses and one paragraph of what reports; the
    arguments were already in WHY.md and algorithms/.
  • CHANGELOG: two entries at 1,413 and 811 words against a historical median near 430. A
    changelog says what changed and why it was wrong before; those re-argued the design.
  • paragraphs() treated a figure's alt text as prose. The 82-word alt text atop this
    README counted as its opening paragraph, so check called the file no short version at
    the top
    when its first sentence is thirty words. It also inflated the cross-file
    duplication count used to argue for this cut: 34 pairs measured, 11 real. The headline
    number was partly an artifact of the instrument that produced it.
  • Also cut: WHY.md section 12, which was credentials and a build order; section 5's
    table, which is warrant.md's; algorithms/README.md's prose, which was CONTRIBUTING's;
    examples/README.md's account of files that no longer exist; and
    evals/results/06-2026-09-02.md, which held two runs concatenated with a failure first.

Repository prose: 43,974 -> 39,341 words.

The machinery

A second pair of clean-context reviews, one on the prose and one on everything that is not
bin/nullius. The prose one measured what the tool's own repetition detector found when
pointed at the repository for the first time: 34 cross-file paragraph pairs sharing half
their content words or more, and a README that check reads as 4,568 words, twenty minutes,
no short version at the top.

  • agents/referee.md mandated major-revision and minor-revision. DEFAULT_SCALE is
    desk-reject / major / minor / accept, so an agent obeying its own file was refused by
    nullius verdict on every review. It now names the venue file's scale, which the same file
    said two paragraphs earlier.
  • agents/librarian.md had the screen arguments in the wrong order, documenting
    screen <search> <index> <include|exclude> where the index is a flag. An agent following it
    failed on every screening call.
  • The eval runner never truncated its output file. tee -a into a name keyed on the date
    means a same-day re-run concatenates, and results/06-2026-09-02.md is two runs in one
    file: the first ends | 8 | 1 | 0 | with a gate that should have refused and did not, the
    second ends | 9 | 0 | 0 |. A reader taking the last table read a failed run as green.
  • The bytecode check added this morning reported an untruth. It said tracked and
    globbed the working tree, so an untracked, gitignored .pyc turned preflight red on a
    clean repository. That is the 5 passed, 1 failed seen earlier today and waved away as
    transient. It was not transient. It reads git ls-files now.
  • Three byte-identical venue skeletons, and two duplicate eval results. The three
    examples/*/venues/EXAMPLE.md had the same md5 as each other and as templates/venue.md,
    which init already writes, so copying a worked field into a project overwrote a copy of
    itself. results/04- and 05-2026-09-10.md differed from their 09-02 twins by a timestamp
    and one citation count.
  • examples/README.md claimed index presets init does not pick. True for
    clinical-ml, false for the other two: FIELD_INDEXES has no key matching language
    models
    or social science.
  • About 900 words of restated argument. WHY.md section 6 was invariants/status.md with
    the column headers reworded, and section 7's boundary subsection was the third telling of
    what algorithms/critique.md carries with its parse schema. The injected files are
    canonical because they are the copy a session actually sees. The duplication was not only
    bloat: today's correction to the folklore claim reached two of the four places it was
    stated, and section 6 was still describing a citation walk that does not exist.
  • The README's Where the rest of it is section opened by saying nothing is summarised
    back here and then summarised five files for thirty-five lines.

A finding checked and rejected. The machinery review reported that PostCompact is not a
Claude Code hook event and that the entry in hooks/hooks.json is inert. It is a valid event,
per the official documentation, and it fires. The constraint re-injection that
REFERENCES.md cites chen2026 for does happen. Acting on that finding
unchecked would have deleted a working mechanism, which is the whole argument for checking.