Skip to content

v0.5.0 — debate that answers the opponent

Choose a tag to compare

@thejohnd0e thejohnd0e released this 06 Nov 22:17
· 21 commits to master since this release

Debate that answers the opponent

In debate mode the two models now have to engage with each other's arguments instead of taking turns at their own monologues.

/discuss-settings mode=debate rounds=2
  • From the second reply on, every reply starts with one or two verbatim quotes from the opponent's last reply (lines starting with >). Each quote is followed by an answer to it: rebutted with a reason, or accepted. Only then comes at most one new argument.
  • The runner checks the quotes against what the opponent actually said. Quote marks, case, punctuation, an ellipsis or a slipped word do not matter. A paraphrase, reordered words or an invented quote do not count.
  • The panel shows the result under each reply: ✓ Answers 2 points of the opponent, or a warning when a reply quoted nothing or quoted something the opponent never said. The handoff flags such replies too.
  • No extra request is made for this. cooperative and critical are unchanged.

Replies in the topic's language, for real this time

In 0.4.0 the rule "answer in the language of the topic" was written in Russian, like the built-in prompts, and one model still answered an English topic in Russian. The rule now quotes the topic, and for a topic in Latin script it is written in English ("not in Russian"). It also follows a topic change during the run.

Verified

A live debate on OpenCode 2.2.5 (DeepSeek Flash vs GPT-6 Luna, 2 rounds, conclusion by B): completed with 5 of 5 requests, $0.0013.

  • All three checked replies quoted the opponent twice, and every quote was real.
  • One side explicitly changed its position on two points it could not defend.
  • The conclusion separated what was agreed in the debate from what was still disputed.
  • Every reply and the conclusion were in English.

193 unit tests, 21 Python bridge tests and both smoke tests pass.

Next

A claim ledger (A1, B2… with open / rebutted / accepted states) and a conclusion built from it.

Full changes: v0.4.0...v0.5.0