Repository navigation
v0.6.1 — stricter quote check
A fix release for the debate quote check. No new features.
Your own words do not count as an answer, wherever they appear
In a debate, a reply must quote the opponent's points and answer them. 0.6.0 already ignored the opponent's own > quote lines. A reviewer pointed out that the same trick still worked when the opponent repeated your phrase inside their own sentence, or when a quote was "your old phrase plus a few new words".
The check now also compares every quote with the replier's own earlier replies:
- Only runs of four or more words count as borrowed, so two or three shared words never make a quote suspicious.
- A quote that is mostly (60%+) your own earlier words is not counted as an answer. The panel shows "⚠ Quotes its own words back, not the opponent's". This holds whether the opponent repeated those words in a quote line, a nested
>>quote, or inside a sentence. - A quote that borrows a substantial part (30–60%) of your words still counts, with a warning: "1 quote largely repeats its own earlier words". A doubtful quote is flagged rather than a real answer being rejected.
- Anything below that is a normal quote.
Verified without paid calls
- Saved debates. The new check was replayed on all seven saved live debates, 22 checked replies. No honest quote was flagged. The only new verdict is the known case from the review: a reply that had quoted its own earlier sentences back, now 0 counted, 2 recycled.
- Tests. Five regression tests cover a nested quote, your phrase inside the opponent's sentence, an old phrase with new words, a half-and-half quote, and an honest quote that shares a few words. 208 unit tests and 37 Python bridge tests pass.
Full changes: v0.6.0...v0.6.1