refactor: NestedSetsBehaviorTest class split into domain specific test classes.
#60
Conversation
WalkthroughThis update introduces a comprehensive suite of abstract test classes for nested set tree operations, covering node insertion, deletion, appending, prepending, state checks, cache management, extensibility, validation, and tree traversal. It also adds concrete SQLite-based test implementations. The base test infrastructure is enhanced with new utilities for deterministic tree creation, node order assertions, and query validation. Changes
Sequence Diagram(s)sequenceDiagram
participant TestCase
participant DB
participant Tree/MultipleTree
participant Node
participant Query
TestCase->>DB: createTreeStructure(structure, updates, modelClass)
DB-->>TestCase: create schema
TestCase->>Tree/MultipleTree: instantiate root node(s)
loop for each child
TestCase->>Node: createChildrenRecursively(parent, nodes)
end
opt updates
TestCase->>DB: applyUpdates(updates, tableName)
end
TestCase->>Node: refresh root node
TestCase-->>TestCase: return root node
TestCase->>Query: assertQueryHasOrderBy(query, methodName)
Query-->>TestCase: check ORDER BY lft
TestCase->>Node: assertNodesInCorrectOrder(nodesList, expectedOrder, nodeType)
Node-->>TestCase: verify count, type, order
Possibly related PRs
Poem
Warning There were issues while running some tools. Please review the errors and either fix the tool's configuration or disable the tool if it's a critical failure. 🔧 PHPStan (2.1.15)Note: Using configuration file /phpstan.neon. ✨ Finishing Touches
Thanks for using CodeRabbit! It's free for OSS, and your support helps us grow. If you like it, consider giving us a shout-out. 🪧 TipsChatThere are 3 ways to chat with CodeRabbit:
SupportNeed help? Create a ticket on our support page for assistance with any issues or questions. Note: Be mindful of the bot's finite context window. It's strongly recommended to break down tasks such as reading entire modules into smaller chunks. For a focused discussion, use review comments to chat about specific files and their changes, instead of using the PR comments. CodeRabbit Commands (Invoked using PR comments)
Other keywords and placeholders
CodeRabbit Configuration File (
|
Codecov ReportAll modified and coverable lines are covered by tests ✅
Additional details and impacted files@@ Coverage Diff @@
## main #60 +/- ##
===========================================
Coverage 100.00% 100.00%
Complexity 134 134
===========================================
Files 4 4
Lines 525 525
===========================================
Hits 525 525 ☔ View full report in Codecov by Sentry. 🚀 New features to boost your workflow:
|
![coderabbitai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/347564?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 3
🧹 Nitpick comments (6)
tests/TestCase.php (1)
227-248: Clarify the return behavior when multiple roots are created.The method returns only the first root node even when multiple roots are created from the structure array. This might be unexpected for users who create multiple roots.
Consider either:
- Documenting this behavior clearly in the PHPDoc
- Returning an array of all created roots
- Throwing an exception if multiple roots are provided
/** * Creates a tree structure based on a hierarchical definition. * * @param array $structure Hierarchical tree structure definition * @param array $updates Database updates to apply after creation * @param string $modelClass The model class to use (Tree::class or MultipleTree::class) * * @throws InvalidArgumentException if the structure array is empty. * - * @return MultipleTree|Tree The root node + * @return MultipleTree|Tree The first root node (when multiple roots are created, only the first is returned) *tests/support/AbstractConnection.php (1)
9-9: Consider using null as the default DSN value instead of an empty string.An empty string DSN would likely cause database connection errors. Using
nullas the default would be more explicit about the absence of a configured connection.- final public function __construct(public readonly string $dsn = '') {} + final public function __construct(public readonly ?string $dsn = null) {}tests/base/AbstractNodeDelete.php (1)
118-140: Consider adding verification that children are preserved in the single node delete test.The test verifies that
delete()affects exactly one row, but doesn't confirm that child nodes remain intact when deleting a parent node (as opposed todeleteWithChildren()). This could be an important distinction to verify.Consider adding an assertion to verify that child nodes are preserved:
self::assertEquals( 1, Tree::findOne(9)?->delete(), "Deleting node with ID '9' from 'Tree' should affect exactly one row.", ); + +// Verify that child nodes are preserved when using delete() instead of deleteWithChildren() +$childrenCount = Tree::find()->andWhere(['>', 'lft', 0])->count(); +self::assertGreaterThan(0, $childrenCount, "Child nodes should be preserved when using delete() instead of deleteWithChildren()");tests/base/AbstractNodePrepend.php (1)
187-238: Consider adding more descriptive variable names for clarity.While the test logic is correct, the variable names
nodeandchildOfNodecould be more descriptive to improve readability, especially when testing complex hierarchical movements.Consider using more descriptive variable names:
- $node = Tree::findOne(9); + $sourceNode = Tree::findOne(9); - $childOfNode = Tree::findOne(2); + $targetParentNode = Tree::findOne(2); - self::assertTrue( - $node->prependTo($childOfNode), + self::assertTrue( + $sourceNode->prependTo($targetParentNode),tests/base/AbstractValidationAndStructure.php (1)
119-164: Consider using a more conventional approach for testing protected methods.While the anonymous class extension works for testing protected methods, this approach may be harder to maintain and understand. Consider using reflection or creating a dedicated test helper class.
Consider using reflection for testing protected methods:
- $behavior = new class extends NestedSetsBehavior { - public function callBeforeInsertNode(int $value, int $depth): void - { - $this->beforeInsertNode($value, $depth); - } - - public function setNodeToNull(): void - { - $this->node = null; - } - - public function getNodeDepth(): int|null - { - return $this->node !== null ? $this->node->getAttribute($this->depthAttribute) : null; - } - }; + $behavior = new NestedSetsBehavior(); + $newNode = new Tree(['name' => 'Test Node']); + $newNode->attachBehavior('testBehavior', $behavior); + + // Use reflection to access protected methods and properties + $reflection = new ReflectionClass($behavior); + $nodeProperty = $reflection->getProperty('node'); + $nodeProperty->setAccessible(true); + $nodeProperty->setValue($behavior, null); + + $beforeInsertMethod = $reflection->getMethod('beforeInsertNode'); + $beforeInsertMethod->setAccessible(true); + $beforeInsertMethod->invoke($behavior, 5, 1);tests/base/AbstractNodeAppend.php (1)
7-7: Use alias for Exception to avoid confusionConsider using an alias for
yii\db\Exceptionto avoid confusion with PHP's built-in\Exceptionclass.-use yii\db\Exception; +use yii\db\Exception as DbException;Also update the catch block at line 60:
- } catch (Exception $e) { + } catch (DbException $e) {
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Plan: Pro
📒 Files selected for processing (25)
tests/TestCase.php(5 hunks)tests/base/AbstractCacheManagement.php(1 hunks)tests/base/AbstractExceptionHandling.php(1 hunks)tests/base/AbstractExtensibility.php(1 hunks)tests/base/AbstractNodeAppend.php(1 hunks)tests/base/AbstractNodeDelete.php(1 hunks)tests/base/AbstractNodeInsert.php(1 hunks)tests/base/AbstractNodePrepend.php(1 hunks)tests/base/AbstractNodeState.php(1 hunks)tests/base/AbstractQueryBehavior.php(1 hunks)tests/base/AbstractTreeTraversal.php(1 hunks)tests/base/AbstractValidationAndStructure.php(1 hunks)tests/sqlite/CacheManagementTest.php(1 hunks)tests/sqlite/ExceptionHandlingTest.php(1 hunks)tests/sqlite/ExtensibilityTest.php(1 hunks)tests/sqlite/NodeAppendTest.php(1 hunks)tests/sqlite/NodeDeleteTest.php(1 hunks)tests/sqlite/NodeInsertTest.php(1 hunks)tests/sqlite/NodePrependTest.php(1 hunks)tests/sqlite/NodeStateTest.php(1 hunks)tests/sqlite/QueryBehaviorTest.php(1 hunks)tests/sqlite/TreeTraversalTest.php(1 hunks)tests/sqlite/ValidationAndStructureTest.php(1 hunks)tests/support/AbstractConnection.php(1 hunks)tests/support/SqliteConnection.php(1 hunks)
🧰 Additional context used
🧠 Learnings (1)
📓 Common learnings
Learnt from: terabytesoftw
PR: yii2-extensions/nested-sets-behavior#13
File: src/NestedSetsBehavior.php:145-145
Timestamp: 2025-06-29T11:22:41.889Z
Learning: The user terabytesoftw prefers to keep PRs focused and small, implementing enhancements in separate dedicated PRs rather than bundling multiple changes together.
🧬 Code Graph Analysis (11)
tests/sqlite/NodeDeleteTest.php (1)
tests/base/AbstractNodeDelete.php (1)
AbstractNodeDelete(12-158)
tests/sqlite/QueryBehaviorTest.php (11)
tests/sqlite/CacheManagementTest.php (1)
Group(10-14)tests/sqlite/ExtensibilityTest.php (1)
Group(10-14)tests/sqlite/ExceptionHandlingTest.php (1)
Group(10-14)tests/sqlite/NodeAppendTest.php (1)
Group(10-14)tests/sqlite/NodeDeleteTest.php (1)
Group(10-14)tests/sqlite/NodePrependTest.php (1)
Group(10-14)tests/sqlite/NodeStateTest.php (1)
Group(10-14)tests/sqlite/TreeTraversalTest.php (1)
Group(10-14)tests/sqlite/NodeInsertTest.php (1)
Group(10-14)tests/sqlite/ValidationAndStructureTest.php (1)
Group(10-14)tests/base/AbstractQueryBehavior.php (1)
AbstractQueryBehavior(13-235)
tests/sqlite/TreeTraversalTest.php (1)
tests/base/AbstractTreeTraversal.php (1)
AbstractTreeTraversal(16-207)
tests/sqlite/NodeStateTest.php (1)
tests/base/AbstractNodeState.php (1)
AbstractNodeState(11-124)
tests/sqlite/NodeInsertTest.php (1)
tests/base/AbstractNodeInsert.php (1)
AbstractNodeInsert(10-473)
tests/support/SqliteConnection.php (1)
tests/support/AbstractConnection.php (1)
AbstractConnection(7-10)
tests/base/AbstractQueryBehavior.php (4)
src/NestedSetsQueryBehavior.php (1)
NestedSetsQueryBehavior(36-144)tests/support/model/Tree.php (1)
Tree(17-64)tests/support/model/TreeQuery.php (1)
TreeQuery(15-32)tests/TestCase.php (1)
TestCase(38-411)
tests/sqlite/ValidationAndStructureTest.php (11)
tests/sqlite/CacheManagementTest.php (1)
Group(10-14)tests/sqlite/ExtensibilityTest.php (1)
Group(10-14)tests/sqlite/ExceptionHandlingTest.php (1)
Group(10-14)tests/sqlite/NodeAppendTest.php (1)
Group(10-14)tests/sqlite/NodeDeleteTest.php (1)
Group(10-14)tests/sqlite/NodePrependTest.php (1)
Group(10-14)tests/sqlite/NodeStateTest.php (1)
Group(10-14)tests/sqlite/QueryBehaviorTest.php (1)
Group(10-14)tests/sqlite/TreeTraversalTest.php (1)
Group(10-14)tests/sqlite/NodeInsertTest.php (1)
Group(10-14)tests/base/AbstractValidationAndStructure.php (1)
AbstractValidationAndStructure(11-165)
tests/base/AbstractNodeDelete.php (5)
tests/support/model/MultipleTree.php (1)
MultipleTree(18-59)tests/support/model/Tree.php (2)
Tree(17-64)isTransactional(34-41)tests/TestCase.php (6)
TestCase(38-411)createDatabase(165-199)generateFixtureTree(251-285)loadFixtureXML(326-343)buildFlatXMLDataSet(122-163)getDataSet(292-308)tests/base/AbstractExceptionHandling.php (1)
makeRoot(315-318)src/NestedSetsBehavior.php (1)
deleteWithChildren(527-532)
tests/base/AbstractTreeTraversal.php (4)
tests/support/model/MultipleTree.php (1)
MultipleTree(18-59)tests/support/model/Tree.php (1)
Tree(17-64)tests/TestCase.php (5)
TestCase(38-411)createTreeStructure(216-249)assertNodesInCorrectOrder(67-90)assertQueryHasOrderBy(100-115)generateFixtureTree(251-285)src/NestedSetsBehavior.php (4)
children(483-503)parents(922-943)next(878-888)prev(1010-1020)
tests/base/AbstractExtensibility.php (3)
tests/support/model/ExtendableMultipleTree.php (1)
ExtendableMultipleTree(18-59)tests/support/stub/ExtendableNestedSetsBehavior.php (7)
ExtendableNestedSetsBehavior(15-97)exposedBeforeInsertNode(23-28)wasMethodCalled(93-96)exposedBeforeInsertRootNode(30-35)exposedMoveNodeAsRoot(49-54)exposedMoveNode(37-47)exposedShiftLeftRightAttribute(56-61)tests/TestCase.php (2)
TestCase(38-411)createDatabase(165-199)
⏰ Context from checks skipped due to timeout of 90000ms (11)
- GitHub Check: phpunit-compatibility / PHP 8.3-windows-latest
- GitHub Check: phpunit-compatibility / PHP 8.4-windows-latest
- GitHub Check: phpunit-compatibility / PHP 8.1-windows-latest
- GitHub Check: phpunit-compatibility / PHP 8.2-windows-latest
- GitHub Check: phpunit / PHP 8.2-ubuntu-latest
- GitHub Check: phpunit / PHP 8.4-windows-latest
- GitHub Check: phpunit / PHP 8.3-windows-latest
- GitHub Check: phpunit / PHP 8.1-windows-latest
- GitHub Check: mutation / PHP 8.4-ubuntu-latest
- GitHub Check: phpunit / PHP 8.2-windows-latest
- GitHub Check: mutation / PHP 8.4-ubuntu-latest
🔇 Additional comments (35)
tests/sqlite/ExtensibilityTest.php (1)
10-14: LGTM!The SQLite test implementation follows the established pattern correctly, extending the abstract base class and configuring the in-memory SQLite DSN.
tests/sqlite/NodePrependTest.php (1)
10-14: LGTM!The SQLite test implementation correctly extends the abstract base class and configures the in-memory SQLite DSN.
tests/sqlite/ExceptionHandlingTest.php (1)
10-14: LGTM!The SQLite test implementation properly extends the abstract base class and configures the in-memory SQLite DSN.
tests/sqlite/QueryBehaviorTest.php (1)
1-14: LGTM! Follows the established SQLite test pattern perfectly.This class correctly extends the abstract base class and configures the SQLite DSN for database-specific testing. The structure is consistent with other SQLite test classes in the suite.
tests/sqlite/NodeStateTest.php (1)
1-14: LGTM! Consistent implementation following the SQLite test pattern.The class structure and configuration are identical to other SQLite test classes, properly extending
AbstractNodeStateand setting up the SQLite DSN.tests/sqlite/CacheManagementTest.php (1)
1-14: LGTM! Maintains the consistent SQLite test class pattern.The implementation correctly extends
AbstractCacheManagementand follows the established pattern for SQLite-specific test configuration.tests/sqlite/NodeDeleteTest.php (1)
1-14: LGTM! Follows the established SQLite test pattern consistently.The class properly extends
AbstractNodeDeleteand maintains the same structure and configuration as other SQLite test classes in the suite.tests/sqlite/NodeAppendTest.php (1)
1-14: LGTM! Excellent consistency across the SQLite test suite.This final class completes the pattern established by the other SQLite test classes, properly extending
AbstractNodeAppendand maintaining the same clean structure and configuration approach throughout the entire test suite.tests/sqlite/NodeInsertTest.php (1)
1-14: Clean implementation following established pattern.The class correctly extends the abstract base test class and configures the SQLite in-memory database. The implementation is minimal and focused, which aligns well with the refactoring objective of splitting the monolithic test class into domain-specific classes.
tests/sqlite/TreeTraversalTest.php (1)
1-14: Excellent adherence to the established pattern.The class correctly implements the SQLite-specific test configuration for tree traversal functionality. The naming is descriptive and the implementation is consistent with the refactoring strategy.
tests/support/SqliteConnection.php (1)
7-13: Well-implemented factory pattern for SQLite connections.The static factory method provides a clean interface for creating SQLite connections with the appropriate DSN. The implementation is concise and follows good object-oriented design principles.
tests/sqlite/ValidationAndStructureTest.php (1)
1-14: Consistent implementation for validation and structure testing.The class correctly follows the established pattern and provides SQLite-specific configuration for validation and structure tests. The implementation supports the goal of modular, domain-specific test organization.
tests/base/AbstractQueryBehavior.php (8)
5-11: Proper namespace and import organization for abstract base class.The namespace change to
tests\basecorrectly reflects the new role as an abstract base class. The grouped imports are well-organized and include all necessary dependencies.
13-13: Appropriate class abstraction for the refactoring.The conversion from concrete to abstract class is the correct approach for creating reusable test logic that can be extended by database-specific implementations.
15-79: Comprehensive test for leaf node ordering requirements.The test correctly validates that the
leaves()method requires proper ordering by the left attribute. The test setup, manipulation of left/right values, and assertions are well-structured and thorough.
81-95: Effective fixture-based testing for multiple tree models.The test properly validates leaf node retrieval for both single and multiple tree models using fixture data. The assertions provide clear error messages for debugging.
97-111: Thorough testing of root node retrieval.The test validates root node functionality for both Tree and MultipleTree models using fixture data, ensuring consistent behavior across different tree implementations.
113-161: Detailed validation of ordering requirements.The test thoroughly validates that the
roots()method includes proper ORDER BY clauses and returns correctly ordered results. The SQL inspection and result validation are comprehensive.
163-206: Excellent test for tree traversal ordering.The test creates multiple root nodes, manipulates their tree IDs, and validates that the traversal returns nodes in the correct order. The test logic is sound and the assertions are descriptive.
208-234: Proper exception handling validation.Both test methods correctly validate that
LogicExceptionis thrown when the behavior is not properly attached to an owner. The exception message validation ensures consistent error reporting.tests/base/AbstractNodeDelete.php (2)
14-53: LGTM! Well-structured test for node state after deletion.The test properly verifies that
deleteWithChildren()correctly updates the node's internal state by checkingisNewRecordandoldAttributesbefore and after deletion. Good use of descriptive assertion messages.
79-112: Good test coverage for beforeDelete() abortion scenario.The test correctly uses a partial mock to simulate
beforeDelete()returning false and verifies thatdeleteWithChildren()properly aborts the operation. The assertions are comprehensive and the test scenario is realistic.tests/base/AbstractTreeTraversal.php (3)
18-37: Excellent test design for ensuring deterministic ordering.The test creates a tree structure with intentionally mixed ordering in the fixture, then applies updates to create a specific left-right ordering. This effectively verifies that the
children()method returns nodes in the correct order based on thelftattribute rather than insertion order.
39-62: Good verification of ORDER BY clause requirement.The test properly uses
assertQueryHasOrderBy()to verify that the SQL query includes the necessary ORDER BY clause, then validates the actual results. This ensures both the query structure and the results are correct.
108-132: Comprehensive fixture-based testing with depth parameter support.The test covers both Tree and MultipleTree models with and without depth constraints. Using external fixture files allows for complex test scenarios without cluttering the test code. The assertions include clear error messages for debugging.
tests/base/AbstractNodeState.php (3)
13-34: Excellent boundary condition testing for nested set logic.The test correctly verifies that
isChildOf()returns false when left values are equal, which is crucial for the nested set model's boundary conditions. The attribute restoration ensures the test doesn't affect other tests.
36-57: Good complementary test for right boundary condition.This test pairs well with the left boundary test to ensure both sides of the nested set boundary logic are properly validated. The test structure mirrors the previous test which maintains consistency.
73-115: Comprehensive testing of ancestor relationships in multiple tree.The test thoroughly validates the
isChildOf()method across various ancestor-descendant relationships in a MultipleTree model. The test cases cover both positive and negative scenarios, ensuring the method correctly identifies valid parent-child relationships.tests/base/AbstractNodePrepend.php (2)
12-60: Excellent validation behavior testing with clear assertions.The test thoroughly verifies both validation scenarios - when validation fails and when it's bypassed. The assertions clearly distinguish between the expected behaviors, and the use of
TreeWithStrictValidationmakes the test intent clear.
115-146: Good test coverage for cross-tree movement in MultipleTree.The test properly verifies that nodes can be moved between different trees in a MultipleTree model. Using
getDataSetMultipleTree()specifically for MultipleTree validation shows attention to model-specific behavior.tests/base/AbstractValidationAndStructure.php (2)
13-71: Comprehensive validation testing with good coverage.The test thoroughly verifies
makeRoot()behavior with and without validation, including proper persistence verification and nested set attribute validation. The assertions cover all important aspects of the operation.
73-117: Good verification of nested set mathematics.The test properly verifies that left and right attributes are correctly calculated when appending a child to a root node. The specific value assertions (1,4 for root and 2,3 for child) demonstrate understanding of nested set model mechanics.
tests/base/AbstractNodeInsert.php (1)
1-473: LGTM! Comprehensive test coverage for node insertion operations.The abstract test class is well-structured with thorough coverage of insertion scenarios including validation handling, cross-tree operations, and various positioning cases. The assertions are clear and meaningful.
tests/base/AbstractCacheManagement.php (1)
1-609: LGTM! Thorough cache management and memoization testing.The abstract test class provides excellent coverage of cache invalidation scenarios and memoization behavior. Good use of the Assert helper for testing private properties and effective mocking for memoization tests.
tests/base/AbstractExceptionHandling.php (1)
1-483: LGTM! Excellent exception handling test coverage.The abstract test class thoroughly covers all exception scenarios with specific error messages. Good use of anonymous class for edge case testing and comprehensive coverage of different exception types.
…ove unused connection classes.
…actExtensibility`.
|
@coderabbitai review |
✅ Actions performedReview triggered.
|
|
@coderabbitai review |
✅ Actions performedReview triggered.
|
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
🧹 Nitpick comments (5)
tests/base/AbstractExtensibility.php (5)
13-53: Test logic is correct but consider extracting common setup.The test correctly verifies that the protected
beforeInsertNodemethod remains accessible to subclasses and properly sets node attributes. The assertions validate both method invocation and state changes.However, there's significant code duplication across test methods that could be refactored.
Consider extracting common setup into a helper method:
+ private function createTestNodeWithBehavior(string $name, int $tree): array + { + $this->createDatabase(); + + $testNode = new ExtendableMultipleTree([ + 'name' => $name, + 'tree' => $tree, + ]); + + $behavior = $testNode->getBehavior('nestedSetsBehavior'); + + self::assertInstanceOf( + ExtendableNestedSetsBehavior::class, + $behavior, + "'ExtendableMultipleTree' should use 'ExtendableNestedSetsBehavior'.", + ); + + return [$testNode, $behavior]; + }Then refactor the test:
public function testProtectedBeforeInsertNodeRemainsAccessibleToSubclasses(): void { - $this->createDatabase(); - - $testNode = new ExtendableMultipleTree( - [ - 'name' => 'Extensibility Test Node', - 'tree' => 1, - ], - ); - - $extendableBehavior = $testNode->getBehavior('nestedSetsBehavior'); - - self::assertInstanceOf( - ExtendableNestedSetsBehavior::class, - $extendableBehavior, - "'ExtendableMultipleTree' should use 'ExtendableNestedSetsBehavior'.", - ); + [$testNode, $extendableBehavior] = $this->createTestNodeWithBehavior('Extensibility Test Node', 1);
55-96: Test implementation is solid but follows duplicated pattern.The test correctly verifies the
beforeInsertRootNodemethod's accessibility and proper attribute setting for root nodes. The assertions are comprehensive and validate the expected root node state (lft=1, rgt=2, depth=0).This test follows the same duplicated setup pattern as the previous test. Consider using the helper method suggested above to reduce code duplication.
98-124: Test correctly verifies method accessibility but lacks state assertions.The test properly verifies that
moveNodeAsRootremains accessible to subclasses. However, unlike other tests, it only asserts method invocation without validating the resulting state changes.Consider adding assertions to verify the state changes after moving a node as root:
self::assertTrue( $sourceBehavior->wasMethodCalled('moveNodeAsRoot'), "'moveNodeAsRoot()' method should remain protected to allow subclass customization.", ); + + // Verify the node is properly set as root + self::assertEquals(1, $sourceNode->lft, "Root node should have left value of 1"); + self::assertEquals(2, $sourceNode->rgt, "Root node should have right value of 2"); + self::assertEquals(0, $sourceNode->depth, "Root node should have depth of 0");
126-161: Test setup is more complex but lacks meaningful state assertions.The test creates a proper parent-child relationship and verifies method accessibility. However, it doesn't validate the actual effects of the
moveNodeoperation, making it less comprehensive than other tests.Consider adding assertions to verify the node movement effects:
self::assertTrue( $sourceBehavior->wasMethodCalled('moveNode'), "'moveNode()' should remain protected to allow subclass customization.", ); + + // Verify the node positions after movement + self::assertEquals(5, $sourceNode->lft, "Source node should be moved to expected left position"); + self::assertEquals(2, $sourceNode->depth, "Source node should be at expected depth");
163-198: Test verifies method accessibility but could benefit from state validation.The test properly sets up a parent-child relationship and verifies that
shiftLeftRightAttributeremains accessible. However, it only checks method invocation without validating the attribute shifting effects.Consider adding assertions to verify the attribute shifting effects:
self::assertTrue( $childBehavior->wasMethodCalled('shiftLeftRightAttribute'), "'shiftLeftRightAttribute()' should remain protected to allow subclass customization.", ); + + // Store original values before shift for comparison + $originalLft = $childNode->lft; + $originalRgt = $childNode->rgt; + + // Verify attributes were shifted by the expected amount + // This would require refreshing the model or checking the actual shift effect
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Plan: Pro
📒 Files selected for processing (1)
tests/base/AbstractExtensibility.php(1 hunks)
🧰 Additional context used
🧠 Learnings (1)
📓 Common learnings
Learnt from: terabytesoftw
PR: yii2-extensions/nested-sets-behavior#13
File: src/NestedSetsBehavior.php:145-145
Timestamp: 2025-06-29T11:22:41.889Z
Learning: The user terabytesoftw prefers to keep PRs focused and small, implementing enhancements in separate dedicated PRs rather than bundling multiple changes together.
🔇 Additional comments (1)
tests/base/AbstractExtensibility.php (1)
1-12: LGTM! Clean class structure and appropriate imports.The class declaration, namespace, and imports are well-structured. The abstract class appropriately extends
TestCaseand imports the necessary classes for testing extensibility.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Pull Request Overview
This PR refactors the test suite by splitting the monolithic NestedSetsBehaviorTest into domain-specific test classes for SQLite and enhancing the base testing infrastructure with reusable helpers and configurable DSN support.
- Added SQLite-specific final test classes extending new abstract base test suites, each setting an in-memory DSN.
- Refactored query behavior test into an abstract base class and aligned test namespaces under
tests/base. - Extended
TestCasewith a$dsnproperty, dynamic console app mocking, tree-structure builders, and new assertion helpers.
Reviewed Changes
Copilot reviewed 23 out of 24 changed files in this pull request and generated 2 comments.
Show a summary per file
| File | Description |
|---|---|
| tests/sqlite/ValidationAndStructureTest.php | Added final class for validation/structure tests on SQLite, setting its DSN. |
| tests/sqlite/TreeTraversalTest.php | Added final class for traversal tests on SQLite, setting its DSN. |
| tests/sqlite/QueryBehaviorTest.php | Added final class for query behavior tests on SQLite, setting its DSN. |
| tests/sqlite/NodeStateTest.php | Added final class for node-state tests on SQLite, setting its DSN. |
| tests/sqlite/NodePrependTest.php | Added final class for prepend-to tests on SQLite, setting its DSN. |
| tests/sqlite/NodeInsertTest.php | Added final class for insert tests on SQLite, setting its DSN. |
| tests/sqlite/NodeDeleteTest.php | Added final class for delete-with-children tests on SQLite, setting its DSN. |
| tests/sqlite/NodeAppendTest.php | Added final class for append-to tests on SQLite, setting its DSN. |
| tests/sqlite/ExtensibilityTest.php | Added final class for extensibility tests on SQLite, setting its DSN. |
| tests/sqlite/ExceptionHandlingTest.php | Added final class for exception-handling tests on SQLite, setting its DSN. |
| tests/sqlite/CacheManagementTest.php | Added final class for cache-management tests on SQLite, setting its DSN. |
| tests/base/AbstractValidationAndStructure.php | Introduced abstract base for validation/structure test logic. |
| tests/base/AbstractTreeTraversal.php | Introduced abstract base for traversal-related tests and new phpstan types. |
| tests/base/AbstractQueryBehavior.php | Refactored concrete query behavior test into an abstract base with proper namespace. |
| tests/base/AbstractNodeState.php | Introduced abstract base for node-state tests. |
| tests/base/AbstractNodePrepend.php | Introduced abstract base for prepend-to tests. |
| tests/base/AbstractNodeInsert.php | Introduced abstract base for insert-after/before tests. |
| tests/base/AbstractNodeDelete.php | Introduced abstract base for delete-with-children tests. |
| tests/base/AbstractNodeAppend.php | Introduced abstract base for append-to tests. |
| tests/base/AbstractExtensibility.php | Introduced abstract base for extensibility tests. |
| tests/base/AbstractExceptionHandling.php | Introduced abstract base for exception-handling tests. |
| tests/base/AbstractCacheManagement.php | Introduced abstract base for cache-management tests. |
| tests/TestCase.php | Enhanced TestCase with $dsn, console-app mocking, helpers for tree creation, updates, and assertions. |
Comments suppressed due to low confidence (1)
tests/TestCase.php:216
- [nitpick] The method accepts multiple root definitions but returns only the first created root; it may be helpful to document this behavior or adjust the return to better match its capabilities.
protected function createTreeStructure(
2 participants
Summary by CodeRabbit
New Features
Tests