Sorting pages between chapters does not work

[Eichiwolf]

Describe the Bug

Trying to move pages from one chapter to another within a book fails without error for every user other than the global administrator.

However sorting pages within a chapter does work just fine

Steps to Reproduce

Enter Sort mode as user.
Drag page to another chapter.
Click 'Save'
BookStack reports "Book successfully re-sorted"

-> Changes are not saved

Expected Behaviour

Pages are moved to another chapter or outside a chapter

Screenshots or Additional Context

Permissions given to the user role on book level:

• View
• Create
• Update

System Permissions: none
Asset Permissions:

Tried on production environment with NGINX proxy and fresh install without proxy

Browser Details

No response

Exact BookStack Version

v22.10.2

PHP Version

8.0.25

Hosting Environment

Docker Compose from Linuxserver.io
MariaDB 10.6.10

[ssddanbrown]

Hi @Eichiwolf, This is likely related to #1200 and #3813.

The permissions involved in sorting are quite complex, and changes are assessed on a per-items basis, where the changes are allowed or not on per-item permissions.

Therefore, I'd imagine you're not seeing changes due to lacking permissions right now.
Based on the shared permissions, I'm guessing is lack of "Delete" permissions. Moving an item out of its original location currently requires "Delete" permission for that item.

[Eichiwolf]

Oh that was it, thanks.
I think i tried granting every permission other than that before opening the issue.
A bit unfortunate since we planned on not giving every user delete permissions, but it'll do for now.