Join GitHub today
GitHub is home to over 40 million developers working together to host and review code, manage projects, and build software together.Sign up
Review Request: Metzner #30
I request a review for the following replication:
Title: Modeling GABA alterations in schizophrenia: a link between impaired inhibition and altered gamma and beta range auditory entrainment
Author(s): Christoph Metzner
@oliviaguest The one who asks
@aaronshifman Regarding your other comments:
@ChristophMetzner Thank you for your last commits and for your comments. Regarding the last point you raise in your comments, on exploring the discrepancies, I agree with you, and, although interesting and welcome, I do not find it strictly necessary to investigate further possible reasons for discrepancy, given that the main results have been replicated.
I think two figures per page is nicer, if they could fit nicely and be readable. I still find it suboptimal to have several pages of figures that completely break off the text, but I don't have an immediate solution for that.
I have one more tiny aesthetic comment: in
I will be on holiday and with limited access to internet from next week. My overall recommendation at this point in time is that the replication (with a few smaller edits) should be accepted.
Hello @ChristophMetzner, I apologize for the delay in the review. I appreciate your addressing my comments and I have no further scientific issues.
My only issues are a few typos / omissions
I agree with @pietromarchesi that the disjointed figures aren't the best option however I don't have a better option and it seems to be that the style that the figure layout isn't nearly as important as the replication itself.
Given this, I move to accept this paper (conditional on these small editorial changes).