Review Request: R. Shimoura et. al.

README.md

@@ -3,6 +3,20 @@
 
 This is the submission repository for the [Re**Science** journal](https://rescience.github.io).
 
+
+### Reference implementation of: 
+
+> The cell-type specific cortical microcircuit: relating structure and activity in a full-scale spiking network model. (2014)
+
+The source code is written in Python (version 2.7.5) Brian (version 2.0.1) using Numpy (version
+1.11.1) Pandas (version 0.19.2) and Matplotlib (version 2.0.0).
+
+* **article** -> This folder contains the accompanying text.
+* **code** -> Here is the source code.
+* **data** -> This folder is empty. 
+* **notebook** -> There is no notebook for this implementation. 
+
+
 ### How to submit an article ?
 
 
@@ -36,56 +50,21 @@ This is the submission repository for the [Re**Science** journal](https://rescie
    $ git push origin AUTHOR1-AUTHOR2
    ```
 
-7. Issue a [pull request](https://help.github.com/articles/using-pull-requests/) (PR) to Re**Science** with title containing author(s) name and follow the template that will appear once you opened the pull request:
+7. Issue a [pull request](https://help.github.com/articles/using-pull-requests/) (PR) to Re**Science** with title "Review Request" and insert the following text in the description:
 
   ```
   **AUTHOR**
 
   Dear @ReScience/editors,
 
-  I request a review for the following replication:
-
-  ### Original article
-
-  **Title:**  
-  **Author(s):**  
-  **Journal (or Conference):**  
-  **Year:**  
-  **DOI:**  
-  **PDF:**   
+  I request a review for the reproduction of the following paper:
 
-  ### Replication
+  * References of the paper holding results you're replicating
 
-  **Author(s)**:   
-  **Repository**:  
-  **PDF**:  
-  **Keywords**:  
-  **Language**:  
-  **Domain**:  
-
-  ### Results
-
-  * [ ] Article has been fully replicated
-  * [ ] Article has been partially replicated
-  * [ ] Article has not been replicated
-
-  ### Potential reviewers
-  <!-- If you know potential reviewers, you can tell us here -->
-  <!-- You can look at http://rescience.github.io/board for the -->
-  <!-- list of registered reviewers (but you can propose others) -->
-
-  ---
-
-  **EDITOR**
-
-  * [ ] Editor acknowledgment
-  * [ ] Reviewer 1 
-  * [ ] Reviewer 2
-  * [ ] Review 1 decision [accept/reject]
-  * [ ] Review 2 decision [accept/reject]
-  * [ ] Editor decision [accept/reject]
+  I believe the original results have been faithfully reproduced as explained in the accompanying article.
   ```
 
-8. You can suggest reviewers from [editorial board](https://rescience.github.io/board).
+8. Assign the PR to an editor from the [editorial board](https://rescience.github.io/board).
 
 9. Answer questions and requests made in the PR conversation page.
+

article/README.md

@@ -1,32 +1,12 @@
-### Important
-
-Don't forget to change the name of the Name-YEAR file to reflect all the
-authors name and the current year.
-
-### Required tools for producing the pdf
-
-You'll need [pandoc](http://pandoc.org) (a universal document converter) and a
-full [TeX distribution](https://www.tug.org/texlive/).
-
-For pandoc, you'll also need the
-[pandoc-crossref](https://github.com/lierdakil/pandoc-crossref) filter that you can
-easily install with:
-
-```
-$ cabal update
-$ cabal install pandoc-crossref
-```
-
 ### How to build the PDF ?
 
 In a console, type:
 
 ```
-pandoc --standalone --filter ~/.cabal/bin/pandoc-crossref --template=rescience-template.tex --latex-engine=xelatex --biblatex --bibliography=bibliography.bib -M "crossrefYaml=crossref.yaml" --output Name-YEAR.tex Name-YEAR.md
-xelatex Name-YEAR
-biber Name-YEAR
-xelatex Name-YEAR
-xelatex Name-YEAR
+xelatex ShimouraR-KamijiNL-PenaRFO-CordeiroVL-CeballosCC-RomaroC-RoqueAC-2017
+biber ShimouraR-KamijiNL-PenaRFO-CordeiroVL-CeballosCC-RomaroC-RoqueAC-2017
+xelatex ShimouraR-KamijiNL-PenaRFO-CordeiroVL-CeballosCC-RomaroC-RoqueAC-2017
+xelatex ShimouraR-KamijiNL-PenaRFO-CordeiroVL-CeballosCC-RomaroC-RoqueAC-2017
 ```
 
-Alternativaley, you can also type `make` after having edited the Makefile.
+Alternativaley, you can place all files in an Overleaf project.