Review Request: R. Shimoura et. al.

[shimoura]

AUTHOR

Dear @ReScience/editors,

I request a review for the replication of the following paper:

• The cell-type specific cortical microcircuit: relating structure and activity in a full-scale spiking network model, T.C. Potjans, M. Diesmann, Cerebral Cortex, 24 (3): 785-806, 2014. DOI: 10.1093/cercor/bhs358

I believed the original results have been faithfully replicated
as explained in the accompanying article.

Repository lives at https://github.com/shimoura/ReScience-submission.git

Potential reviewer: @mstimberg

---

EDITOR

• Editor acknowledgment ()
• Reviewer 1 ()
• Reviewer 2 ()
• Review 1 decision [accept/reject]
• Review 2 decision [accept/reject]
• Editor decision [accept/reject]

[sje30]

I get a 404 on the article link in the original comment; is it just me?

[mstimberg]

I get a 404 on the article link in the original comment; is it just me?

The authors closed this PR, there's a new one (#43) with a working link to the article.

[shimoura]

@sje30 Sorry for that. I had to change the name of the branch because the authors was in the wrong order. I'm new using github, and the way I found to do this was closing the old version and creating a new PR.