docs(requirements): create missing system stakeholder requirements an…

[muhabalwan-aginx]

…d establish traceability

[github-actions]

Claude finished @muhabalwan-aginx's task —— View job

---

PR Review Complete ✅

I've completed my review of this documentation PR. This is a documentation-only change focused on correcting requirement types and cleaning up traceability links.

---

Summary

This PR makes minimal but important corrections to requirements documentation and specification traceability:

1. Requirement Type Corrections (2 files): Changed requirement type from QUALITY to ENVIRONMENT for two system stakeholder requirements
2. Traceability Cleanup (3 files): Removed obsolete requirement IDs from itemFulfills metadata in three specifications

Overall Assessment: ✅ APPROVED - These are valid documentation corrections that improve accuracy and maintainability.

---

Detailed Analysis

1. Requirement Type Changes ✅

Files Modified:

• requirements/SHR-SYSTEM-1.md
• requirements/SHR-SYSTEM-2.md

Change: Requirement type: QUALITY → Requirement type: ENVIRONMENT

Analysis:

• SHR-SYSTEM-1 (System Health Monitoring and Observability): Correctly categorized as ENVIRONMENT - this is about the operational environment and runtime monitoring capabilities, not inherent quality attributes of the code.
• SHR-SYSTEM-2 (Sensitive Data Privacy and Access Control): Correctly categorized as ENVIRONMENT - this concerns deployment environment configuration and runtime access controls, not intrinsic quality measures.

Verdict: ✅ These corrections align with proper requirements classification. Health monitoring and privacy controls are environment/deployment concerns rather than quality attributes.

---

2. Traceability Cleanup ✅

Files Modified:

• specifications/SPEC-UTILS-SERVICE.md
• specifications/SPEC_GUI_SERVICE.md
• specifications/SPEC_SYSTEM_SERVICE.md

Changes: Removed these requirement IDs from itemFulfills metadata:

• SWR-SYSTEM-CLI-HEALTH-1 (removed from 2 specs)
• SWR-SYSTEM-GUI-HEALTH-1 (removed from 2 specs)
• SWR-SYSTEM-GUI-SETTINGS-1 (removed from 2 specs)
• SHR-APPLICATION-1 (removed from GUI spec)

Remaining Traceability:
All three specifications now fulfill only:

• SHR-SYSTEM-1 (System Health Monitoring and Observability)
• SHR-SYSTEM-2 (Sensitive Data Privacy and Access Control)

Analysis:
The removed requirement IDs appear to be obsolete/deleted requirements that were previously tracked. The cleanup ensures that:

1. Only valid, existing requirements are referenced in traceability
2. The specifications focus on the two core system stakeholder requirements
3. Dead links are removed from the requirements traceability matrix

Verdict: ✅ Valid cleanup that maintains accurate traceability links.

---

Quality Checks

✅ Conventional Commits

docs(requirements): create missing system stakeholder requirements and establish traceability

• Type: docs ✅ Correct for documentation changes
• Scope: requirements ✅ Appropriate scope
• Description: Clear and descriptive ✅

✅ No Code Changes

This PR only modifies markdown documentation files in requirements/ and specifications/ directories. No source code, tests, or CI/CD files were modified.

✅ Documentation Standards

All modified files maintain proper YAML frontmatter format:

---
itemId: SHR-SYSTEM-1
itemTitle: System Health Monitoring and Observability
itemType: Requirement
Requirement type: ENVIRONMENT  # Changed from QUALITY
---

✅ No Breaking Changes

These are documentation corrections with no impact on:

• SDK functionality
• API contracts
• User-facing behavior
• Test requirements
• CI/CD pipelines

---

Recommendations

1. Consider Adding Context in PR Description

The PR title mentions "create missing system stakeholder requirements" but the actual changes are:

• Correcting requirement types for existing requirements
• Cleaning up obsolete traceability links

Suggestion: Update the PR description to clarify:

## Changes
1. Corrected requirement type classification for SHR-SYSTEM-1 and SHR-SYSTEM-2 from QUALITY to ENVIRONMENT
2. Removed obsolete requirement IDs from specification traceability (SWR-SYSTEM-CLI-HEALTH-1, SWR-SYSTEM-GUI-HEALTH-1, SWR-SYSTEM-GUI-SETTINGS-1, SHR-APPLICATION-1)
3. Simplified itemFulfills to only include valid system stakeholder requirements

## Rationale
- Health monitoring and privacy controls are environment/deployment concerns, not quality attributes
- Removed dead links to deleted/obsolete requirements
- Improves accuracy of requirements traceability matrix

2. Verify Deleted Requirements Documentation

If SWR-SYSTEM-CLI-HEALTH-1, SWR-SYSTEM-GUI-HEALTH-1, SWR-SYSTEM-GUI-SETTINGS-1, and SHR-APPLICATION-1 were intentionally deleted/obsoleted, consider:

• Adding a CHANGELOG or migration note explaining why they were removed
• Ensuring no other specifications reference these obsolete IDs

3. Requirements Traceability Validation (Optional)

Consider adding a pre-commit hook or CI check that validates:

• All requirement IDs in itemFulfills fields reference existing requirement files
• All specifications have at least one valid requirement traceability link
• No broken traceability references exist

---

Final Verdict

✅ APPROVED - This PR makes valid documentation corrections that improve requirements accuracy and traceability hygiene.

Impact: Low risk, documentation-only changes
Testing: No testing required (no code changes)
Merge Readiness: Ready to merge after addressing the PR description clarification suggestion (optional but recommended)

---

Great work on maintaining requirements traceability! These types of documentation hygiene tasks are essential for medical device software compliance and long-term maintainability.

[codecov]

Codecov Report

✅ All modified and coverable lines are covered by tests.
✅ All tests successful. No failed tests found.

[sonarqubecloud]

Quality Gate passed

Issues
0 New issues
0 Accepted issues

Measures
0 Security Hotspots
0.0% Coverage on New Code
0.0% Duplication on New Code

See analysis details on SonarQube Cloud