Ambient breakdown sessions handler

[sallyom]

@Gkrumbach07 I'm testing now :)

[github-actions]

Pull Request Review: Backend Refactor - Breaking Down Large Handler Files

Overview

This PR implements a significant refactoring of the backend handlers, breaking down two massive files (sessions.go at 2562 lines and rfe.go at 1208 lines) into smaller, more maintainable, single-responsibility modules. This is an excellent architectural improvement that aligns with Go best practices.

---

✅ Strengths

1. Excellent Code Organization

The file breakdown follows clear separation of concerns:

Sessions Module (formerly sessions.go):

• sessions_crud.go - CRUD operations
• sessions_control.go - Control operations (pause, resume, stop)
• sessions_git.go - Git operations
• sessions_k8s.go - Kubernetes resource management
• sessions_workspace.go - Workspace management
• sessions_types.go - Type definitions and package variables

RFE Module (formerly rfe.go):

• rfe_crud.go - CRUD operations
• rfe_agents.go - Agent management
• rfe_seeding.go - Repository seeding
• rfe_sessions.go - Session management
• rfe_types.go - Type definitions

Projects Module (formerly projects.go):

• projects_crud.go - CRUD operations
• projects_auth.go - Authentication/authorization
• projects_types.go - Type definitions and validation

This breakdown significantly improves:

• Code discoverability
• Maintainability
• Testing potential (smaller, focused units)
• Onboarding for new developers

2. Type-Safe Helper Functions

The new helper functions in helpers.go are excellent additions that follow CLAUDE.md guidelines:

func GetMetadataMap(obj *unstructured.Unstructured) (map[string]interface{}, bool)
func GetSpecMap(obj *unstructured.Unstructured) (map[string]interface{}, bool)
func GetStatusMap(obj *unstructured.Unstructured) (map[string]interface{}, bool)

These replace unsafe type assertions (like obj.Object["spec"].(map[string]interface{})) with nil-checking, which directly addresses a critical rule in CLAUDE.md:

Type-Safe Unstructured Access

• FORBIDDEN: Direct type assertions without checking
• REQUIRED: Use helpers with three-value returns

Impact: Prevents runtime panics when dealing with Kubernetes Custom Resources.

3. Improved Documentation

All new files have:

• Package-level documentation
• Function-level godoc comments
• Parameter and return value documentation
• Clear explanations of business logic

Example from helpers.go:

// RetryWithBackoff attempts an operation with exponential backoff.
// Used for operations that may temporarily fail due to async resource creation.
//
// Parameters:
//   - maxRetries: Maximum number of retry attempts
//   - initialDelay: Initial delay duration before first retry
//   ...

4. Frontend Improvements

• Added repository branch listing feature (addresses issue Bug: Input & Output Repos in "Create Agentic Session" don't show feature branch names #231)
• Cleaned up redundant back buttons (addresses issue Bug: Redundant 'Back' navigation link breaking page layout #199)
• Proper React Query integration with new use-repo.ts hooks
• Type-safe API integration

5. golangci-lint Configuration

The simplified .golangci.yml configuration is cleaner and more maintainable, though I have concerns about removed exclusions (see below).

---

⚠️ Concerns & Recommendations

1. CRITICAL: golangci-lint Configuration Regression

Issue: The golangci-lint configuration was significantly simplified by removing important exclusions:

Removed exclusions:

# OLD (removed):
linters-settings:
  staticcheck:
    checks: ["all", "-SA1019"]  # Disable deprecation warnings only

issues:
  exclude-rules:
    - path: _test\.go
      linters: [staticcheck, govet]
    - path: (handlers|jira)/.*\.go
      text: "type assertion"

Why this matters:

1. Type assertions exclusion removed: The codebase still uses intentional type assertions for Kubernetes unstructured objects. While the new helpers (GetMetadataMap, etc.) are great, they may not be used everywhere yet.
2. staticcheck configuration removed: The checks: ["all", "-SA1019"] explicitly disabled deprecation warnings, which is reasonable for production code.
3. Test file exclusions removed: Some linters can be overly strict on test files.

Recommendation:

# Run golangci-lint to see if new violations were introduced
cd components/backend
golangci-lint run
cd ../operator
golangci-lint run

If there are no new violations, the simplification is fine. If violations exist, either:

• Fix all violations before merging, OR
• Restore necessary exclusions temporarily with TODOs to fix later

2. Missing Test Coverage

Issue: No test files were added or updated despite major refactoring.

CLAUDE.md requirements (from Backend Development section):

make test              # Unit + contract tests
make test-unit         # Unit tests only
make test-contract     # Contract tests only

Recommendation:

• Before merge: Verify existing tests still pass: cd components/backend && make test
• Post-merge: Add unit tests for the new helper functions, especially:
  • GetMetadataMap, GetSpecMap, GetStatusMap (nil handling, type mismatches)
  • ResolveContentServiceName (temp vs regular service logic)

3. Potential for Unsafe Type Assertions

While the new helpers are great, I found instances where direct access might still occur. For example, in projects_crud.go:236:

meta, ok := GetMetadataMap(projObj)
if \!ok || meta == nil {
    meta = map[string]interface{}{}
    projObj.Object["metadata"] = meta
}

This is correct! But ensure all similar patterns throughout the codebase use these helpers.

Recommendation: Run a grep to find any remaining unsafe patterns:

grep -r 'Object\["' components/backend/handlers/ | grep -v '// '

If found, replace with the new helpers.

4. ResolveContentServiceName Function Design

In helpers.go, the ResolveContentServiceName function:

func ResolveContentServiceName(c *gin.Context, project, session string) string {
    // Tries temp service, falls back to regular service
    tempServiceName := fmt.Sprintf("temp-content-%s", session)
    
    reqK8s, _ := GetK8sClientsForRequest(c)
    if reqK8s \!= nil {
        if _, err := reqK8s.CoreV1().Services(project).Get(...); err == nil {
            return tempServiceName
        }
    }
    
    return fmt.Sprintf("ambient-content-%s", session)
}

Issue: This function performs a K8s API call on every invocation. For frequently called endpoints, this could impact performance.

Recommendations:

1. Cache the result if this is called multiple times for the same session
2. Add context timeout to the Get() call to prevent hanging
3. Log the decision at debug level for troubleshooting:

   log.Printf("DEBUG: Using %s service for session %s", serviceName, session)

5. No Routes File Changes Visible

The PR shows components/backend/routes.go changed (+1 line), but the diff doesn't show what changed.

Recommendation: Verify that:

• All refactored handlers are still properly registered
• No endpoints were accidentally dropped
• The new ListRepoBranches endpoint is registered correctly

6. Frontend: Repository Branch Listing

The new ListRepoBranches handler (in repo.go) is a great addition, but:

Security concern: Does this endpoint have rate limiting? GitHub API has strict rate limits, and repeated calls could exhaust the limit.

Recommendation:

• Add caching (even 1-minute cache would help)
• Consider adding rate limiting middleware
• Return cache headers to allow client-side caching

---

🔒 Security Review

✅ Correct Authentication Patterns

All handlers correctly use GetK8sClientsForRequest(c) for user-scoped operations, following CLAUDE.md guidelines:

// sessions_crud.go:33
_, reqDyn := GetK8sClientsForRequest(c)

// sessions_k8s.go:33
reqK8s, _ := GetK8sClientsForRequest(c)
if reqK8s == nil {
    c.JSON(http.StatusUnauthorized, gin.H{"error": "unauthorized"})
    return
}

✅ No token logging - All logging avoids sensitive data

✅ Proper RBAC checks - Authorization logic maintained in projects_auth.go

---

📊 Performance Considerations

Positive Impact:

• Smaller files → faster compilation
• Modular structure → better tree-shaking potential
• Clear separation → easier to identify bottlenecks

Potential Concerns:

• ResolveContentServiceName makes API call on every invocation (see above)
• No obvious performance regressions otherwise

---

🧪 Testing Recommendations

Before Merge:

# 1. Run all existing tests
cd components/backend
make test

# 2. Run linting
make lint

# 3. Verify build succeeds
make build

# 4. Integration test (if cluster available)
make test-integration

Post-Merge:

1. Add unit tests for new helper functions
2. Add tests for ResolveContentServiceName logic
3. Add contract tests for the new ListRepoBranches endpoint

---

📝 Documentation Impact

The documentation files (.md files) were updated to reflect the "Ambient Code Platform" naming (previously "vTeam"), which is good for consistency. No documentation gaps identified.

---

✅ Final Verdict

This is a high-quality refactoring that significantly improves code maintainability and follows established patterns from CLAUDE.md. The breakdown is logical, documentation is thorough, and security patterns are maintained.

Blockers:

• ❌ MUST run golangci-lint to verify no new violations from simplified config
• ❌ MUST verify existing tests pass (make test)

Recommended Before Merge:

• ⚠️ Verify all unsafe type assertions replaced with new helpers
• ⚠️ Add context timeout to ResolveContentServiceName
• ⚠️ Verify routes.go change doesn't drop endpoints

Recommended Post-Merge:

• 📝 Add unit tests for new helper functions
• 📝 Add caching to ListRepoBranches
• 📝 Consider performance monitoring for ResolveContentServiceName

---

Summary Score

Category	Score	Notes
Code Quality	9/10	Excellent organization, minor type safety verification needed
Security	10/10	All patterns correct, no violations found
Performance	8/10	ResolveContentServiceName could be optimized
Testing	5/10	No new tests, must verify existing tests pass
Documentation	9/10	Excellent inline docs, CLAUDE.md updates consistent

Overall: Strong Approve pending verification of linting and tests.

Great work on this refactor! 🎉

[sallyom]

Merging!
✅ Rate limiting is NOT urgent - The endpoint is likely called on-demand (e.g., when user selects a repo in session creation),
not polled frequently.

✅ Safe to Merge As-Is

1. golangci-lint config - Simplified v2 config works perfectly (0 issues)
2. Routes registration - All endpoints properly registered
3. ResolveContentServiceName performance - Acceptable for current usage
4. Rate limiting - Not urgent since endpoint isn't polled