Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Detector Parameters Update: Inner Trackers #567

Closed
Chao1009 opened this issue Oct 12, 2023 · 1 comment
Closed

Detector Parameters Update: Inner Trackers #567

Chao1009 opened this issue Oct 12, 2023 · 1 comment

Comments

@Chao1009
Copy link
Contributor

Chao1009 commented Oct 12, 2023

EDIT: update comparison with the 2023/10/13 table
https://eic.jlab.org/Geometry/Detector/Detector-20231013155913.html

A series of smaller issues from #552
det: new value from 2023/09/27 parameter table
sim: current simulation value as of 2023/10/11
template_var: from which we extract the sim value in compact files. Empty means we do not know.
stat: Correct, Missing, or Mismatched

Please implement the new detector parameters, and try to fill in the template_var for the Missing ones if you think it's important for future simulation/design comparison.

CENTRAL DETECTOR, Inner Tracker (Micromegas), : 
                           det  sim template_var     stat
Length (cm)              265.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
Inner Radius (cm)        49.75  NaN        Empty  Missing
Outer Radius (cm)         51.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
Offset from Center (cm)   12.5  NaN        Empty  Missing
Physical Start (cm)     -120.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
Physical End (cm)        145.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
 
CENTRAL DETECTOR, Inner Tracker (Micromegas), Micromega 1: 
                           det  sim template_var     stat
Length (cm)               70.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
Inner Radius (cm)        49.75  NaN        Empty  Missing
Outer Radius (cm)         50.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
Offset from Center (cm)   78.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
Physical Start (cm)       43.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
Physical End (cm)        113.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
 
CENTRAL DETECTOR, Inner Tracker (Micromegas), Micromega 2: 
                           det  sim template_var     stat
Length (cm)               70.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
Inner Radius (cm)        50.75  NaN        Empty  Missing
Outer Radius (cm)         51.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
Offset from Center (cm)  110.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
Physical Start (cm)       75.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
Physical End (cm)        145.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
 
CENTRAL DETECTOR, Inner Tracker (Micromegas), Micromega 3: 
                           det  sim template_var     stat
Length (cm)               70.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
Inner Radius (cm)        50.75  NaN        Empty  Missing
Outer Radius (cm)         51.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
Offset from Center (cm)  -85.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
Physical Start (cm)     -120.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
Physical End (cm)        -50.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
 
CENTRAL DETECTOR, Inner Tracker (Micromegas), Micromega 4: 
                           det  sim template_var     stat
Length (cm)               70.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
Inner Radius (cm)        51.75  NaN        Empty  Missing
Outer Radius (cm)         52.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
Offset from Center (cm)    5.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
Physical Start (cm)      -30.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
Physical End (cm)         40.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
 
CENTRAL DETECTOR, Inner Tracker (Micromegas), Micromega 5: 
                           det  sim template_var     stat
Length (cm)               70.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
Inner Radius (cm)        52.75  NaN        Empty  Missing
Outer Radius (cm)         53.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
Offset from Center (cm)  -10.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
Physical Start (cm)      -45.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
Physical End (cm)         25.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
 
CENTRAL DETECTOR, Inner Tracker (Si Barrel), : 
                          det  sim template_var     stat
Length (cm)              80.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
Inner Radius (cm)         3.6  NaN        Empty  Missing
Outer Radius (cm)        42.5  NaN        Empty  Missing
Offset from Center (cm)   0.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
Physical Start (cm)     -40.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
Physical End (cm)        40.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
 
CENTRAL DETECTOR, Inner Tracker (Si Barrel), Si Layer 1: 
                          det   sim                        template_var        stat
Length (cm)              27.0   NaN                               Empty     Missing
Inner Radius (cm)         3.6   3.5         {{VertexBarrelLayer1_rmin}}  Mismatched
Outer Radius (cm)         4.1   3.7         {{VertexBarrelLayer1_rmax}}  Mismatched
Offset from Center (cm)   0.0   NaN                               Empty     Missing
Physical Start (cm)     -13.5 -24.0  -{{VertexBarrelEnvelope_length/2}}  Mismatched
Physical End (cm)        13.5  24.0   {{VertexBarrelEnvelope_length/2}}  Mismatched
 
CENTRAL DETECTOR, Inner Tracker (Si Barrel), Si Layer 2: 
                          det   sim                        template_var        stat
Length (cm)              27.0   NaN                               Empty     Missing
Inner Radius (cm)         4.8   4.7         {{VertexBarrelLayer2_rmin}}  Mismatched
Outer Radius (cm)         5.3   4.9         {{VertexBarrelLayer2_rmax}}  Mismatched
Offset from Center (cm)   0.0   NaN                               Empty     Missing
Physical Start (cm)     -13.5 -24.0  -{{VertexBarrelEnvelope_length/2}}  Mismatched
Physical End (cm)        13.5  24.0   {{VertexBarrelEnvelope_length/2}}  Mismatched
 
CENTRAL DETECTOR, Inner Tracker (Si Barrel), Si Layer 3: 
                          det   sim                        template_var        stat
Length (cm)              27.0   NaN                               Empty     Missing
Inner Radius (cm)        12.0  11.9         {{VertexBarrelLayer3_rmin}}  Mismatched
Outer Radius (cm)        12.5  12.1         {{VertexBarrelLayer3_rmax}}  Mismatched
Offset from Center (cm)   0.0   NaN                               Empty     Missing
Physical Start (cm)     -13.5 -24.0  -{{VertexBarrelEnvelope_length/2}}  Mismatched
Physical End (cm)        13.5  24.0   {{VertexBarrelEnvelope_length/2}}  Mismatched
 
CENTRAL DETECTOR, Inner Tracker (Si Barrel), Si Layer 4: 
                          det   sim                  template_var        stat
Length (cm)              54.0   NaN                         Empty     Missing
Inner Radius (cm)        27.0  27.1       {{SiBarrelLayer1_rmin}}  Mismatched
Outer Radius (cm)        27.5  30.1       {{SiBarrelLayer1_rmax}}  Mismatched
Offset from Center (cm)   0.0   NaN                         Empty     Missing
Physical Start (cm)     -27.0 -26.1  -{{SiBarrelLayer1_length/2}}  Mismatched
Physical End (cm)        27.0  26.1   {{SiBarrelLayer1_length/2}}  Mismatched
 
CENTRAL DETECTOR, Inner Tracker (Si Barrel), Si Layer 5: 
                          det   sim                  template_var        stat
Length (cm)              80.0   NaN                         Empty     Missing
Inner Radius (cm)        42.0  43.0       {{SiBarrelLayer2_rmin}}  Mismatched
Outer Radius (cm)        42.5  46.0       {{SiBarrelLayer2_rmax}}  Mismatched
Offset from Center (cm)   0.0   NaN                         Empty     Missing
Physical Start (cm)     -40.0 -26.1  -{{SiBarrelLayer1_length/2}}  Mismatched
Physical End (cm)        40.0  26.1   {{SiBarrelLayer1_length/2}}  Mismatched
 
CENTRAL DETECTOR, Inner Tracker (Si Disks), : 
                            det  sim template_var     stat
Length (cm)               242.5  NaN        Empty  Missing
Inner Radius (cm)         3.676  NaN        Empty  Missing
Outer Radius (cm)          43.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
Offset from Center (cm)    15.0  NaN        Empty  Missing
Physical Start (cm)     -106.25  NaN        Empty  Missing
Physical End (cm)        136.25  NaN        Empty  Missing
 
CENTRAL DETECTOR, Inner Tracker (Si Disks), HD Disk 1: 
                           det     sim                                                       template_var        stat
Length (cm)                2.5     NaN                                                              Empty     Missing
Inner Radius (cm)        3.676   3.676                                 {{InnerTrackerEndcapPLayer1_rmin}}     Correct
Outer Radius (cm)         23.0    24.0                                 {{InnerTrackerEndcapPLayer1_rmax}}  Mismatched
Offset from Center (cm)   25.0     NaN                                                              Empty     Missing
Physical Start (cm)      23.75  24.984                                 {{InnerTrackerEndcapPLayer1_zmin}}  Mismatched
Physical End (cm)        26.25  25.015  {{InnerTrackerEndcapPLayer1_zmin+SiTrackerEndcapLayer_thickness}}  Mismatched
 
CENTRAL DETECTOR, Inner Tracker (Si Disks), HD Disk 2: 
                           det     sim                                                  template_var        stat
Length (cm)                2.5     NaN                                                         Empty     Missing
Inner Radius (cm)        3.676   3.676                                 {{TrackerEndcapPLayer1_rmin}}     Correct
Outer Radius (cm)         43.0    41.5                                 {{TrackerEndcapPLayer1_rmax}}  Mismatched
Offset from Center (cm)   45.0     NaN                                                         Empty     Missing
Physical Start (cm)      43.75  44.984                                 {{TrackerEndcapPLayer1_zmin}}  Mismatched
Physical End (cm)        46.25  45.015  {{TrackerEndcapPLayer1_zmin+SiTrackerEndcapLayer_thickness}}  Mismatched
 
CENTRAL DETECTOR, Inner Tracker (Si Disks), HD Disk 3: 
                           det     sim                                                  template_var        stat
Length (cm)                2.5     NaN                                                         Empty     Missing
Inner Radius (cm)        3.842   3.846                                 {{TrackerEndcapPLayer2_rmin}}  Mismatched
Outer Radius (cm)         43.0   42.14                                 {{TrackerEndcapPLayer2_rmax}}  Mismatched
Offset from Center (cm)   70.0     NaN                                                         Empty     Missing
Physical Start (cm)      68.75  69.984                                 {{TrackerEndcapPLayer2_zmin}}  Mismatched
Physical End (cm)        71.25  70.015  {{TrackerEndcapPLayer2_zmin+SiTrackerEndcapLayer_thickness}}  Mismatched
 
CENTRAL DETECTOR, Inner Tracker (Si Disks), HD Disk 4: 
                            det      sim                                                  template_var        stat
Length (cm)                 2.5      NaN                                                         Empty     Missing
Inner Radius (cm)         5.443    5.343                                 {{TrackerEndcapPLayer3_rmin}}  Mismatched
Outer Radius (cm)          43.0    42.14                                 {{TrackerEndcapPLayer3_rmax}}  Mismatched
Offset from Center (cm)   100.0      NaN                                                         Empty     Missing
Physical Start (cm)       98.75   99.984                                 {{TrackerEndcapPLayer3_zmin}}  Mismatched
Physical End (cm)        101.25  100.015  {{TrackerEndcapPLayer3_zmin+SiTrackerEndcapLayer_thickness}}  Mismatched
 
CENTRAL DETECTOR, Inner Tracker (Si Disks), HD Disk 5: 
                            det      sim                                                  template_var        stat
Length (cm)                 2.5      NaN                                                         Empty     Missing
Inner Radius (cm)         7.014    7.014                                 {{TrackerEndcapPLayer4_rmin}}     Correct
Outer Radius (cm)          43.0    42.14                                 {{TrackerEndcapPLayer4_rmax}}  Mismatched
Offset from Center (cm)   135.0      NaN                                                         Empty     Missing
Physical Start (cm)      133.75  134.984                                 {{TrackerEndcapPLayer4_zmin}}  Mismatched
Physical End (cm)        136.25  135.015  {{TrackerEndcapPLayer4_zmin+SiTrackerEndcapLayer_thickness}}  Mismatched
 
CENTRAL DETECTOR, Inner Tracker (Si Disks), LD Disk 1: 
                           det     sim                                                       template_var        stat
Length (cm)                2.5     NaN                                                              Empty     Missing
Inner Radius (cm)        3.676   3.676                                 {{InnerTrackerEndcapNLayer1_rmin}}     Correct
Outer Radius (cm)         23.0    24.0                                 {{InnerTrackerEndcapNLayer1_rmax}}  Mismatched
Offset from Center (cm)  -25.0     NaN                                                              Empty     Missing
Physical Start (cm)     -26.25  24.984                                 {{InnerTrackerEndcapNLayer1_zmin}}  Mismatched
Physical End (cm)       -23.75  25.015  {{InnerTrackerEndcapNLayer1_zmin+SiTrackerEndcapLayer_thickness}}  Mismatched
 
CENTRAL DETECTOR, Inner Tracker (Si Disks), LD Disk 2: 
                           det     sim                                                   template_var        stat
Length (cm)                2.5     NaN                                                          Empty     Missing
Inner Radius (cm)        3.676   3.676                                  {{TrackerEndcapNLayer1_rmin}}     Correct
Outer Radius (cm)         43.0    41.5                                  {{TrackerEndcapNLayer1_rmax}}  Mismatched
Offset from Center (cm)  -45.0     NaN                                                          Empty     Missing
Physical Start (cm)     -46.25 -45.015  -{{TrackerEndcapNLayer1_zmin+SiTrackerEndcapLayer_thickness}}  Mismatched
Physical End (cm)       -43.75 -44.984                                 -{{TrackerEndcapNLayer1_zmin}}  Mismatched
 
CENTRAL DETECTOR, Inner Tracker (Si Disks), LD Disk 3: 
                           det     sim                                                   template_var        stat
Length (cm)                2.5     NaN                                                          Empty     Missing
Inner Radius (cm)        3.676   3.676                                  {{TrackerEndcapNLayer2_rmin}}     Correct
Outer Radius (cm)         43.0   42.14                                  {{TrackerEndcapNLayer2_rmax}}  Mismatched
Offset from Center (cm)  -65.0     NaN                                                          Empty     Missing
Physical Start (cm)     -66.25 -65.015  -{{TrackerEndcapNLayer2_zmin+SiTrackerEndcapLayer_thickness}}  Mismatched
Physical End (cm)       -63.75 -64.984                                 -{{TrackerEndcapNLayer2_zmin}}  Mismatched
 
CENTRAL DETECTOR, Inner Tracker (Si Disks), LD Disk 4: 
                             det     sim                                                   template_var        stat
Length (cm)                  2.5     NaN                                                          Empty     Missing
Inner Radius (cm)        4.00614   4.006                                  {{TrackerEndcapNLayer3_rmin}}  Mismatched
Outer Radius (cm)           43.0   42.14                                  {{TrackerEndcapNLayer3_rmax}}  Mismatched
Offset from Center (cm)    -85.0     NaN                                                          Empty     Missing
Physical Start (cm)       -86.25 -85.015  -{{TrackerEndcapNLayer3_zmin+SiTrackerEndcapLayer_thickness}}  Mismatched
Physical End (cm)         -83.75 -84.984                                 -{{TrackerEndcapNLayer3_zmin}}  Mismatched
 
CENTRAL DETECTOR, Inner Tracker (Si Disks), LD Disk 5: 
                             det      sim                                                   template_var        stat
Length (cm)                  2.5      NaN                                                          Empty     Missing
Inner Radius (cm)        4.63529    4.635                                  {{TrackerEndcapNLayer4_rmin}}  Mismatched
Outer Radius (cm)           43.0    42.14                                  {{TrackerEndcapNLayer4_rmax}}  Mismatched
Offset from Center (cm)   -105.0      NaN                                                          Empty     Missing
Physical Start (cm)      -106.25 -105.015  -{{TrackerEndcapNLayer4_zmin+SiTrackerEndcapLayer_thickness}}  Mismatched
Physical End (cm)        -103.75 -104.984                                 -{{TrackerEndcapNLayer4_zmin}}  Mismatched
@Chao1009 Chao1009 changed the title Detector Parameters Update: Detector Parameters Update: Inner Trackers Oct 12, 2023
github-merge-queue bot pushed a commit that referenced this issue Oct 19, 2023
### Briefly, what does this PR introduce?
A new table with some typo fixes is at
https://eic.jlab.org/Geometry/Detector/Detector-20231013155913.html, but
without csv format.
Since we expect more of the fixes to come, adding a support for
extracting html table would be easier to update the comparison reports.
Related to issue #567 

### What kind of change does this PR introduce?
- [ ] Bug fix (issue #__)
- [ ] New feature (issue #__)
- [ ] Documentation update
- [x] Other: __

### Please check if this PR fulfills the following:
- [ ] Tests for the changes have been added
- [ ] Documentation has been added / updated
- [ ] Changes have been communicated to collaborators

### Does this PR introduce breaking changes? What changes might users
need to make to their code?
No

### Does this PR change default behavior?
No

---------

Co-authored-by: Chao Peng <cpeng@anl.gov>
@Chao1009
Copy link
Contributor Author

Chao1009 commented Nov 7, 2023

Hi @ShujieL , any progress in updating these parameters?

github-merge-queue bot pushed a commit that referenced this issue Nov 15, 2023
### Briefly, what does this PR introduce?
Updates MPGD disks to match detector parameter table

### What kind of change does this PR introduce?
- [x] Bug fix (issue #567 )
- [ ] New feature (issue #__)
- [] Documentation update
- [ ] Other: __

### Please check if this PR fulfills the following:
- [ ] Tests for the changes have been added
- [ ] Documentation has been added / updated
- [ x] Changes have been communicated to collaborators

### Does this PR introduce breaking changes? What changes might users
need to make to their code?
There should be no breaking changes 

### Does this PR change default behavior?
No
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Projects
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants