📊 Agent Performance Report — 2026-06-28

[github-actions[bot]]

Agent Performance Report — 2026-06-28

Executive Summary

Metric	Value	Trend
Agents analyzed	18 active	—
Average quality score	63/100	↑+1
Average effectiveness score	64/100	↑+1
Ecosystem health	82/100	↓-2
Compilation	257/257 (100%)	✅ Stable
P1 failures	3 (Code Simplifier, BYOK Ollama, Safe Output Integrator)	→ unchanged

Key headline: Gradual quality/effectiveness improvements continue. CI recovery confirmed (PR #41849). However, Code Simplifier fix PR #41852 proved ineffective — EACCES persists, requiring architecture-level investigation. New CI failure at 12:57 UTC and Avenger intermittency (3 consecutive failures 09:30–11:58 UTC) are being monitored.

Performance Rankings

Top Performing Agents 🏆

1. Copilot SWE Agent (Q: 92, E: 91) — 80% merge rate (61/76 settled), 83 PRs. Dominant throughput across bug fixes, features, eslint rules, CI hardening.
2. PR Triage (Q: 88, E: 86) — 5/5 runs. Structured risk/priority tables with delta tracking.
3. Team Status (Q: 85, E: 83) — 5/5 runs. Excellent repo pulse formatting.
4. Static Analysis (Q: 84, E: 81) — 5/5 runs. 11+ consecutive days zizmor High = 0.
5. Workflow Health Manager (Q: 82, E: 80) — 5/5 runs. Accurate P1/P2 tracking, run references.
6. Issue Monster / Agentic Maintenance (Q: 80, E: 82) — 5/5 each, 100% success streak.
7. Auto-Triage Issues (Q: 78, E: 80) — 5/5 runs. Fully recovered from Jun 21–25 P1 failure.
8. PR Code Quality Reviewer (Q: 75, E: 76) — 4/5 runs; 1 isolated failure, not yet a trend.

Agents Needing Improvement 📉

1. Code Simplifier (Q: 10, E: 5) — 9/10 failures. Fix PR fix(setup): clean up root-owned /tmp/awf-*-chroot-home directories #41852 merged but EACCES persists. Architecture-level sandbox review needed. Issue #42003 — DO NOT RE-FILE.
2. Daily Safe Output Integrator (Q: 10, E: 10) — 10/10 failures. Tool denial limit exceeded (5/5). Structural refactor needed. Issue #41935 — DO NOT RE-FILE.
3. Daily BYOK Ollama Test (Q: 10, E: 5) — 10/10 failures. api-proxy 503 infra dependency. Issue #41827 — DO NOT RE-FILE.
4. Go Logger Enhancement (Q: 20, E: 20) — 3 consecutive failures. Issue #42002 — DO NOT RE-FILE.

Intermittent Concerns 🔄

• Avenger: 5/10 failures Jun 27–28, including 3 consecutive (09:30–11:58 UTC Jun 28). Correlates with CI instability. No existing issue — monitor through Jun 29.
• Changeset Generator: 5/10 alternating failures. workflows scope needed. Issue #41987.

Behavioral Patterns & Coverage

Productive Patterns ✅

• Campaign-driven delivery: eslint-factory improvements (fix(eslint-factory): isInsideTryBlock unsound for deferred callbacks #42060, eslint-factory: add no-unsafe-catch-error-property rule #42057, eslint-factory: add require-parseInt-radix suggestion fix and correct docs URL #42047, eslint-factory: complete test suite for require-parseInt-radix #42042, audit: count workflow failure when telemetry is unavailable #42046) — coordinated incremental work
• Failure deduplication: "DO NOT RE-FILE" pattern working across all orchestrators
• Delta reporting: PR Triage and Workflow Health correctly show changes vs prior run

Problematic Patterns ⚠️

• Stranded fix PRs: No signal when a merged fix PR fails to resolve the issue (Code Simplifier)
• Guaranteed-fail execution: Safe Output Integrator and BYOK Ollama continue scheduling despite architectural blockers — wasted ~1.9M AIC tokens/run on Code Simplifier alone
• Avenger ambiguity: Failure mode indistinguishable between "Avenger bug" and "CI is unfixable" — hard to triage
• New CI regression: CI failed at 12:57 UTC Jun 28 (after Jun 27 resolution) — monitor

Coverage Gaps

• No stale PR detection (PRs open >7 days)
• No automated recovery/auto-close for chronic P1 failures
• No AIC budget forecasting or per-workflow credit alerting
• No "fix PR effectiveness tracking"

Recommendations

High Priority

1. Code Simplifier — sandbox architecture review ([aw] Code Simplifier failed #42003): Audit chroot mount/umount permissions; upstream cleanup before sandbox teardown. PR approach failed — needs deeper change.
2. Safe Output Integrator — structural refactor ([aw] Daily Safe Output Integrator exceeded tool denial limit #41935): Redesign to avoid blocked shell tools, not just retune prompt.
3. Avenger — CI-state skip guard: Pre-flight CI check before attempting fixes; emit noop when blockers are known-tracked. Reduces false-failure rate.

Medium Priority

4. Fix PR effectiveness tracking: Workflow Health Manager should detect workflows still failing after their fix PR merges.
5. Stale issue escalation: Auto-escalate infra-blocked P1 issues after N days without resolution.

Trends

Metric	Jun 28	Jun 27	Δ
Quality	63/100	62/100	↑+1
Effectiveness	64/100	63/100	↑+1
Health	82/100	84/100	↓-2
Agent PR merge rate	80%	81%	↓-1
Active P1 failures	3	3	→
Active P2 watches	4	3	↑+1 (Avenger added)

Actions Taken

• Updated agent-performance-latest.md and shared-alerts.md in shared memory
• 0 new issues filed (all active issues tracked; Avenger under observation)

Next Steps

1. Monitor Avenger through Jun 29 — file P2 if streak continues
2. Escalate Code Simplifier to sandbox architecture review
3. Workflow Health Manager to assess new CI failure (12:57 UTC) on next run
4. Issue nolint-suppression parity gap: 5 linters still have no (nolint/redacted) support, blocking CI enforcement #41844 (CI) can be closed — resolution confirmed

---

Analysis: 2026-06-27 → 2026-06-28 | Next: 2026-06-29 | Run: §28323141732

Generated by ⚡ Agent Performance Analyzer - Meta-Orchestrator · 100.9 AIC · ⌖ 26.6 AIC · ⊞ 10.3K · ◷

• expires on Jun 29, 2026, 5:18 AM UTC-08:00

[github-actions[bot]]

This discussion was automatically closed because it expired on 2026-06-29T13:18:20.799Z.

Closed by Workflow