Repository navigation
Future support for Author Personal Name in standard "Last Name, First Name" format? #13564
Replies: 1 comment
|
OpenLibrary made a decision early on to use normal name order, which I personally think was the right call from a usability point of view. Inverted order is primarily useful for helping name variants to collate together (e.g. in a card catalog), but computers have other ways grouping things. Note that "normal" name order varies by culture, so sometimes you'll see the family name first and sometimes last. Although the import code attempts to "fix" names imported from MARC, doing this algorithmically is error prone (and even more so when it's attempted with non-MARC sources like Amazon). The only way to deal with things reliably is to have separate storage fields for family name, given name, display name (for each locale), sort name, etc. If you need this level of granularity, your best bet is probably to follow the link to Wikidata and get the data from there. |
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
I’ve searched through both the open and the closed issues in this repository and found a few references to flipping imported name data from "Doe, John" to "John Doe" (I also found do_flip() in openlibrary/catalog/add_book/load_book.py). However, I haven't found any discussion regarding adding support for storing or outputting the standard "Last Name, First Name" format, as detailed in the MARC 21 standards:
I opted to start a discussion rather than open an issue since I don't have full context on the original design decisions behind using the "First Name Last Name" format. I'm curious if there are structural or architectural reasons for currently not supporting the "Last Name, First Name" format, or if support for it might be considered in the future?
As a potential approach, when incoming names are flipped, could they simultaneously be parsed into separate "personal_name_first" and "personal_name_last" fields to allow for flexible formatting later?
All reactions