Debian Bookworm: Unable to install latest llvm 19 with apt

[henrythebuilder]

Hi,
at the moment I am unable to install/update the latest packages from Debian Bookworm, the update forces the removal of Chromium, this is the log of the simulated upgrade:

~#  apt-get -s install clang-19 lldb-19 lld-19 clangd-19 clang-tidy-19 clang-format-19 clang-tools-19 llvm-19-dev lld-19 lldb-19 llvm-19-tools libomp-19-dev libc++-19-dev libc++abi-19-dev libclang-common-19-dev libclang-19-dev libclang-cpp19-dev libunwind-19-dev libclang-rt-19-dev libpolly-19-dev clang-19-doc llvm-19-doc
Reading package lists... Done
Building dependency tree... Done
Reading state information... Done
The following additional packages will be installed:
  lib32gcc-s1 lib32stdc++6 libc++1-19 libc++abi1-19 libc6-i386 libclang-cpp19 libclang1-19 libgrpc++1.51 libgrpc29 liblldb-19 libllvm19 libobjc-12-dev libomp5-19 libpfm4 libprotoc32
  libunwind-19 llvm-19 llvm-19-linker-tools llvm-19-runtime python3-lldb-19
Suggested packages:
  wasi-libc clang libomp-19-doc
The following packages will be REMOVED:
  chromium chromium-common chromium-l10n libc++1-16 libc++abi1-16 libunwind-16
The following NEW packages will be installed:
  clang-19 clang-19-doc clang-format-19 clang-tidy-19 clang-tools-19 clangd-19 lib32gcc-s1 lib32stdc++6 libc++-19-dev libc++1-19 libc++abi-19-dev libc++abi1-19 libc6-i386 libclang-19-dev
  libclang-common-19-dev libclang-cpp19 libclang-cpp19-dev libclang-rt-19-dev libclang1-19 libgrpc++1.51 libgrpc29 liblldb-19 libllvm19 libobjc-12-dev libomp-19-dev libomp5-19 libpfm4
  libpolly-19-dev libprotoc32 libunwind-19 libunwind-19-dev lld-19 lldb-19 llvm-19 llvm-19-dev llvm-19-doc llvm-19-linker-tools llvm-19-runtime llvm-19-tools python3-lldb-19
0 upgraded, 40 newly installed, 6 to remove and 0 not upgraded.
Remv chromium-l10n [129.0.6668.58-1~deb12u1]
Remv chromium [129.0.6668.58-1~deb12u1]
Remv chromium-common [129.0.6668.58-1~deb12u1]
Remv libc++1-16 [1:16.0.6-15~deb12u1]
Remv libc++abi1-16 [1:16.0.6-15~deb12u1]
Remv libunwind-16 [1:16.0.6-15~deb12u1]
Inst libllvm19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst libclang-cpp19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst libobjc-12-dev (12.2.0-14 Debian:12.7/stable [amd64])
Inst libclang-common-19-dev (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst llvm-19-linker-tools (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst libclang1-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst clang-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst clang-19-doc (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [all])
Inst clang-format-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst clang-tools-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst clang-tidy-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst libprotoc32 (3.21.12-3 Debian:12.7/stable [amd64])
Inst libgrpc29 (1.51.1-3+b1 Debian:12.7/stable [amd64])
Inst libgrpc++1.51 (1.51.1-3+b1 Debian:12.7/stable [amd64])
Inst clangd-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst libc6-i386 (2.36-9+deb12u8 Debian:12.7/stable [amd64])
Inst lib32gcc-s1 (12.2.0-14 Debian:12.7/stable [amd64])
Inst lib32stdc++6 (12.2.0-14 Debian:12.7/stable [amd64])
Inst libunwind-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst libc++abi1-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst libc++1-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst libc++abi-19-dev (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst libunwind-19-dev (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst libc++-19-dev (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst libclang-19-dev (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst libclang-cpp19-dev (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst libclang-rt-19-dev (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst liblldb-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst libomp5-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst libomp-19-dev (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst libpfm4 (4.13.0-1 Debian:12.7/stable [amd64])
Inst libpolly-19-dev (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst lld-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst python3-lldb-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst lldb-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst llvm-19-runtime (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst llvm-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst llvm-19-tools (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst llvm-19-dev (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Inst llvm-19-doc (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [all])
Conf libllvm19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf libclang-cpp19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf libobjc-12-dev (12.2.0-14 Debian:12.7/stable [amd64])
Conf libclang-common-19-dev (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf llvm-19-linker-tools (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf libclang1-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf clang-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf clang-19-doc (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [all])
Conf clang-format-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf clang-tools-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf clang-tidy-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf libprotoc32 (3.21.12-3 Debian:12.7/stable [amd64])
Conf libgrpc29 (1.51.1-3+b1 Debian:12.7/stable [amd64])
Conf libgrpc++1.51 (1.51.1-3+b1 Debian:12.7/stable [amd64])
Conf clangd-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf libc6-i386 (2.36-9+deb12u8 Debian:12.7/stable [amd64])
Conf lib32gcc-s1 (12.2.0-14 Debian:12.7/stable [amd64])
Conf lib32stdc++6 (12.2.0-14 Debian:12.7/stable [amd64])
Conf libunwind-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf libc++abi1-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf libc++1-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf libc++abi-19-dev (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf libunwind-19-dev (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf libc++-19-dev (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf libclang-19-dev (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf libclang-cpp19-dev (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf libclang-rt-19-dev (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf liblldb-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf libomp5-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf libomp-19-dev (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf libpfm4 (4.13.0-1 Debian:12.7/stable [amd64])
Conf libpolly-19-dev (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf lld-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf python3-lldb-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf lldb-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf llvm-19-runtime (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf llvm-19 (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf llvm-19-tools (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf llvm-19-dev (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [amd64])
Conf llvm-19-doc (1:19.1.0~++20240920062301+64075837b553-1~exp1~20240920062432.44 apt.llvm.org [all])

[firewave]

Is this still an issue?

And are you using packages from apt.llvm.org? Otherwise you need to report this to your distro.

[henrythebuilder]

yes, I used using packages from apt.llvm.org.
The only solution I've found is to use the 'static' package as a user, without installation (eg release binary LLVM-19.1.0-Linux-X64.tar.xz).
Some time ago I had to change distribution, switching to openSUSE and, despite it having a repo aligned with the current versions, I continue to use the 'release binary' version as a user.
Thanks for the support.

[borjamunozf]

I have the same problem but in Ubuntu 24.04. Trying to build in Docker image 24.04.01 and 24.04.02 without success.

19.96 The following packages have unmet dependencies:
20.14  clang-19 : Depends: libllvm19 (= 1:19.1.7~++20250114103332+cd708029e0b2-1~exp1~20250114103446.78) but 1:19.1.1-1ubuntu1~24.04.2 is to be installed
20.14  clang-tidy-19 : Depends: libllvm19 (= 1:19.1.7~++20250114103332+cd708029e0b2-1~exp1~20250114103446.78) but 1:19.1.1-1ubuntu1~24.04.2 is to be installed
20.14  libclang-cpp19 : Depends: libllvm19 (= 1:19.1.7~++20250114103332+cd708029e0b2-1~exp1~20250114103446.78) but 1:19.1.1-1ubuntu1~24.04.2 is to be installed
20.15  lld-19 : Depends: libllvm19 (= 1:19.1.7~++20250114103332+cd708029e0b2-1~exp1~20250114103446.78) but 1:19.1.1-1ubuntu1~24.04.2 is to be installed
20.15  llvm-19-dev : Depends: libllvm19 (= 1:19.1.7~++20250114103332+cd708029e0b2-1~exp1~20250114103446.78) but 1:19.1.1-1ubuntu1~24.04.2 is to be installed
20.16 E: Unable to correct problems, you have held broken packages.

[sylvestre]

@borjamunozf could you please give more details on how you are installing it?
thanks

[borjamunozf]

Yes, sorry :)

It's a long Dockerfile with multistage, but last stage where my-base is originating from
FROM ubuntu:noble-20240801 or FROM ubuntu:24.04

FROM my-base AS ubuntu-whatever
other stuff...


## Install last llvm
RUN wget -O - https://apt.llvm.org/llvm-snapshot.gpg.key | apt-key add - && \
    add-apt-repository "deb https://apt.llvm.org/noble/ llvm-toolchain-noble-19 main" && \
    apt-get update && \
    apt-get install -y --no-install-recommends \
       clang-19 \
       clang-tidy-19 \
       clang-tools-19 \
       libclang-rt-19-dev \
       lld-19 \
       llvm-19 \
       llvm-19-dev \
    && rm -rf /var/lib/apt/lists/*

@borjamunozf could you please give more details on how you are installing it? thanks

[borjamunozf]

Hm, something relative to my Dockerfile.

I tested with a minimal file and it seems to work.

FROM ubuntu:24.04

ADD mycert.pem /etc/ssl/certs/
ADD mycert.crt /usr/local/share/ca-certificates/mycert.crt

RUN apt-get update && apt-get install -y gnupg wget ca-certificates software-properties-common
RUN update-ca-certificates

#RUN apt-get update && apt-get install -y gnupg wget
RUN wget -O - https://apt.llvm.org/llvm-snapshot.gpg.key | apt-key add - && \
    add-apt-repository "deb https://apt.llvm.org/noble/ llvm-toolchain-noble-19 main" && \
    apt-get update && \
    apt-get install -y --no-install-recommends \
       clang-19 \
       clang-tidy-19 \
       clang-tools-19 \
       libclang-rt-19-dev \
       lld-19 \
       llvm-19 \
       llvm-19-dev \
    && rm -rf /var/lib/apt/lists/*

The root problem seems adding the libqt5gui5:i386 package, so I think there is not much to do

[sylvestre]

libqt5gui5:i386 ? I thought ubuntu didn't have i386 anymore ?!

[firewave]

libqt5gui5:i386 ? I thought ubuntu didn't have i386 anymore ?!

IIRC they stopped shipping ISOs but still offering the packages. But that might have been a different distro.

The latest reference to the state of i386 I found in a quick search: https://lists.debian.org/debian-devel-announce/2023/12/msg00003.html

The release notes for Bookworm also still reference it:

32-bit PC (i386) no longer covers any i586 processor; the new minimum processor requirement is i686. If your machine is not compatible with this requirement, it is recommended that you stay with bullseye for the remainder of its support cycle.

https://pkgs.org/ seems to have dropped all i386 packages which is a bit unfortunate given they still exist.