Skip to content

Conversation

@florian-berger-netwrix
Copy link
Contributor

A no longer required, and existing link was removed from the "Installation Server Manager" page.

@florian-berger-netwrix florian-berger-netwrix requested a review from a team as a code owner November 14, 2025 11:54
@claude
Copy link

claude bot commented Nov 14, 2025

Pull Request Review

Summary

This PR removes a broken link reference to a non-existent SAML configuration document from the Password Secure 9.3 installation guide. The change is appropriate and fixes a documentation build issue.

✅ Positive Findings

1. Correct Problem Identification

  • The removed link referenced /docs/passwordsecure/9.3/configuration/advancedview/clientmodule/applications/configuration_of_saml.md, which does not exist in the 9.3 documentation
  • The SAML configuration file exists in versions 9.1 and 9.2, but was not carried over to 9.3
  • This was causing build failures (as indicated by the PR title "bug/npws-build: Building is possible again")

2. Clean Removal

  • The entire paragraph has been removed cleanly (4 lines deleted)
  • No orphaned formatting or structural issues remain
  • The document flows naturally after the removal

3. Consistency

  • The 9.2 version of this file contains the same SAML reference (lines 23-25), which is appropriate since that file exists in 9.2
  • This PR correctly handles the version-specific difference

🤔 Considerations

1. Content Accuracy
While removing the broken link fixes the build, consider whether:

  • Does Password Secure 9.3 still support SAML as an identity provider during installation?
  • If yes, should alternative documentation be referenced or created?
  • If no, this removal is fully appropriate

2. Documentation Completeness
The paragraph that was removed stated: "If you want to use Netwrix Password Secure as an identity provider [Configuration of SAML] must be selected. Otherwise, it will not be installed."

This suggests important installation guidance. If SAML functionality still exists in 9.3, users might need this information elsewhere.

📋 Technical Assessment

Category Status Notes
Code Quality N/A (documentation change)
Broken Links Fixes broken link issue
Build Status Resolves build failure
Security No concerns
Test Coverage N/A (documentation)
Backwards Compat Version-specific change

💡 Recommendations

  1. Verify SAML Support: Confirm whether SAML identity provider functionality exists in Password Secure 9.3
  2. Consider Documentation: If SAML is supported in 9.3, consider:
    • Creating the missing configuration_of_saml.md file for version 9.3
    • Adding a reference to alternative SAML documentation if it exists elsewhere
    • Including this note in a release notes/migration guide

✅ Approval

This PR is approved for merging as it:

  • Fixes a legitimate build issue
  • Removes a broken link correctly
  • Maintains document structure and readability
  • Is properly scoped to the identified problem

However, I recommend following up on the SAML documentation question to ensure users of version 9.3 have adequate guidance if that feature is still supported.


Review performed by Claude Code

@florian-berger-netwrix florian-berger-netwrix merged commit 4090c06 into dev Nov 14, 2025
5 checks passed
@florian-berger-netwrix florian-berger-netwrix deleted the bug/npws-build branch November 14, 2025 20:57
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants