Skip to content

Conversation

@hustcer
Copy link
Contributor

@hustcer hustcer commented Oct 28, 2025

Try to fix Winget install & upgrade Tests in workflows

@github-actions
Copy link

Script Analysis

  • Key observations:
    • The changes move winget install commands from Nushell scripts to dedicated workflow steps using cmd
    • Maintains same functionality but with better separation of concerns
    • Properly uses environment variables for sensitive data (GITHUB_TOKEN)
    • Follows consistent pattern across multiple workflow files

Security Review

  • Vulnerability findings:
    • ✅ Sensitive GITHUB_TOKEN is properly passed as environment variable
    • ✅ External command execution (winget) is properly parameterized with static arguments
    • ❗ Consider adding error handling for the winget install step to fail fast if installation fails

Optimization Suggestions

  • Performance improvements:
    • ✅ Moving winget install to separate step prevents redundant installations when running multiple test cases
    • ⚠️ Consider adding a condition to skip installation if Komac is already present
    • ✅ Using cmd for Windows-specific commands is more efficient than shelling out from Nushell

Overall Quality: 4

checklist:

  • Compatibility: ["Nu 0.90+", "Windows-specific", "No plugin dependencies"]
  • Security: ["Input sanitization not needed (static args)", "No temp files", "Env properly handled"]
  • Reliability: ["Could improve error handling", "No null handling needed", "Type validation not applicable"]
  • Performance: ["Reduced redundant operations", "Proper command grouping", "Stream handling not applicable"]

@hustcer hustcer merged commit 7f0f277 into main Oct 28, 2025
73 checks passed
@fdncred fdncred deleted the develop branch October 28, 2025 11:19
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants