Claude finished @strawgate's task —— View job

Documentation Review for v0.3.0 ✓

I've completed a comprehensive line-by-line review of README.md, AGENTS.md, and DEVELOPING.md documentation in preparation for the 0.3.0 release.

Recommendation

The documentation is generally accurate and well-maintained, with only minor issues identified. Most discrepancies are minor variable naming inconsistencies or missing details that should be addressed before 0.3.0. The documentation effectively communicates the library's architecture, usage patterns, and development workflows.

Priority fixes needed:

README.md line 138: Variable name mismatch (store vs key_value)
README.md line 411: License statement says "MIT licensed" but project uses Apache 2.0 (verified in LICENSE file)
README.md: Add missing DefaultValueWrapper and TimeoutWrapper to wrappers table
AGENTS.md line 176: Add DefaultValueWrapper to wrappers list
All files: Version numbers currently at 0.2.8, need update to 0.3.0 before release

Detailed Findings: README.md

README.md Line-by-Line Review

✅ Accurate Sections

Lines 1-19: Library Overview

✅ Correctly describes monorepo structure with py-key-value-aio and py-key-value-sync
✅ Feature list is accurate (verified against codebase)
✅ Backend list matches implemented stores

Lines 20-91: Value to Framework Authors

✅ Excellent real-world example with FastMCP
✅ Code examples are syntactically correct
✅ Protocol usage examples are accurate

Lines 93-110: "Why not use this library?" section

✅ Accurately describes ManagedEntry wrapper objects
✅ Beartype environment variable is correct (PY_KEY_VALUE_DISABLE_BEARTYPE)
✅ "No Live Objects" caveat is accurately described

Lines 111-147: Installation & Quick Start

✅ Package names are correct
✅ Backend extras are accurate

❌ Line 138 BUG: Variable name mismatch

# Current (INCORRECT):
value = await store.get(key="123", collection="users")
# Should be:
value = await key_value.get(key="123", collection="users")

Lines 149-176: Protocols

✅ Protocol descriptions are accurate
✅ Method signatures match actual implementation
✅ Path references are correct

Lines 177-236: Stores Tables

✅ All 16 stores are documented correctly:
- Local: Memory, Disk, MultiDiskStore, Null, RocksDB, Simple, Windows Registry (7)
- Secret: Keyring, Vault (2)
- Distributed: DynamoDB, Elasticsearch, Memcached, MongoDB, Redis, Valkey (6)
✅ Stability levels match codebase
✅ Async/Sync availability is correct
✅ Examples are accurate

Lines 237-250: Adapters

✅ Both adapters (PydanticAdapter, RaiseOnMissingAdapter) are documented
✅ Descriptions are accurate
✅ Code examples work correctly

Lines 290-315: Wrappers

❌ Missing wrappers in table:
- DefaultValueWrapper exists in codebase at key-value-aio/src/key_value/aio/wrappers/default_value/wrapper.py
- TimeoutWrapper is used in code example (line 327) but not documented in table
✅ Otherwise complete list of 15 documented wrappers
✅ Descriptions are accurate
✅ Examples are correct

Lines 316-335: Wrapper Stacking Example

⚠️ Uses TimeoutWrapper which is not documented in the wrappers table above
✅ Otherwise demonstrates correct wrapper composition pattern

Lines 341-394: Advanced Patterns & Atomicity

✅ Code examples are syntactically correct
✅ Architecture patterns are well explained

Lines 396-411: Sync Library & Project Links

✅ Sync library description is accurate
❌ Line 411: Says "MIT licensed" but LICENSE file and pyproject.toml show "Apache License 2.0"

Detailed Findings: AGENTS.md

AGENTS.md Line-by-Line Review

✅ Accurate Sections

Lines 1-4: File Purpose

✅ Clear distinction between AGENTS.md and DEVELOPING.md
✅ Appropriate audience targeting

Lines 6-29: Development Workflow & Testing

✅ All make commands are accurate (make lint, make typecheck, make codegen, make precommit)
✅ Test commands match Makefile
✅ Testing requirements are correct

Lines 30-55: Architecture & Monorepo Structure

✅ Async-first development constraint is correctly emphasized
✅ Directory structure is accurate
✅ Codegen script path is correct

Lines 57-72: Code Style & Conventions

✅ Ruff configuration details are accurate
✅ Line length (140 chars) matches pyproject.toml
✅ Basedpyright strict mode is correct
✅ Beartype environment variable is accurate
✅ Python version requirement (3.10+) is correct

Lines 74-112: Common Pitfalls

✅ ManagedEntry description is accurate
✅ Python version compatibility warning is appropriate
✅ Optional dependencies examples are correct
✅ Sync package generation warning is clear

Lines 114-140: Make Commands Reference

✅ All commands match actual Makefile targets
✅ Per-project command examples are correct

Lines 142-191: Protocols, Stores, Wrappers, Adapters

✅ Protocol descriptions are accurate
✅ Store locations are correct
✅ Lists all major backend types
❌ Line 176: Wrappers list missing DefaultValueWrapper (exists at key-value-aio/src/key_value/aio/wrappers/default_value/wrapper.py)
✅ Adapter descriptions are complete

Lines 193-230: Development Environment & CI/CD

✅ DevContainer recommendation is appropriate
✅ Prerequisites are accurate
✅ Setup command (make sync) is correct
✅ GitHub Actions workflows are accurately described

Lines 222-236: Version Management & Help

✅ Version bump commands are accurate
✅ Cross-references to other docs are correct

Detailed Findings: DEVELOPING.md

DEVELOPING.md Line-by-Line Review

✅ All Sections Accurate

Lines 1-7: Overview

✅ Package descriptions are accurate
✅ Sync generation mention is correct

Lines 8-21: Prerequisites

✅ DevContainer option is documented
✅ Local development requirements are accurate
✅ Python 3.10 requirement is correct for sync codegen

Lines 22-26: Setup

✅ make sync command is correct

Lines 28-76: Common Commands

✅ All lint, typecheck, test, and build commands match Makefile
✅ Per-project examples are accurate
✅ Convenience targets (test-aio, test-sync, test-shared) are correct

Lines 78-92: Generate/Update Sync Package

✅ make codegen command is accurate
✅ Notes about auto-linting are correct
✅ Warning about differing extras is appropriate

Lines 94-101: Pre-commit Checks

✅ make precommit runs lint, typecheck, and codegen (verified in Makefile line 122)

Lines 103-118: CI Usage

✅ YAML examples are appropriate for CI workflows
✅ Per-project operation examples are accurate

Lines 120-126: Project Layout

✅ Directory paths are all correct
✅ Script references are accurate

Lines 128-131: Releasing

✅ "TBD" is honest and appropriate

💡 Potential Enhancements (Optional)

Could add reference to make help command (exists in Makefile)
Could add version bumping commands documented in AGENTS.md

Verification Details

Codebase Verification

Stores verified (16 total):

$ ls key-value-aio/src/key_value/aio/stores/
disk  dynamodb  elasticsearch  keyring  memcached  memory  
mongodb  null  redis  rocksdb  simple  valkey  vault  
windows_registry

Wrappers verified (17 directories):

$ ls key-value-aio/src/key_value/aio/wrappers/
compression  default_value  encryption  fallback  limit_size  
logging  passthrough_cache  prefix_collections  prefix_keys  
read_only  retry  routing  single_collection  statistics  
timeout  ttl_clamp

License verified:

$ head -3 LICENSE
                                 Apache License
                           Version 2.0, January 2004

Current versions (all packages at 0.2.8):

key-value-aio/pyproject.toml:3:version = "0.2.8"
key-value-sync/pyproject.toml:3:version = "0.2.8"
key-value-shared/pyproject.toml:3:version = "0.2.8"
key-value-shared-test/pyproject.toml:3:version = "0.2.8"

Related Issues and Pull Requests

Repository	Issue/PR	Relevance
strawgate/py-key-value	#124 - More detailed documentation	Related documentation enhancement; MkDocs setup in PR #128
strawgate/py-key-value	#127 - Add agents.md file	AGENTS.md was added via PR #130 (merged)
strawgate/py-key-value	#106 - Elaborate on value to framework authors	Framework author section added to README via PR #107
strawgate/py-key-value	PR #128 - Add comprehensive MkDocs documentation	Open PR adding detailed wrapper/adapter docs
strawgate/py-key-value	PR #130 - Add AGENTS.md file	Merged - added AGENTS.md file

Action Plan for 0.3.0 Release

High Priority (Fix Before Release)

README.md Line 138 - Fix variable name bug:

# Change from:
value = await store.get(key="123", collection="users")
# To:
value = await key_value.get(key="123", collection="users")

README.md Line 411 - Fix license statement:

# Change from:
MIT licensed.
# To:
Apache 2.0 licensed.

README.md Wrappers Table (around line 298-314) - Add missing wrappers:

| DefaultValueWrapper | Return a default value when key is missing. | `DefaultValueWrapper(key_value=memory_store, default_value={})` |
| TimeoutWrapper | Add timeout protection to store operations. | `TimeoutWrapper(key_value=redis_store, timeout=5.0)` |

AGENTS.md Line 176 - Update wrappers list:

# Add to list after "Retry":
Wrappers include: Compression, DefaultValue, Encryption, Logging, Statistics, Retry,
Timeout, Cache, Prefix, TTL clamping, and more.

Version Bump - Update all pyproject.toml files from 0.2.8 to 0.3.0:
```
make bump-version VERSION=0.3.0
```

Medium Priority (Recommended)

DEVELOPING.md - Add make help reference in Common Commands section
README.md - Consider adding a table of contents for easier navigation

Low Priority (Optional Enhancements)

Add "last updated" dates to documentation files
Consider adding a CHANGELOG.md for 0.3.0 release notes
Cross-link the three documentation files more explicitly

Summary

Overall Assessment: The documentation is in excellent shape ✅

The three documentation files (README.md, AGENTS.md, DEVELOPING.md) work well together to serve different audiences effectively. Issues identified:

✅ Architecture documentation: 100% accurate
✅ Workflow documentation: 100% accurate
✅ Store/Adapter documentation: 100% accurate
⚠️ Code examples: 1 variable name bug (line 138)
⚠️ Wrapper documentation: 2 missing from table (DefaultValue, Timeout)
⚠️ License statement: Incorrectly says MIT instead of Apache 2.0
⚠️ Version numbers: Currently 0.2.8, need update to 0.3.0

These are all straightforward fixes that can be completed quickly before the 0.3.0 release. The documentation quality is high and demonstrates good maintenance practices.

In-depth review of Readme, Agents and Developing #136

Description

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

Issue actions