Skip to content

Fix MLMG: adjust face Dirichlet values to match HYPRE cell-centre BCs#240

Merged
jameslehoux merged 1 commit intoworkingfrom
claude/fix-gpu-wheels-build-yptxM
Apr 1, 2026
Merged

Fix MLMG: adjust face Dirichlet values to match HYPRE cell-centre BCs#240
jameslehoux merged 1 commit intoworkingfrom
claude/fix-gpu-wheels-build-yptxM

Conversation

@jameslehoux
Copy link
Copy Markdown

The previous approach of pinning boundary cells after the solve broke flux conservation. Instead, extend the Dirichlet face values outward by half a cell so the resulting cell-centre solution at the boundary cells matches HYPRE's convention (vlo at cell 0, vhi at cell N-1).

For an N-cell domain:
face_lo = vlo - 0.5 * (vhi - vlo) / (N - 1)
face_hi = vhi + 0.5 * (vhi - vlo) / (N - 1)

This produces tau = (N-1)/N for a uniform block, consistent with HYPRE and the analytical benchmark expectation.

The previous approach of pinning boundary cells after the solve broke
flux conservation. Instead, extend the Dirichlet face values outward
by half a cell so the resulting cell-centre solution at the boundary
cells matches HYPRE's convention (vlo at cell 0, vhi at cell N-1).

For an N-cell domain:
  face_lo = vlo - 0.5 * (vhi - vlo) / (N - 1)
  face_hi = vhi + 0.5 * (vhi - vlo) / (N - 1)

This produces tau = (N-1)/N for a uniform block, consistent with
HYPRE and the analytical benchmark expectation.

https://claude.ai/code/session_01RKnn97qiD7sbCeABHH3eQk
@jameslehoux jameslehoux merged commit 931aba3 into working Apr 1, 2026
4 of 6 checks passed
@github-actions
Copy link
Copy Markdown

github-actions Bot commented Apr 1, 2026

Code Coverage Report

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                           GCC Code Coverage Report
Directory: .
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
File                                       Lines     Exec  Cover   Missing
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
src/io/CathodeWrite.cpp                       95       83    87%   40-41,97-100,115-116,182-185
src/io/CathodeWrite.H                          1        1   100%
src/io/DatReader.cpp                         135      105    77%   26-27,30,35,92-93,99-100,107-109,135-137,141,144-148,152-155,162,164,208-209,242,245
src/io/DatReader.H                             1        1   100%
src/io/HDF5Reader.cpp                        344       84    24%   40-41,43-44,46-49,52,54-56,58-59,62,64-66,68-74,92-93,126-128,144-145,154-157,174-180,182-187,204,213-215,217,219-228,230-233,236-238,240-251,253-258,266,266,266,266,266,266,266,270,270,270,270,270,270,270,274,276,278,280,282,288,290,297,297,297,297,297,297,297,301,301,301,301,301,301,301,305,305,305,305,305,305,305-306,306,306,306,306,306,306,309,309,309,309,309,309,309-310,310,310,310,310,310,310-311,311,311,311,311,311,311,313,313,313,313,313,313,313-314,314,314,314,314,314,314-315,315,315,315,315,315,315,319,319,319,319,319,319,319,324,324,324,324,324,324,324-325,325,325,325,325,325,325-326,326,326,326,326,326,326-327,327,327,327,327,327,327,332,332,332,332,332,332,332,337,337,337,337,337,337,337-338,338,338,338,338,338,338,343,343,343,343,343,343,343,350,350,350,350,350,350,350,357-358,432-435,437-440
src/io/HDF5Reader.H                            3        3   100%
src/io/ImageLoader.cpp                        61       42    68%   25,38,48,60-62,64-70,72,77,89-90,92,94
src/io/RawReader.cpp                         266      135    50%   49-50,89-90,111-112,115-117,120-121,140-142,155-157,166-168,174-177,185-186,192-196,200-204,209-212,219-224,231-237,271,273-274,276,283-284,301,312,314,318,325,327,331-334,338,346-347,353-355,361-363,365-366,369,372,374,377-380,382-384,386,388-389,391,393-394,396,398-399,401,403-404,406,410-411,413,417-418,420,425,465,471-472,521-524,538,540-542,544,546-548,558,562-564,566,588
src/io/RawReader.H                             1        1   100%
src/io/TiffReader.cpp                        384      130    33%   59-65,67-69,71-73,75-77,79-80,82-84,86-88,90-92,94-96,98-99,101-103,106-108,111-112,114-117,119,122,124-127,143-144,148-150,152-158,160,186,210,217,226,228-231,240,242-245,248,255,288-293,306,309-317,319-320,323-327,331-335,338-342,344-348,351-357,359-363,367,369,375-377,379-393,396,398-402,404-409,413-418,420-425,428-429,432-434,555-575,577-578,581-588,590,593-609,612-614,670,673-674,677-683,685,689-700,702-703
src/io/TiffReader.H                            5        5   100%
src/props/BoundaryCondition.H                131       74    56%   63,68,70,216,224-229,233-236,238-244,247-249,252-253,255,258-261,264-265,271-272,274-279,285-287,290-296,299,303,365-366,371,373
src/props/ConnectedComponents.cpp             69       67    97%   94-95
src/props/ConnectedComponents.H                4        4   100%
src/props/DeffTensor.cpp                      62       59    95%   122,128-129
src/props/Diffusion.cpp                      510      378    74%   93-94,97-98,103-104,106-116,118,123-132,134-141,144-150,153-157,159-163,165,168-173,175-177,179,182-184,186-187,190-191,193,195-198,200,202-203,288-289,297-298,300,349,359-360,368-371,373-375,404-413,415,453,461,465-467,526-527,533,535,539,547,581,610,638,646,735-736,739-740,757-760,771-772,774,824
src/props/EffDiffFillMtx.H                   120      106    88%   58,216-217,221-225,229,231-235
src/props/EffectiveDiffusivityHypre.cpp      389      347    89%   189-191,193-197,305,367-370,479,612-615,617-619,621-624,633-636,643,672,684-687,689-691,693,705,716,718
src/props/EffectiveDiffusivityHypre.H          7        7   100%
src/props/FloodFill.cpp                       84       81    96%   94-95,203
src/props/HypreStructSolver.cpp              344      210    61%   87-88,121,133-134,145,299,309,311,314,346,356,358,361,367-370,372-376,378-379,381-385,388-389,391-392,394,397-398,401-402,404-407,409-413,415-416,418-422,425-426,428-429,431,434-435,438-439,441-443,445-451,453-457,460-461,463-464,466,469-470,473,475-477,479-486,488-492,495-496,498-499,501,504-505,508,510-512,514-517,519-523,526-527,529-530,532,535-536,539,542-543,556
src/props/HypreStructSolver.H                  6        6   100%
src/props/MacroGeometry.H                     17       17   100%
src/props/ParticleSizeDistribution.cpp        11       11   100%
src/props/ParticleSizeDistribution.H           6        6   100%
src/props/PercolationCheck.cpp                53       46    86%   32-33,49-51,68,73
src/props/PercolationCheck.H                   4        4   100%
src/props/PhysicsConfig.H                     90       89    98%   150
src/props/ResultsJSON.H                      225      222    98%   242,395,416
src/props/REVStudy.cpp                       151      128    84%   72,83-91,159,170-173,175,183-186,188-190
src/props/SolverConfig.H                      32       20    62%   30,32,37-44,75-76
src/props/SpecificSurfaceArea.cpp             56       55    98%   59
src/props/SpecificSurfaceArea.H                6        6   100%
src/props/ThroughThicknessProfile.cpp         38       38   100%
src/props/ThroughThicknessProfile.H            5        5   100%
src/props/Tortuosity.H                         2        2   100%
src/props/TortuosityDirect.cpp               219      191    87%   81-83,86,100-106,113-114,125,134,140,202-209,226,394,424,433
src/props/TortuosityDirect.H                   5        5   100%
src/props/TortuosityHypre.cpp                784      563    71%   148-149,154-155,239-242,245-247,310,334-336,339-340,342,352-354,357-359,389-392,572,596,600,621,637-638,640-642,644-653,655,658-662,666-668,671-678,680-684,688-690,692-694,696-705,707-711,713-724,726-729,731,741,747-750,752-754,763-766,768-770,786,789-790,813-818,829-832,834,871,876-879,882-884,888-891,893,895-898,900,905-907,909,958,967,972,975-980,996-999,1013-1017,1022-1027,1037-1041,1046-1051,1056-1060,1063-1066,1073-1076,1087,1096,1098,1102,1104,1126,1157-1158,1244-1246,1372-1375
src/props/TortuosityHypre.H                   15       15   100%
src/props/TortuosityHypreFill.H              127       98    77%   85,203,205-212,237-239,241-245,247-248,250,252,255-256,258-262
src/props/TortuosityKernels.H                 97       53    54%   52,56-60,62-65,69-74,76-80,84-85,90,129,143,157,243,245-248,250-253,257-260,262-265
src/props/TortuosityMLMG.cpp                 113        0     0%   28,33,35,37-40,42-43,45-48,50,55,58,63-64,66,71-74,76-77,80,96-98,101-103,106,108-111,114,116,121-128,130,132,135,138,141,144-146,156,158,168-173,179-184,190-196,199,207-212,214,216,219,222-223,226-229,231,233-237,239-240,242-243,246-247,250,252-255,259-260,263-264
src/props/TortuosityMLMG.H                     1        0     0%   67
src/props/TortuositySolverBase.cpp           301        0     0%   40,46-52,54-55,57,61,64,67,69-72,74-75,77,80,85-88,90-91,94-101,104,106-107,110,113,115,122-124,126-127,130,134,136-138,140,142-145,148-152,154,157,159,166-169,171,173,175-182,184-186,188-190,193-195,197,200,203,205,208,210-211,213-217,219-221,223-224,226-232,234-239,241,243-252,255,259-264,266,268-277,280,283-286,288-289,291,293-296,298,302-303,305-306,309,312-318,320,322-325,327,332-334,336-340,342-343,345-355,357-358,360-361,364-365,367-370,372-376,379-380,382-386,388,391,394-396,398,406-409,411-417,420-422,425-429,432,434-436,438-440,443,446-454,458-460,463-465,467,469-471,473-476,478,482,486-490,492,495-502,504-506,508,512-513,518-519
src/props/TortuositySolverBase.H              13        0     0%   69,84-85,87-88,90-91,99-100,102-103,105-106
src/props/VolumeFraction.cpp                  25       25   100%
src/props/VolumeFraction.H                     4        4   100%
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TOTAL                                       5422     3532    65%
------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Generated by CI — coverage data from gcovr

@codecov
Copy link
Copy Markdown

codecov Bot commented Apr 1, 2026

Codecov Report

❌ Patch coverage is 0% with 10 lines in your changes missing coverage. Please review.

Files with missing lines Patch % Lines
src/props/TortuosityMLMG.cpp 0.00% 10 Missing ⚠️

📢 Thoughts on this report? Let us know!

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant