fix: board header presence label uses username over email consistently (#683)

[Chris0Jeky]

Summary

• Add normalizePresenceMembers() in BoardView.vue that replaces the current user's displayName with the locally-known sessionStore.username before applying any incoming SignalR presence snapshot
• This prevents the idle→editing identity label switch where the server sends an email address (demo@taskdeck.local) while the local seed uses the short username (demo)
• Other collaborators' display names are left unchanged
• Closes UX-25: Board header presence label should not switch between username and email formats #683

Test plan

• Unit test: current user email displayName is replaced with username in presence snapshot
• Unit test: other members' displayNames are left unchanged
• Unit test: snapshots for unrelated boards are ignored (regression guard)
• All 1547 existing vitest tests pass
• Manual: sign in as demo, open a board, verify label shows demo — open a card, verify label still shows demo (editing) not demo@taskdeck.local (editing)

[chatgpt-codex-connector]

You have reached your Codex usage limits for code reviews. You can see your limits in the Codex usage dashboard.
To continue using code reviews, you can upgrade your account or add credits to your account and enable them for code reviews in your settings.

[Chris0Jeky]

Self-review findings

Logic correctness

• normalizePresenceMembers guards on !currentUserId || !currentUsername and returns members unchanged — correct. The only edge case where normalization silently skips is if the session loses its username mid-session, which cannot happen while the user is actively on the board.
• Matching is by userId, not by displayName string comparison, so the replacement is stable even if the server changes what it sends as displayName in the future.
• Other collaborators are passed through unmodified — only the current user's entry is normalized.

Type safety

• currentUsername is narrowed to string by the early-return guard before being assigned to displayName: string | null — no type coercion needed.

Bonus improvement

• If the server sends null as displayName for the current user (instead of their email), the normalization now replaces it with username — better than the previous behavior where null would fall back to userId.slice(0, 8) in the template.

Minor fix applied post-review

• Removed a stray blank line between the two presence helper functions (cosmetic only).

No real issues found.

[Copilot]

Pull request overview

Updates the board presence handling in BoardView to keep the current user’s identity label stable (username vs email) when SignalR presence snapshots arrive, addressing the idle→editing label switch reported in #683.

Changes:

• Added normalizePresenceMembers() in BoardView.vue to force the current user’s presence displayName to sessionStore.username when applying presence snapshots.
• Updated presence snapshot handling to store/use the normalized member list.
• Added vitest coverage for current-user normalization, “other member unchanged”, and “ignore other board snapshot” regression cases.

Reviewed changes

Copilot reviewed 2 out of 2 changed files in this pull request and generated no comments.

File	Description
frontend/taskdeck-web/src/views/BoardView.vue	Normalizes current user presence displayName before updating local/store presence state.
frontend/taskdeck-web/src/tests/views/BoardView.spec.ts	Adds unit tests validating normalization behavior and board scoping of snapshots.

---

💡 Add Copilot custom instructions for smarter, more guided reviews. Learn how to get started.

[gemini-code-assist]

Code Review

This pull request addresses issue #683 by implementing display name normalization in BoardView.vue to ensure the current user's identity label remains consistent. It also adds unit tests to verify this normalization and ensure snapshots for other boards are ignored. Feedback suggests centralizing the normalization logic in a store or utility for better reusability.

[gemini-code-assist]

While this normalization logic correctly addresses the issue in BoardView, it might be more robust to handle this transformation within the boardStore or a shared utility. If other views eventually display presence data, they would benefit from a centralized normalization of the current user's display name. However, for the current scope of fixing the idle-to-editing label switch in this component, this implementation is functional.

[Chris0Jeky]

Adversarial review — PR #744 (fix/#683 board header presence label)

Summary

The fix is correct and safe. All 1544 frontend unit tests pass locally. Detailed findings below.

---

CI failures

API Integration fails on both ubuntu and windows — this is a pre-existing failure unrelated to this PR. The root cause is AuthControllerEdgeCaseTests.cs (lines 278, 291, 308): new AuthController(authService.Object, CreateGitHubSettings(false)) passes only 2 arguments but the current AuthController constructor requires 3 (AuthenticationService, GitHubOAuthSettings, IUserContext). The CI also fails on the main branch for the same commits that merged before this PR was opened — confirmed by checking gh run list --branch main. This is a pre-existing defect in the test suite and does not block this frontend-only PR.

---

Adversarial checklist

1. Does the fix handle sessionStore.username being null/empty?
Yes. normalizePresenceMembers guards with if (!currentUserId || !currentUsername) return members — passing the snapshot through unchanged when either value is absent. This is the correct fallback: don't replace with null, leave the server value as-is.

2. Could normalization run before sessionStore is hydrated?
No. normalizePresenceMembers is only invoked from the onPresenceChanged callback, which fires when a SignalR message arrives over the network — always after App.vue's onMounted has called restoreSession(). The closure references the Pinia store reactively, so it always reads the current value. No race condition.

3. Are the tests asserting the right thing?
Yes. The tests capture the onPresenceChanged callback via the createBoardRealtimeController mock, then fire it with synthetic snapshots and assert on setBoardPresenceMembers.mock.calls. The assertions verify exact member payloads including editingCardId preservation (important: confirms the fix doesn't drop the editing state). The "other boards ignored" test verifies the existing boardId guard, not just that the function runs.

One gap: there is no test for the username === null path through normalizePresenceMembers when a snapshot arrives. The existing "null session" test covers the seed/mount path only. This is low risk given the guard's simplicity, but adding it would complete coverage.

4. Are there other places in the codebase with the same bug?
BoardToolbar.vue is the only renderer of presence member labels (member.displayName || member.userId.slice(0, 8)). It receives presenceMembers as a prop passed from BoardView, which is now always the normalized array. boardStore.setBoardPresenceMembers has only one call-site that passes raw server data (the onPresenceChanged handler in BoardView) — that is now normalized before being passed. No other views or components consume boardPresenceMembers from the store directly for rendering.

5. Does the fix break multi-user boards?
No. normalizePresenceMembers only mutates the entry for userId === sessionStore.userId. Other collaborators' displayName values are passed through unchanged. Confirmed by the "leaves other members unchanged" test.

6. Does the fix affect the presence seed on mount?
The seed path (currentUserPresenceSeed) already uses sessionStore.username directly and is unaffected. The normalizePresenceMembers function is only called in the snapshot handler, not for the seed.

---

Minor findings (no action required)

• Gemini bot suggestion (centralizing normalization in the store or a shared utility) is a reasonable long-term refactor but unnecessary for this scoped fix. setBoardPresenceMembers has exactly one upstream caller that deals with server data, so there is no current duplication risk.
• The PR description says "1547 existing vitest tests pass" — local run shows 1544. This is a test count drift from prior merges and is not a problem.

---

Verdict

Approved for merge once the pre-existing AuthControllerEdgeCaseTests.cs CI failure is tracked. That failure existed on main before this branch was created and is unrelated to this change. The frontend fix is correct, well-tested, and does not regress any existing behavior.