Skip to content

Rm housing evals#174

Merged
saucetray merged 3 commits intoComputerScienceHouse:masterfrom
mxmeinhold:rm-housing-evals
Nov 24, 2019
Merged

Rm housing evals#174
saucetray merged 3 commits intoComputerScienceHouse:masterfrom
mxmeinhold:rm-housing-evals

Conversation

@mxmeinhold
Copy link
Contributor

@mxmeinhold mxmeinhold commented Oct 6, 2019

Check one:

  • Semantic Change: something about the meaning of the text is different
  • Non-semantic Change: Spelling, grammar, or formatting changes.

Summary of change(s):

Deletes bad references to Housing Evals, makes housing points automatic. Also updates constitution to current process.

* Describe our current process
* Use 1 (one) housing point rather than 2 since we don't do 1-3 now
* Fix broken references
@saucetray
Copy link
Member

LGTM 🎆 🍾

@nicholastmosher
Copy link

In theory this should fix the state of the points system, but in practice this will only work starting with incoming freshmen. I think that housing points should not need to be "accumulated", but instead that they should simply be a property of your membership that is derived from the number of years you've been an active member. This would make a difference in a case like myself, where I have already "missed" housing points in the past.

  • Under this proposed amendment as-is, I would - from this point forward - always receive my 2 housing points each year. However, since I "missed" housing points in the past under the old system, I still only have 4 housing points.
  • Under the "derived points" system, the number of points I have is simply calculated from the number of years I've been a member (i.e. years since passing my first spring evals). If the calculation is simply "number of years as a member * 2", then I would have (8 points? 10 points? depending on whether points get added at the beginning or end of the year)

I'm in favor of a "derived points" system because it eliminates the edge case where people missed housing points from the old (and broken) points system.

@mxmeinhold mxmeinhold added Ballot Pending Discussion has occurred, but ballots have yet to be issued and removed Needs Discussion labels Nov 3, 2019
@mxmeinhold mxmeinhold added Ballot Passed and removed Ballot Pending Discussion has occurred, but ballots have yet to be issued labels Nov 14, 2019
@mxmeinhold
Copy link
Contributor Author

Handed out: 61
Yes: 58
No: 2
Abstain: 1

@saucetray saucetray merged commit f34706a into ComputerScienceHouse:master Nov 24, 2019
@mxmeinhold mxmeinhold deleted the rm-housing-evals branch April 9, 2020 00:42
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants