refactor(watch): change watch footer to match jesusfilm.org#5422
Conversation
|
Caution Review failedThe pull request is closed. WalkthroughThis pull request reworks the Watch site footer. The changes include a major update to the Footer component and its tests, introducing dynamic rendering from internal link arrays and a unified FooterLink component. Several legacy footer subcomponents and their tests (FooterLinks, FooterLogos, FooterSocials) have been removed. In addition, the FooterLink component was enhanced with an optional styling property and adjusted default settings, and localization keys have been restructured. New documentation files outlining product requirements for the footer redesign have also been added. Changes
Sequence Diagram(s)sequenceDiagram
participant U as User
participant B as Browser
participant F as Footer Component
participant FL as FooterLink Component
U->>B: Request page view
B->>F: Load and render Footer
F->>FL: Iterate through navigationLinks and render each link
F->>FL: Iterate through socialLinks and render each link
F-->>B: Return complete Footer with Donation & Newsletter elements
U->>B: Interact with rendered links/buttons
Warning There were issues while running some tools. Please review the errors and either fix the tool’s configuration or disable the tool if it’s a critical failure. 🔧 ESLint
apps/watch/src/components/Footer/Footer.tsxOops! Something went wrong! :( ESLint: 8.57.1 TypeError: Key "rules": Key "react/jsx-indent": Could not find plugin "react". 📜 Recent review detailsConfiguration used: CodeRabbit UI ⛔ Files ignored due to path filters (5)
📒 Files selected for processing (2)
✨ Finishing Touches
Thanks for using CodeRabbit! It's free for OSS, and your support helps us grow. If you like it, consider giving us a shout-out. 🪧 TipsChatThere are 3 ways to chat with CodeRabbit:
Note: Be mindful of the bot's finite context window. It's strongly recommended to break down tasks such as reading entire modules into smaller chunks. For a focused discussion, use review comments to chat about specific files and their changes, instead of using the PR comments. CodeRabbit Commands (Invoked using PR comments)
Other keywords and placeholders
CodeRabbit Configuration File (
|
tataihono
added
priority: now
type: feat
tataihono
changed the title
tataihono
added
type: refactor
|
The latest updates on your projects.
|
|
The latest updates on your projects.
|
|
The latest updates on your projects.
|
|
The latest updates on your projects.
|
|
The latest updates on your projects.
|
![coderabbitai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/347564?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 1
🧹 Nitpick comments (9)
apps/watch/src/components/DownloadDialog/DownloadDialog.tsx (1)
94-94: Improved code robustness with optional chaining.Adding optional chaining (
?.) when accessingmobileCinematicHighfromimages[0]prevents potential runtime errors ifimages[0]is undefined. This enhances the application's stability and is a best practice for defensive programming.Consider extending this pattern to other potentially nullable references in the component, such as
imageAlt[0]in line 105, for consistent error handling:- alt={imageAlt[0].value} + alt={imageAlt[0]?.value ?? ''}libs/journeys/ui/src/components/SearchBar/SearchDropdown/SearchbarDropdown.tsx (1)
123-123: Consider using theme-based spacing for better maintainabilityReplacing theme-based spacing with hard-coded pixel values reduces maintainability. If theme spacing changes in the future, this component won't automatically adapt.
- padding: `3px 6px 0 8px`, + padding: `${theme.spacing(0.375)} ${theme.spacing(0.75)} 0 ${theme.spacing(1)}`,apps/watch/src/components/Footer/Footer.spec.tsx (2)
72-81: Consider adding a test ID for the Give Now button.While testing by text content works, adding a specific test ID to the Give Now button in the component would make the test more resilient to text changes.
- const giveNowButtons = screen.getAllByText('Give Now') + const giveNowButtons = screen.getAllByTestId('give-now-button')And in the component:
<Button data-testid="give-now-button">Give Now</Button>
83-97: Contact information test could be more robust.The current test simply checks for the presence of text. Consider adding more specific tests for proper formatting and structure of the address information.
- const addressLines = screen.getAllByText('100 Lake Hart Drive') + const addressSection = screen.getByTestId('contact-info') + expect(addressSection).toHaveTextContent('100 Lake Hart Drive') + expect(addressSection).toHaveTextContent('Orlando, FL, 32832')apps/watch/src/components/VideosPage/FilterList/LanguagesFilter/LanguagesFilter.tsx (1)
28-35: Consider adding more spacing between language items.For better readability, especially when both local and native names are displayed, consider adding some padding between the typography elements.
- <Stack> + <Stack spacing={0.5}>prds/ENG-1939.md (2)
15-60: Comprehensive functional requirements with responsive design considerationsThe functional requirements are detailed and specific, covering all necessary elements for the footer redesign including logo, social media integration, navigation, CTAs, and responsive design. This provides clear guidance for implementation.
There is a minor grammatical issue in line 59 where it appears a preposition might be missing before "across all device sizes", but this doesn't affect the understanding of the requirement.
- Maintain proper layout and readability across all device sizes + Maintain proper layout and readability across all device sizes🧰 Tools
🪛 LanguageTool
[uncategorized] ~36-~36: Possible missing preposition found.
Context: ..." button in the top right position - Link to the donation page on jesusfilm.org ...(AI_HYDRA_LEO_MISSING_TO)
[misspelling] ~40-~40: Did you mean “hard”?
Context: ...y the organization's address: "100 Lake Hart Drive, Orlando, FL, 32832" - Include...(HART_HARD)
[uncategorized] ~59-~59: Possible missing preposition found.
Context: ...g to both desktop and mobile views - Maintain proper layout and readability across al...(AI_HYDRA_LEO_MISSING_TO)
161-161: Minor grammatical issue in testing strategyThere's a minor grammatical issue with "device sizes" - the noun "device" should be pluralized or have an article.
- Ensure proper display across various device sizes + Ensure proper display across various device sizes🧰 Tools
🪛 LanguageTool
[grammar] ~161-~161: Possible agreement error. The noun ‘device’ seems to be countable; consider using: “various devices”.
Context: ...Testing**: Ensure proper display across various device sizes 3. Accessibility Testing: Val...(MANY_NN)
apps/watch/src/components/Footer/Footer.tsx (2)
143-157: Implement data-testid for the Give Now buttonThe "Give Now" button is missing a data-testid attribute which would be helpful for testing.
<Button component="a" href="/how-to-help/ways-to-donate/give-now/?amount=&frequency=single&campaign-code=NXWJPO&designation-number=2592320&thankYouRedirect=/dev/special/thank-you-refer/social-share/" variant="contained" color="primary" size="small" + data-testid="GiveNowButton" sx={{ p: '8px 13px 7px', borderRadius: 20, lineHeight: '1.1334', height: '34px' }} > {t('Give Now')} </Button>
210-226: Add data-testid for newsletter buttonThe newsletter signup button is missing a data-testid attribute which would be helpful for testing.
<Button component="a" href="/email/" variant="contained" size="small" + data-testid="NewsletterButton" sx={{ backgroundColor: '#333', color: 'white', p: '8px 13px 7px', borderRadius: 20, lineHeight: '1.1334', height: '34px' }} > {t('Sign Up For Our Newsletter')} </Button>
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Plan: Pro
⛔ Files ignored due to path filters (32)
apps/watch/pages/fonts/Apercu-Pro-Bold.woff2is excluded by!**/*.woff2apps/watch/pages/fonts/Apercu-Pro-BoldItalic.woff2is excluded by!**/*.woff2apps/watch/pages/fonts/Apercu-Pro-Medium.woff2is excluded by!**/*.woff2apps/watch/pages/fonts/Apercu-Pro-MediumItalic.woff2is excluded by!**/*.woff2apps/watch/pages/fonts/Apercu-Pro-Regular.woff2is excluded by!**/*.woff2apps/watch/public/footer/facebook.svgis excluded by!**/*.svgapps/watch/public/footer/instagram.svgis excluded by!**/*.svgapps/watch/public/footer/jesus-film-logo.pngis excluded by!**/*.pngapps/watch/public/footer/x-twitter.svgis excluded by!**/*.svgapps/watch/public/footer/youtube.svgis excluded by!**/*.svgapps/watch/public/watch/assets/fonts/apercu_bold.eotis excluded by!**/*.eotapps/watch/public/watch/assets/fonts/apercu_bold.otfis excluded by!**/*.otfapps/watch/public/watch/assets/fonts/apercu_bold.svgis excluded by!**/*.svgapps/watch/public/watch/assets/fonts/apercu_bold.ttfis excluded by!**/*.ttfapps/watch/public/watch/assets/fonts/apercu_bold.woffis excluded by!**/*.woffapps/watch/public/watch/assets/fonts/apercu_bold.woff2is excluded by!**/*.woff2apps/watch/public/watch/assets/fonts/apercu_light.eotis excluded by!**/*.eotapps/watch/public/watch/assets/fonts/apercu_light.svgis excluded by!**/*.svgapps/watch/public/watch/assets/fonts/apercu_light.ttfis excluded by!**/*.ttfapps/watch/public/watch/assets/fonts/apercu_light.woffis excluded by!**/*.woffapps/watch/public/watch/assets/fonts/apercu_light.woff2is excluded by!**/*.woff2apps/watch/public/watch/assets/fonts/apercu_regular.otfis excluded by!**/*.otfapps/watch/public/watch/assets/fonts/apercu_regular.svgis excluded by!**/*.svgapps/watch/public/watch/assets/fonts/apercu_regular.ttfis excluded by!**/*.ttfapps/watch/public/watch/assets/fonts/apercu_regular.woffis excluded by!**/*.woffapps/watch/public/watch/assets/fonts/apercu_regular.woff2is excluded by!**/*.woff2apps/watch/src/components/Footer/FooterLogos/assets/cru.svgis excluded by!**/*.svgapps/watch/src/components/Footer/FooterLogos/assets/jesus-film.svgis excluded by!**/*.svgapps/watch/src/components/Footer/FooterSocials/assets/facebook.svgis excluded by!**/*.svgapps/watch/src/components/Footer/FooterSocials/assets/instagram.svgis excluded by!**/*.svgapps/watch/src/components/Footer/FooterSocials/assets/twitter.svgis excluded by!**/*.svgapps/watch/src/components/Footer/FooterSocials/assets/youtube.svgis excluded by!**/*.svg
📒 Files selected for processing (28)
apps/watch/pages/_app.tsx(4 hunks)apps/watch/public/watch/assets/fonts/fonts.css(0 hunks)apps/watch/src/components/DownloadDialog/DownloadDialog.tsx(1 hunks)apps/watch/src/components/Footer/Footer.spec.tsx(1 hunks)apps/watch/src/components/Footer/Footer.tsx(1 hunks)apps/watch/src/components/Footer/FooterLink/FooterLink.spec.tsx(1 hunks)apps/watch/src/components/Footer/FooterLink/FooterLink.tsx(3 hunks)apps/watch/src/components/Footer/FooterLinks/FooterLinks.spec.tsx(0 hunks)apps/watch/src/components/Footer/FooterLinks/FooterLinks.tsx(0 hunks)apps/watch/src/components/Footer/FooterLinks/index.ts(0 hunks)apps/watch/src/components/Footer/FooterLogos/FooterLogos.spec.tsx(0 hunks)apps/watch/src/components/Footer/FooterLogos/FooterLogos.tsx(0 hunks)apps/watch/src/components/Footer/FooterLogos/index.ts(0 hunks)apps/watch/src/components/Footer/FooterSocials/FooterSocials.spec.tsx(0 hunks)apps/watch/src/components/Footer/FooterSocials/FooterSocials.tsx(0 hunks)apps/watch/src/components/Footer/FooterSocials/index.ts(0 hunks)apps/watch/src/components/VideoCard/VideoCard.tsx(5 hunks)apps/watch/src/components/VideoContentPage/VideoContent/VideoContent.tsx(1 hunks)apps/watch/src/components/VideoContentPage/VideoHero/VideoHeroOverlay/VideoHeroOverlay.tsx(1 hunks)apps/watch/src/components/VideosPage/FilterList/FilterList.tsx(3 hunks)apps/watch/src/components/VideosPage/FilterList/LanguagesFilter/LanguagesFilter.tsx(1 hunks)libs/journeys/ui/src/components/SearchBar/SearchDropdown/SearchbarDropdown.tsx(2 hunks)libs/journeys/ui/src/components/SearchBar/SearchDropdown/Suggestions/Suggestion/Suggestion.tsx(1 hunks)libs/locales/en/apps-watch.json(0 hunks)libs/shared/ui/src/libs/themes/website/tokens/components.tsx(2 hunks)libs/shared/ui/src/libs/themes/website/tokens/typography.ts(4 hunks)prds/A-README.md(1 hunks)prds/ENG-1939.md(1 hunks)
💤 Files with no reviewable changes (11)
- apps/watch/src/components/Footer/FooterSocials/index.ts
- apps/watch/src/components/Footer/FooterLogos/index.ts
- libs/locales/en/apps-watch.json
- apps/watch/public/watch/assets/fonts/fonts.css
- apps/watch/src/components/Footer/FooterLogos/FooterLogos.spec.tsx
- apps/watch/src/components/Footer/FooterLinks/index.ts
- apps/watch/src/components/Footer/FooterLinks/FooterLinks.tsx
- apps/watch/src/components/Footer/FooterLogos/FooterLogos.tsx
- apps/watch/src/components/Footer/FooterSocials/FooterSocials.tsx
- apps/watch/src/components/Footer/FooterSocials/FooterSocials.spec.tsx
- apps/watch/src/components/Footer/FooterLinks/FooterLinks.spec.tsx
✅ Files skipped from review due to trivial changes (1)
- prds/A-README.md
🧰 Additional context used
🪛 LanguageTool
prds/ENG-1939.md
[uncategorized] ~36-~36: Possible missing preposition found.
Context: ..." button in the top right position - Link to the donation page on jesusfilm.org ...
(AI_HYDRA_LEO_MISSING_TO)
[misspelling] ~40-~40: Did you mean “hard”?
Context: ...y the organization's address: "100 Lake Hart Drive, Orlando, FL, 32832" - Include...
(HART_HARD)
[uncategorized] ~59-~59: Possible missing preposition found.
Context: ...g to both desktop and mobile views - Maintain proper layout and readability across al...
(AI_HYDRA_LEO_MISSING_TO)
[grammar] ~161-~161: Possible agreement error. The noun ‘device’ seems to be countable; consider using: “various devices”.
Context: ...Testing**: Ensure proper display across various device sizes 3. Accessibility Testing: Val...
(MANY_NN)
⏰ Context from checks skipped due to timeout of 90000ms (15)
- GitHub Check: visual-test (22)
- GitHub Check: danger (22)
- GitHub Check: danger (22)
- GitHub Check: danger (22)
- GitHub Check: Deploy Preview and Test (watch, 5422/merge, pull_request, 22)
- GitHub Check: Deploy Preview and Test (videos-admin, 5422/merge, pull_request, 22)
- GitHub Check: Deploy Preview and Test (journeys-admin, 5422/merge, pull_request, 22)
- GitHub Check: Deploy Preview and Test (journeys, 5422/merge, pull_request, 22)
- GitHub Check: Deploy Preview and Test (arclight, 5422/merge, pull_request, 22)
- GitHub Check: test (22, 3/3)
- GitHub Check: test (22, 2/3)
- GitHub Check: build (22)
- GitHub Check: test (22, 1/3)
- GitHub Check: lint (22)
- GitHub Check: Analyze (javascript)
🔇 Additional comments (57)
apps/watch/pages/_app.tsx (4)
6-7: Good addition of Next.js font system.The integration of the Next.js font system with
next/font/googleandnext/font/localis an excellent approach for managing typography in your application.
28-61: Well-structured font configuration with comprehensive weight and style coverage.The font configuration is thorough and well-structured:
notoSerifis properly configured with specific weights and subsetsapercuProis comprehensively defined with multiple weights and styles, including regular, medium, medium italic, bold, and bold italic variantsThis robust configuration ensures consistent typography across the application.
89-95: Effective implementation of CSS variables for font families.The global styles approach using CSS variables is a best practice that:
- Makes the fonts accessible throughout the application
- Maintains a single source of truth for font definitions
- Enables easy theme switching and consistency
<style jsx global>{` :root { --font-noto-serif: ${notoSerif.style.fontFamily}; --font-apercu-pro: ${apercuPro.style.fontFamily}; } `}</style>This implementation aligns with modern CSS architecture principles.
96-159: Component structure preserved while enhancing font management.The component structure has been properly maintained while integrating the new font system. The wrapping with React fragments allows for the addition of global styles without disrupting the component hierarchy.
apps/watch/src/components/VideoContentPage/VideoHero/VideoHeroOverlay/VideoHeroOverlay.tsx (1)
147-147: Typography variant update enhances visual hierarchy.Changing the typography variant from "body1" to "h6" for the video duration improves the visual hierarchy and ensures consistency with the typography system across the application. This aligns with the footer redesign objectives mentioned in the PR.
apps/watch/src/components/VideoContentPage/VideoContent/VideoContent.tsx (2)
124-126: Enhanced visual prominence of discussion question indices.Increasing the
minHeightandminWidthfrom 38 to 42 pixels for the circular index container improves the visual presence and readability of the discussion question numbers, making them more prominent in the UI.
132-132: Typography hierarchy improvement for question numbering.Changing the typography variant from "h6" to "h5" for the question index numbers enhances the typographic hierarchy and ensures better visual prominence. This change works well with the increased container size and aligns with the font system updates introduced in the application.
libs/journeys/ui/src/components/SearchBar/SearchDropdown/Suggestions/Suggestion/Suggestion.tsx (3)
38-40: Typography variant and weight update for better semanticsThe change from numeric font weight (1000) to semantic weight ("bold") improves readability and maintainability. The addition of the h6 variant also provides better semantic structure to the component.
41-45: Typography variant update improves hierarchyAdding the h6 variant to this Typography component ensures consistent heading styles with other components while maintaining the existing padding and text wrapping behavior.
47-48: Consistent typography hierarchy appliedChanging the variant from body1 to h6 maintains visual consistency with the other typography elements in this component, creating a more cohesive design.
libs/shared/ui/src/libs/themes/website/tokens/components.tsx (2)
78-78: Consistent font family application using CSS variablesThe addition of the font family using CSS variables aligns with modern CSS practices and ensures consistent typography across input components. This supports the footer redesign objective mentioned in the PR by maintaining typographic consistency.
89-89: Consistent font application for input labelsSimilar to the input component, adding the font family using CSS variables to the input labels ensures visual consistency. This is a good practice for maintaining design system coherence.
libs/journeys/ui/src/components/SearchBar/SearchDropdown/SearchbarDropdown.tsx (1)
153-161: Improved layout structure for tabsThe restructuring of the LocalTabsHeader component with flexbox properties improves alignment and visual hierarchy. The addition of
justifyContent: "center"ensures better centered alignment of the tab content.apps/watch/src/components/VideosPage/FilterList/FilterList.tsx (3)
158-158: Consistent typography for better visual hierarchyAdding the h6 variant to the "Languages" label improves the visual hierarchy and maintains consistency with the typography updates across the application.
170-170: Consistent typography for better visual hierarchyAdding the h6 variant to the "Subtitles" label maintains consistency with other headings in the component.
183-183: Consistent typography for better visual hierarchyAdding the h6 variant to the "Title" label completes the consistent styling approach across all filter categories, creating a cohesive visual experience.
apps/watch/src/components/Footer/FooterLink/FooterLink.tsx (5)
2-2: Good addition of SxProps import.This import correctly supports the new styling capabilities being added to the component.
19-19: Good addition of the sx prop to the component interface.Adding the
sxprop allows for flexible styling customization from parent components, enhancing the component's reusability.
31-32: Good code formatting with improved readability.The proper line breaks and parameter organization make the component more readable and maintainable.
45-47: Good implementation of Typography with sx prop.The Typography component correctly uses the sx prop and properly handles the component's content.
25-25:Details
❓ Verification inconclusive
Default variant change from 'body1' to 'h6' needs verification.
This is a significant change that affects the visual styling of all footer links that don't explicitly override the variant. Ensure this aligns with the new footer design in the PRD and verify it looks correct across all instances.
🏁 Script executed:
#!/bin/bash # Search for all usage of FooterLink to ensure variant isn't explicitly set in most places rg -C 3 "FooterLink" --type tsx | grep -i "variant"Length of output: 77
Verification Required: Confirm FooterLink Variant Update
The original change—frombody1toh6as the default variant inFooterLink.tsx—can affect the styling of footer links. Please run the updated search script above to verify that no component usage is explicitly overriding the variant. Once you manually confirm that FooterLink usages do not set the variant (or that any explicit settings are aligned with the design requirements in the PRD), the change can be approved.
🏁 Script executed:
#!/bin/bash # Re-run the search targeting .tsx files explicitly to check for explicit variant settings in FooterLink usage rg -g '*.tsx' "FooterLink" -C 3 | grep -i "variant"Length of output: 355
Verify FooterLink Default Variant Update
The code search confirms that the only reference to the
variantproperty is withinFooterLink.tsx—with the default set to'h6'—and no component usage explicitly overrides it. Given that this change impacts the visual styling of footer links, please ensure that'h6'as the default aligns with the PRD's new footer design and has been visually verified in all instances.libs/shared/ui/src/libs/themes/website/tokens/typography.ts (5)
113-114: Improved text readability with serif font and adjusted line height.Adding a serif font family (
var(--font-noto-serif)) for body text and increasing the line height improves readability, especially for longer text blocks. The line height increase from 21px to 28px provides better spacing between lines.
119-120: Consistent font styling for body2.Good addition of the serif font to body2 while maintaining the same line height. This creates consistency between body text styles.
124-125: Clear documentation and proper overrides for overline styles.The added comments clearly explain why the font family needs to be overridden, and the implementation correctly applies the apercu font to maintain the intended design for overline text.
Also applies to: 137-138
87-89:Details
❓ Verification inconclusive
Significant changes to h6 styling that need verification.
The h6 styling has been substantially modified:
- Font size reduced from 21px to 16px
- Font weight reduced from 700 to 500
- Line height adjusted
Verify this matches the design specifications and check the visual impact across the application, especially with the FooterLink default variant changing to 'h6'.
🏁 Script executed:
#!/bin/bash # Find all usage of h6 variant in the codebase rg -C 3 "variant=\"h6\"" --type tsxLength of output: 63
The previous command errored due to the unrecognized file type "tsx". Please re-run the above script to manually verify the usages of the "h6" variant in the codebase.
🏁 Script executed:
#!/bin/bash # Revised search for the "h6" variant usage in TypeScript React files using a glob pattern. rg -C 3 'variant="h6"' --glob '*.tsx'Length of output: 37016
Action Required: Verify Updated h6 Styling Across Components
The updated h6 typography in
libs/shared/ui/src/libs/themes/website/tokens/typography.ts(lines 87–89) now sets:
fontSize: 16fontWeight: 500lineHeight: pxToRem(28, 16)A recent search for usages of
variant="h6"uncovered its application in a number of components (e.g., dashboards, settings, footers, video cards, etc.). Considering the impact on elements such as the FooterLink (now defaulting to h6), please manually verify that these visual changes match the design specifications and work well across the application.
37-37:Details
❓ Verification inconclusive
Good migration to CSS variables for font family.
Using CSS variables (
var(--font-apercu-pro)) instead of hardcoded font stacks improves maintainability and consistency across the application. Make sure these variables are properly defined in your global styles.
🏁 Script executed:
#!/bin/bash # Check if the CSS variable is defined in the application rg -C 3 "--font-apercu-pro" --type css # Also check for definitions in _app.tsx or other root files rg -C 5 "--font-apercu-pro" --type tsxLength of output: 917
Below is a revised review comment incorporating a note to recheck the actual global definitions of the CSS variable. Since our earlier shell script call failed due to quoting issues, please re-run the verification (using an updated shell script) to confirm that your global styles actually define
--font-apercu-pro.
CSS Variable Usage Verified – Please Confirm Global Definitions
Good migration to CSS variables for the font family. The update to use
fontFamily: 'var(--font-apercu-pro)',improves maintainability and consistency across the app. However, please ensure that the variable
--font-apercu-prois properly defined in your global styles (for example, in your base CSS/SCSS or your root _app.tsx).Next Steps:
- Re-run an updated verification command such as:
# Search for usage in CSS files rg -C 3 'var(--font-apercu-pro)' --type css # Search for a possible definition (e.g. in a :root declaration) rg -C 3 '--font-apercu-pro:' --type css # Optionally check in TSX files too rg -C 5 'var(--font-apercu-pro)' --type tsx- Confirm that an appropriate definition exists in your global styles.
Below is an updated shell script to re-verify that the CSS variable is defined properly in your global styles. The previous script failed due to quoting issues. Please run the following commands:
Once you confirm that
--font-apercu-prois defined in your global styles (or within your root _app.tsx and similar files), the migration to CSS variables can be considered successful.Next Steps:
- Verify that the expected output shows a proper definition (likely within a
:root { ... }block) in your CSS files.- Confirm that the TSX files reference the variable correctly via
var(--font-apercu-pro).Thank you for ensuring the consistency and maintainability of your typography tokens!
🏁 Script executed:
#!/bin/bash # Search for usage of the variable in CSS files rg -C 3 "var(--font-apercu-pro)" --type css # Check for the definition of the variable (e.g., in a :root or similar declaration) rg -C 3 "--font-apercu-pro:" --type css # Optionally, inspect TSX files for usage to ensure it’s consistently applied rg -C 5 "var(--font-apercu-pro)" --type tsxLength of output: 702
Below is an updated review comment asking for manual verification of the global CSS variable definition. Note that the previous commands ran into quoting issues and file type recognition problems. Please run the updated verification script below to confirm that the CSS variable is defined in your global styles (for example, within a
:root { ... }block).CSS Variable Definition Verification Required
Good migration to CSS variables for the font family. Changing to
fontFamily: 'var(--font-apercu-pro)',improves maintainability and consistency across the application. However, please ensure that the global definition for
--font-apercu-prois present (e.g., in your base CSS in a:root { ... }block or in your root component styles).• Next Steps:
- Run the updated verification commands above.
- Confirm that your CSS files include a definition like
--font-apercu-pro: ...in a globally scoped selector.Once you have manually verified that the variable is defined and applied as intended, the migration can be considered complete.
🏁 Script executed:
#!/bin/bash # Search all CSS files for usage of the variable rg -C 3 -- "var(--font-apercu-pro)" -g '*.css' # Search all CSS files for the variable's definition (e.g., in a :root declaration) rg -C 3 -- "--font-apercu-pro:" -g '*.css' # Optionally, check TSX files for its usage (if applicable) rg -C 5 -- "var(--font-apercu-pro)" -g '*.tsx'Length of output: 529
Action Required – Please Manually Verify Global Definition of
--font-apercu-proThe migration to using a CSS variable for the font family:
fontFamily: 'var(--font-apercu-pro)',is a good move for maintainability and consistency. However, our automated script did not return any confirmations regarding the actual definition of
--font-apercu-proin your CSS files. This might be due to file naming conventions or location differences (for example, if your global styles are in SCSS or another non-.cssfile).
- Next Steps:
- Manually verify that your global styles (e.g., in a
:root { ... }block in CSS/SCSS, or in your _app.tsx) include the definition for--font-apercu-pro.- If the variable isn’t defined, please add it to ensure the CSS variable works as intended.
- If it is defined elsewhere (e.g., in a SCSS file), consider updating the verification command or documentation for clarity.
apps/watch/src/components/Footer/Footer.spec.tsx (5)
6-11: Good test coverage for the Jesus Film logo.The test correctly verifies both the presence of the logo and its link behavior.
13-48: Comprehensive testing of social media links.This test case thoroughly checks all social media links, including their:
- Presence in the DOM
- Correct href attributes
- Proper target attributes for external links
This is an excellent approach to ensure these critical navigation elements work correctly.
50-70: Well-structured navigation links test with data-driven approach.The test uses a data-driven approach with an array of link definitions, which makes it easy to maintain. If navigation links change in the future, only the array needs to be updated rather than the test logic.
117-123: Good test for newsletter section.The test correctly verifies the presence of the newsletter signup and its link destination.
99-114:Details
❓ Verification inconclusive
Verify the legal links URLs are correct.
The test is checking for relative URLs ('/privacy/' and '/legal/'). Ensure these paths are correct and match the actual deployment URLs for these pages.
🏁 Script executed:
#!/bin/bash # Check if these routes are properly defined in the application rg -C 3 "/privacy|/legal" --type tsx | grep -i "route\|path"Length of output: 90
Verify Legal Links Route Definitions
The test confirms that the Footer component's legal links reference '/privacy/' and '/legal/', but our initial search for these routes in the codebase failed due to a file type recognition error with TSX files. Please manually verify that your routing configuration (in your TSX files) indeed defines these paths as expected. If needed, adjust your search (for example, add a TSX file type definition using
--type-add 'tsx:*.tsx') to ensure that the routes match the deployment URLs.
- Check your TSX route configuration files to see if the routes are defined exactly as '/privacy/' and '/legal/'.
- Update the test or configuration if discrepancies are found.
apps/watch/src/components/VideosPage/FilterList/LanguagesFilter/LanguagesFilter.tsx (4)
15-38: Well-implemented Option component for improved language selection.The new
Optioncomponent enhances the language selector with better styling and a clear visual hierarchy between local and native language names. The use of Typography with appropriate variants improves readability.
43-67: Good migration to updated Material UI patterns.Refactoring from
InputPropstoslotProps.inputfollows current Material UI best practices. This change improves the component's compatibility with future MUI updates.
69-75: Clean and concise component implementation.The refactored
LanguagesFiltercomponent is well-structured and makes good use of component composition by passing theOptioncomponent as therenderOptionprop. This improves code readability and maintainability.
51-64:Details
❓ Verification inconclusive
Ensure proper TypeScript typing for slotProps.
The
slotPropsimplementation looks correct, but verify that TypeScript doesn't show any errors for this structure, as Material UI has specific typing requirements for slot props.
🏁 Script executed:
#!/bin/bash # Check if there are any TypeScript errors related to slotProps in the codebase rg -C 3 "slotProps.*Type" --type tsLength of output: 37
Action: Manual Verification Required for TypeScript SlotProps Types
The inline slotProps implementation appears correct, and the initial search did not reveal any type errors. However, the absence of output from the grep command suggests that manual confirmation is advisable to ensure Material UI’s strict typing requirements for slot props are met.
- Location to Check:
apps/watch/src/components/VideosPage/FilterList/LanguagesFilter/LanguagesFilter.tsx(lines 51-64)- Next Step: Please verify that the TypeScript definitions used for
slotPropsalign with Material UI’s expected types, ensuring no hidden type errors are present.apps/watch/src/components/VideoCard/VideoCard.tsx (5)
180-182: Typography styling enhancements applied consistentlyThe addition of explicit font styling properties (fontWeight, fontSize, lineHeight) for the video title helps ensure visual consistency with the jesusfilm.org design as specified in the footer redesign project.
238-238: Typography variant standardizationUpdating to variant="h6" for the "Playing now" text aligns with the typography standardization throughout the application, matching the jesusfilm.org design system.
254-261: Typography variant consistency for duration textThe update to use variant="h6" for the duration text ensures consistent styling with other text elements in the component, improving the overall visual harmony.
265-267: Typography standardization for child count labelUsing variant="h6" for the childCountLabel brings consistency to the UI elements within the video card, aligning with the design standards established in the footer redesign project.
294-301: Enhanced typography for expanded variant titlesThe updated typography properties for the expanded variant title ensure visual consistency with the contained variant, creating a cohesive experience regardless of the card's display mode. The explicit font sizing and weight values match the jesusfilm.org styling guidelines.
apps/watch/src/components/Footer/FooterLink/FooterLink.spec.tsx (4)
7-11: Updated test to reflect relative path linking and security attributesThe test case now correctly uses relative paths for internal links and verifies the presence of the "noopener" rel attribute, which is an important security best practice for external links.
16-24: Updated image link tests with proper dimensions and attributesThe test now uses the correct path structure for footer icons ("/footer/facebook.svg") and appropriate dimensions (24x24) as specified in the PRD. The addition of the noFollow prop is also properly tested.
26-30: Enhanced assertion for image and link attributesThe test now properly checks for the alt attribute on images and verifies that external links have both nofollow and noopener attributes, which align with SEO best practices and security requirements.
33-44: Added test coverage for custom stylingThis new test case verifies that the FooterLink component can accept and apply custom styles through the sx prop, which is essential for the flexible styling requirements outlined in the PRD document.
prds/ENG-1939.md (7)
1-9: Well-structured PRD with clear problem statementThe document provides a comprehensive overview of the footer redesign project with a clear problem statement that establishes the need for consistency between the Watch site and jesusfilm.org.
63-76: Well-defined non-functional requirementsThe non-functional requirements appropriately address performance, accessibility, and internationalization concerns, which are critical for a global application like the Watch site.
80-99: Clear design specifications with component structureThe design specifications provide a clear structure for the footer layout, color scheme, and component architecture, making implementation straightforward.
102-131: Thorough technical considerations and implementation decisionsThe technical considerations section provides detailed implementation guidance, including the technology stack, code structure, and key implementation decisions. This ensures consistency in the development approach.
134-156: Detailed component usage instructionsThe component usage section provides clear examples of how to use the Footer and FooterLink components, which is valuable for developers working on this and future projects.
159-188: Complete testing strategy and success metricsThe document includes a comprehensive testing strategy and clear success metrics, ensuring that the implementation can be properly validated against the requirements. The implementation status confirms that the redesign has been successfully completed.
🧰 Tools
🪛 LanguageTool
[grammar] ~161-~161: Possible agreement error. The noun ‘device’ seems to be countable; consider using: “various devices”.
Context: ...Testing**: Ensure proper display across various device sizes 3. Accessibility Testing: Val...(MANY_NN)
40-40:Details
✅ Verification successful
Verify address accuracy
The address mentions "Lake Hart Drive" which the static analysis flagged as potentially being "Lake Hard Drive". Please verify this is the correct address.
🌐 Web query:
Is there a "Lake Hart Drive" in Orlando, FL?💡 Result:
Yes, Lake Hart Drive exists in Orlando, Florida. Multiple organizations and institutions are located along this road, primarily at 100 Lake Hart Drive and nearby addresses in the 32832 ZIP code. Key entities include:
- Cru (Campus Crusade for Christ International), a global Christian ministry headquartered at 100 Lake Hart Drive[1][4][6][7][10].
- Jesus Film Project, offering free guided tours at the same address[2].
- Harvest Community Church, located at 11002 Lake Hart Drive, hosting bilingual Sunday services[3].
- Reliant Mission, a support-based missionary organization at 11002 Lake Hart Drive, Suite 100[5].
The street is also listed in real estate databases, such as Zillow, confirming its presence[9]. Organizations along Lake Hart Drive span religious ministries, community services, and missionary operations, all clustered in the same Orlando area.
Citations:
- 1: https://www.crufoundation.org/contact/
- 2: https://www.jesusfilm.org/about/tour/
- 3: https://harvestflorida.org
- 4: https://db.ministrywatch.com/ministry.php?ein=956006173
- 5: https://reliant.org/contact
- 6: https://www.cru.org/us/en/about.html
- 7: https://www.cru.org/us/en/about/contact-us.html
- 8: https://www.mk2mk.org/contact
- 9: https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/100-Lake-Hart-Dr-Orlando-FL-32832/123470841_zpid/
- 10: https://epicmovement.com/contact/
Verified: "Lake Hart Drive" is Accurate
The web query confirmed that "Lake Hart Drive" exists in Orlando, FL, and notably at the address "100 Lake Hart Drive" as referenced. No changes are required in the snippet.
🧰 Tools
🪛 LanguageTool
[misspelling] ~40-~40: Did you mean “hard”?
Context: ...y the organization's address: "100 Lake Hart Drive, Orlando, FL, 32832" - Include...(HART_HARD)
apps/watch/src/components/Footer/Footer.tsx (6)
16-28: Well-structured navigation links arrayThe navigationLinks array is well-organized and follows the structure specified in the PRD. Using the translation function (t) for each link name ensures proper internationalization support.
30-51: Comprehensive social media links with iconsThe socialLinks array includes all required social platforms (X/Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, YouTube) with their correct URLs and icon paths, matching the requirements in the PRD.
54-158: Well-structured upper section with responsive layoutThe upper section of the footer includes all required elements (logo, social media icons, navigation links, and "Give Now" button) with a responsive layout that adapts to different screen sizes. The order properties ensure proper stacking on mobile devices.
77-84: Logo implementation with proper linkingThe Jesus Film logo is correctly implemented with proper dimensions and linked to the homepage as specified in the PRD.
98-117: Dynamic social media links with hover effectsThe social media links are dynamically generated from the socialLinks array, and include hover scaling effects as required in the PRD. The use of noFollow is good for SEO best practices.
160-227: Well-organized lower section with required elementsThe lower section includes all required elements (address, contact information, legal links, and newsletter signup) in a responsive layout. The use of Stack components with proper spacing creates a clean and organized appearance.
|
Merge conflict attempting to merge this into stage. Please fix manually. |
tataihono
changed the title
…lmorg' of https://github.com/JesusFilm/core into tataihono/eng-1939-changing-the-footer-to-match-jesusfilmorg
|
Merge conflict attempting to merge this into stage. Please fix manually. |
…-pro-bold-medium-or-noto' into tataihono/eng-1939-changing-the-footer-to-match-jesusfilmorg
|
Merge conflict attempting to merge this into stage. Please fix manually. |
|
Merge conflict attempting to merge this into stage. Please fix manually. |
tataihono
deleted the
tataihono/eng-1939-changing-the-footer-to-match-jesusfilmorg
branch
2 participants
This PR implements the new footer design for the Watch site to match jesusfilm.org as specified in the PRD. It includes: new Footer component implementation, updated FooterLink component, removal of old components, comprehensive PRD documentation, and updated tests.
Changes
Documentation
prds/ENG-1939.mdprds/A-README.mdexplaining the purpose and structure of PRDsCode Cleanup
Implementation
Summary by CodeRabbit