Skip to content

v0.3.2 — notgalen full Konclude parity (Phase 2e)

Choose a tag to compare

@micheldumontier micheldumontier released this 05 Jun 22:02
· 234 commits to main since this release

Highlights

notgalen MISSED 18 → 0 — full Konclude parity. The corpus completeness gap is now just SIO's 2 out-of-EL pairs. FP=0 held across the entire corpus.

Phase 2e — functional super-role witness-merge (#15)

The saturator's witness-merge rule back-propagated the merged synthetic to a subject's other functional-sub-role witnesses but skipped the merge-triggering role, wrongly assuming CR9 covered it (CR9 only lifts the original witness up to the super-role; it never pushes the merged synthetic down to the triggering sub-role). When an existential body lives on that sub-role — notgalen's Anonymous-349 ⊑ ∃hasIntrinsicPathologicalStatus.pathological, where hasIntrinsicPathologicalStatus/hasPathologicalStatus are siblings under the functional StatusAttribute — the merged filler must land there. Which sub-role triggers depends on processing order, so GALEN hit the good order (closed in 2d) while notgalen's equiv-vs-subclass structure hit the bad one, leaving 18 pairs unrecovered through Phases 2a–2d.

Fix: drop the skip. Sound by functionality of R_f (every sub-role witness coincides with the single R_f-successor carrying the full merged atom set). Verified three ways: saturator = rustdl tableau (minimal module) = Konclude (9 corpus ontologies).

Corpus gate (FP=0 throughout)

Fixture FP MISSED
alehif 0 0
galen 0 0
notgalen 0 18 → 0
ro 0 0
shoiq-knowledge 0 0
ore-10908-sroiq 0 0
sulo 0 0
sio 0 2 (out-of-EL)
ore-15672-shoin 0 0

Also included

  • #14 — sub-tableau-caching lever scoping; corrects the stale "Lever C is dead" roadmap finding (the build-a-model premise is stale for the wedge, but the §2 reuse-soundness trap stands; the sound form already ships as the Phase 1b/1c snapshot cache).
  • #13blocks_fired/block_eligible tableau counters + correction of the stale "blocking never fires" roadmap claim.

Full changelog: v0.3.1...v0.3.2