Skip to content

Erdos1038: demote weighted-QR to diagnostic + clarify patch-handoff + Round 19 dispatch log#2

Open
bengoechea wants to merge 3 commits into
agent/codex/erdos-experiments-preserve-2026-05-24from
agent/claude/route-demote-weighted-qr-and-handoff-clarify-20260527
Open

Erdos1038: demote weighted-QR to diagnostic + clarify patch-handoff + Round 19 dispatch log#2
bengoechea wants to merge 3 commits into
agent/codex/erdos-experiments-preserve-2026-05-24from
agent/claude/route-demote-weighted-qr-and-handoff-clarify-20260527

Conversation

@bengoechea
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Erdos #1038 Packet PR

Summary

Route-management housekeeping in response to the Round 18 review outcome. The weighted-QR basis route is demoted from primary to diagnostic only (f64 transform condition ~4.7e16 disqualifies it as a summit-critical certificate); the canonical hyperelliptic basis is named the primary parallel route. MODE2_GIT_HANDOFF.md gains an authoritative patch-handoff block (a sandbox agent that produced a commit must NOT retry push — it emits a format-patch and the local clone applies it). The Round 19 dispatch (Mode 2 end-to-end, posted as Linear comment 348613ea on KEN-5 at 2026-05-28T03:31:02Z) is logged to the Everest playback ledger. Originals of rewritten files archived under Erdos1038/agent-work/archive/. No #1038 claim made.

Packet Identity

```text
Problem: Erdos #1038
Packet ID: PACKET-ERDOS1038-ROUTE-DEMOTE-WEIGHTED-QR-AND-HANDOFF-CLARIFY-20260527-01
Thread: cloud-period-basis-backend
Source round / reviewer: Round 18 outcome (Linear comment 57cef820-68c8-468c-b7fc-c665819e7a9a on KEN-5); route decision by ken-via-claude
Semantic mode: MODE_1_REVIEW_RESEARCH_OPINE
```

(Closest fit; this PR is local route-management housekeeping driven by the Round 18 review outcome. No solve work is claimed.)

Claim Level

```text
[x] 0 - external work product / intent only
[ ] 1 - local synthetic scaffold or harness pass
[ ] 2 - real local certificate receipts consumed
[ ] 3 - local theorem composition over fixed projection
[ ] 4 - local theorem with legitimacy/attainment composition
[ ] 5 - coefficient-facing theorem in explicitly named scope
[ ] 6 - public SOTA comparison verified
[ ] 7 - full #1038 theorem candidate
```

Claim ceiling:

```text
Route management only. This PR documents a route-priority decision (weighted-QR demote)
and an operational policy clarification (patch-handoff chain). No #1038 mathematical claim,
no theorem advance, no Lean compile, no altitude movement, no SOTA comparison.
```

Changed Paths

```text
Erdos1038/PERPLEXITY_FULL_CONTEXT.md (+ Route status as of 2026-05-27 paragraph)
Erdos1038/agent-work/CURRENT_FRONTIER.md (rewrite weighted-QR section as STATUS: DEMOTED)
Erdos1038/agent-work/MODE2_GIT_HANDOFF.md (append patch-handoff chain section)
Erdos1038/agent-work/EVEREST_ROUTE_PLAYBACK.jsonl (+2 rows: route_demote, round_dispatch)
Erdos1038/agent-work/WORK_QUEUE.jsonl (+1 row: demote decision)
Erdos1038/agent-work/MANIFEST.sha256 (refreshed for the 5 files above)
Erdos1038/agent-work/archive/CURRENT_FRONTIER_2026-05-27.md (new — original archived)
Erdos1038/agent-work/archive/MODE2_GIT_HANDOFF_2026-05-27.md (new — original archived)
```

Everest Route Playback

Playback rows added:

```text
evt-20260527-weighted-qr-demote | event_type: route_demote | route: weighted_qr | claim_level: 0 | actor: ken-via-claude
evt-20260528-round-19-dispatch | event_type: round_dispatch | route: canonical_hyperelliptic_basis | claim_level: 0 | actor: ken-via-claude
```

Receipts Consumed

```text
NONE
```

Missing Receipts / Blockers

Round 18 confirmed all six required receipts for the dependent-Vieta image consumer are absent. No change in this PR — receipt production is a future-round local-agent deliverable, not in scope here.

```text
ROOT_BOX.json — absent
ROOT_MULTIPLICITY_LEDGER.json — absent
ORDERED_ROOT_INTERVALS.json — absent
SCALED_VIETA_IMAGE_CONTRACT.json — absent
FIXED_CLOUD_BOUND_CERTIFICATE.json — absent
ATTAINED_WITNESS_TYPED_DUAL_MARGIN_RESULTS.json — absent
```

Verification Performed

```text
$ shasum -a 256 -c Erdos1038/agent-work/MANIFEST.sha256
every listed file: OK (verified by Ken from repo root after c121a41)

$ python3 -c "import json; [json.loads(l) for l in open('Erdos1038/agent-work/EVEREST_ROUTE_PLAYBACK.jsonl') if l.strip()]"
PASS (all rows parse)

$ python3 -c "import json; [json.loads(l) for l in open('Erdos1038/agent-work/WORK_QUEUE.jsonl') if l.strip()]"
PASS (all rows parse)

$ tail -1 Erdos1038/agent-work/EVEREST_ROUTE_PLAYBACK.jsonl | python3 -c "import json,sys; r=json.loads(sys.stdin.read()); print(r['event_type'])"
round_dispatch

$ grep -n "DEMOTED" Erdos1038/agent-work/CURRENT_FRONTIER.md
81:### Route status — weighted-QR: STATUS: DEMOTED — diagnostic only (2026-05-27)

$ ls Erdos1038/agent-work/archive/
CURRENT_FRONTIER_2026-05-27.md
MODE2_GIT_HANDOFF_2026-05-27.md
```

CI checks (Python runner compile / JSON parse / JSONL parse / cargo check / scaffold runner / MANIFEST.sha256) run on push via `.github/workflows/erdos1038-agent-work.yml`. Held-out private artifacts pre-existed; the four files modified in this PR have their hashes refreshed in the manifest.

Scope Tags

```text
[ ] F64_SAMPLED_ONLY
[ ] F64_INTERVAL_CONSTRAINED
[ ] FIXED_PROJECTION_DIRECTED_INTERVAL
[ ] FIXED_ROOT_BOX_DIRECTED_INTERVAL
[ ] WITNESS_TYPED_REGION_DIRECTED_INTERVAL
[ ] INDEPENDENT_COEFFICIENT_BOX_DIRECTED_INTERVAL
[ ] LEAN_PROVEN
[x] SCAFFOLD_ONLY
```

(Scope-tag selection reflects that the underlying #1038 work remains at scaffold; this PR doesn't move scope.)

Forbidden Claims

```text
[x] This PR does not claim #1038 is solved unless claim level 7 is checked and receipts are attached.
[x] This PR does not claim public SOTA movement unless claim level 6+ is checked and public comparison is attached.
[x] This PR does not claim altitude movement unless a local route-map assimilation packet licenses it.
[x] This PR does not treat Linear, Perplexity, Claude, or Comet prose as evidence.
[x] This PR does not turn synthetic fixtures into a real theorem pass.
```

External Review Provenance

```text

  • Round 18 outcome (Linear comment 57cef820-68c8-468c-b7fc-c665819e7a9a on KEN-5) is the proximate cause of the weighted-QR demote and the MODE2_GIT_HANDOFF clarification. Status: locally assimilated as a route-management decision; not used as theorem evidence.
  • Round 19 dispatch (Linear comment 348613ea-3a75-44bd-9a68-84cbf391113a on KEN-5, 2026-05-28T03:31:02Z) is logged in EVEREST_ROUTE_PLAYBACK.jsonl as a round_dispatch event. Status of PC's Round 19 output: NOT YET RECEIVED. When received, it will be INTENT_ONLY until a local EXTERNAL-REVIEW-ASSIMILATION-ROUND_19 packet imports, tests, and decides.
    ```

Per Round 18 review: weighted-QR f64 transform condition ~4.7e16
disqualifies it as a summit-critical certificate. Promote canonical
hyperelliptic basis as primary parallel route. MODE2_GIT_HANDOFF
clarified to document the patch-handoff chain (no push from sandbox).

Originals archived to Erdos1038/agent-work/archive/.

Plan: /Users/kenbengoetxea/.claude/plans/remove-all-items-that-hashed-donut.md
Updates the four entries whose contents changed in e8c8a81
(CURRENT_FRONTIER.md, MODE2_GIT_HANDOFF.md, EVEREST_ROUTE_PLAYBACK.jsonl,
WORK_QUEUE.jsonl). Other entries (including held-out private artifacts
listed in the preservation lane) untouched.
Dispatched Perplexity Computer via Linear KEN-5 comment 348613ea
(2026-05-28T03:31:02Z) for Mode 2 end-to-end Round 19: Track B
(canonical hyperelliptic basis seed) primary + Track A (adversarial
falsifier) parallel. Refreshes MANIFEST.sha256 for the playback file.
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant