Priority Level
Medium
Task Summary
Add unit-test coverage for the pure helpers in .agents/tools/structural_impact.py and clean up two latent issues that get cheap to fix in the same pass: the module-level _REPO_ROOT global and the asymmetric .resolve() between changed-files paths and source-file paths.
Follow-up to PR #567 review feedback from @nabinchha.
Technical Details & Implementation Plan
-
Unit tests — add .agents/tools/tests/test_structural_impact.py covering:
_get_package — engine / config / interface / external paths, including the data-designer vs data-designer-engine substring-precedence ordering
_dedup — collisions on shared label prefixes (regression guard for the bug fixed in bfc5db69)
_collect_source_files — smoke test against a tmp dir with mock packages/<name>/src/... layout
_unknown_package_dirs — synthetic packages outside _KNOWN_PACKAGE_DIRS
-
CI wiring — .agents/tools/ lives outside the three package test suites, so make test won't pick it up. Decide between (a) a new Makefile target, (b) a step in agentic-ci-pr-review.yml / agentic-ci-daily.yml, or (c) folding into an existing CI workflow. Lean toward (b) since the file's own change cadence is tied to the agentic-CI surface.
-
Thread repo_root through helpers — replace the module-level _REPO_ROOT global + global _REPO_ROOT mutation in main() with explicit parameter passing through _collect_source_files, _unknown_package_dirs, _rel, _changed_files_mode, _full_mode. Removes test-time fragility (no need to mutate a global to vary input) and decouples the otherwise-pure helpers from module state.
-
Symmetric path resolution — once helpers take repo_root explicitly, either drop .resolve() on changed_paths (current _changed_files_mode:198) or also .resolve() paths inside _collect_source_files. Latent today because no symlinks live under packages/, but the symmetric form removes a future-divergence trap.
Investigation / Context
PR #567 review thread: #567 (review by @nabinchha and follow-up at #567 (comment))
Relevant prior fixes that justify the test coverage:
bfc5db69 — _dedup 30-char prefix-collision bug (pre-merge)
55f0bdda — changed_node_ids ID-stability bug (pre-merge)
Both bugs were caught during review; tests would have surfaced them earlier and would protect against the most likely future failure mode (graphify API drift at the loose graphifyy==0.4.23 pin).
Dependencies
None
Priority Level
Medium
Task Summary
Add unit-test coverage for the pure helpers in
.agents/tools/structural_impact.pyand clean up two latent issues that get cheap to fix in the same pass: the module-level_REPO_ROOTglobal and the asymmetric.resolve()between changed-files paths and source-file paths.Follow-up to PR #567 review feedback from @nabinchha.
Technical Details & Implementation Plan
Unit tests — add
.agents/tools/tests/test_structural_impact.pycovering:_get_package— engine / config / interface / external paths, including thedata-designervsdata-designer-enginesubstring-precedence ordering_dedup— collisions on shared label prefixes (regression guard for the bug fixed inbfc5db69)_collect_source_files— smoke test against a tmp dir with mockpackages/<name>/src/...layout_unknown_package_dirs— synthetic packages outside_KNOWN_PACKAGE_DIRSCI wiring —
.agents/tools/lives outside the three package test suites, somake testwon't pick it up. Decide between (a) a new Makefile target, (b) a step inagentic-ci-pr-review.yml/agentic-ci-daily.yml, or (c) folding into an existing CI workflow. Lean toward (b) since the file's own change cadence is tied to the agentic-CI surface.Thread
repo_rootthrough helpers — replace the module-level_REPO_ROOTglobal +global _REPO_ROOTmutation inmain()with explicit parameter passing through_collect_source_files,_unknown_package_dirs,_rel,_changed_files_mode,_full_mode. Removes test-time fragility (no need to mutate a global to vary input) and decouples the otherwise-pure helpers from module state.Symmetric path resolution — once helpers take
repo_rootexplicitly, either drop.resolve()onchanged_paths(current_changed_files_mode:198) or also.resolve()paths inside_collect_source_files. Latent today because no symlinks live underpackages/, but the symmetric form removes a future-divergence trap.Investigation / Context
PR #567 review thread: #567 (review by @nabinchha and follow-up at #567 (comment))
Relevant prior fixes that justify the test coverage:
bfc5db69—_dedup30-char prefix-collision bug (pre-merge)55f0bdda—changed_node_idsID-stability bug (pre-merge)Both bugs were caught during review; tests would have surfaced them earlier and would protect against the most likely future failure mode (graphify API drift at the loose
graphifyy==0.4.23pin).Dependencies
None