Problem
Vignette interpretation paragraphs in peace-fwcp.Rmd and
kootenay-lake.Rmd make defensible-sounding claims about temperature
departure — "warming has accelerated/slowed", "summer daytime maximum
is the salmonid thermal envelope", "day-night asymmetry shows up here
unlike X" — but currently land on zero peer-reviewed citations
for those claims. For FWCP fish-passage reporting context, these need
the same cited backing #53 gave the Snowpack section.
Scope
First of three sequential climate-departure lit reviews covering the
non-snow vignette sections (the 3-split: temperature, precipitation +
drying, interpretation framing). Mirrors the #53 / #54 / v0.1.7
pattern verbatim:
- Targeted lit search → candidate list of ~10 papers
- Add to
NewGraphEnvironment/climate Zotero collection (key
8MH9LCC9), PDFs first per /lit-search policy
- Build
data/rag/temperature_methodology.duckdb ragnar store
- Mine for methodology quotes, write
findings.md with "cite this
for that" citation map
- Vignette citation insertion (the
[@key] markers) happens on a
downstream branch, not here
Topics to cover
- Temperature trend methodology — global / NH / BC-specific
- Day-night asymmetry (DTR — diurnal temperature range)
- Tmax vs tmin trends — the established asymmetry that our AOIs
don't always show
- Climate→stream-temperature bridge — link from air-temperature
departure to salmonid thermal stress (the FWCP fish-passage
context bridge)
- Per-ecoregion / mountain-vs-interior warming patterns
- ERA5-Land temperature validation — bias structure (parallel to
snow's Kouki 2023 for SWE)
Starting candidate list (will refine in Phase 1)
| Citation key (proposed) |
Why |
karl_etal1993 |
Foundational DTR / day-night asymmetry (BAMS) |
vose_etal2005 |
DTR over land 1950-2004 |
easterling_etal1997 |
Tmax vs tmin trends (Science) |
vincent_etal2018 (or current CCCS update) |
Canadian temperature trends |
mantua_etal2010 |
PNW climate change impacts on salmon |
eaton_scheller1996 |
Salmonid stream-temp thermal limits (classic) |
isaak_etal2017 |
NorWeST stream temperature model (already in collection) |
mauger_etal2015 |
PNW temperature regional patterns |
mora_etal2013 |
Climate-departure framing (already in collection) |
najafi_etal2017 |
BC attribution methodology (already in snow rag) |
Existing items in climate collection to screen first
19 items already there. Relevant temperature-side starters not to
re-add: mora_etal2013, hersbach_etal2020, munoz_sabater_etal2021,
isaak_etal2017, dierauer_etal2020, warkentin_etal2022,
islam_etal2019, IPCC AR6 WGI/SYR. Link by existing item key, don't
duplicate.
Phases (mirror #53 task_plan)
- Targeted lit search — candidate list, DOI confirmation, OA / RG access
- Add to
NewGraphEnvironment/climate Zotero collection — PDFs first
- Build ragnar DuckDB at
data/rag/temperature_methodology.duckdb
- Mine the store for methodology quotes
- Synthesis + citation map in
findings.md
- PR — squash, NEWS bullet, v0.x.y patch release
Out of scope
Problem
Vignette interpretation paragraphs in
peace-fwcp.Rmdandkootenay-lake.Rmdmake defensible-sounding claims about temperaturedeparture — "warming has accelerated/slowed", "summer daytime maximum
is the salmonid thermal envelope", "day-night asymmetry shows up here
unlike X" — but currently land on zero peer-reviewed citations
for those claims. For FWCP fish-passage reporting context, these need
the same cited backing #53 gave the Snowpack section.
Scope
First of three sequential climate-departure lit reviews covering the
non-snow vignette sections (the 3-split: temperature, precipitation +
drying, interpretation framing). Mirrors the #53 / #54 / v0.1.7
pattern verbatim:
NewGraphEnvironment/climateZotero collection (key8MH9LCC9), PDFs first per/lit-searchpolicydata/rag/temperature_methodology.duckdbragnar storefindings.mdwith "cite thisfor that" citation map
[@key]markers) happens on adownstream branch, not here
Topics to cover
don't always show
departure to salmonid thermal stress (the FWCP fish-passage
context bridge)
snow's Kouki 2023 for SWE)
Starting candidate list (will refine in Phase 1)
karl_etal1993vose_etal2005easterling_etal1997vincent_etal2018(or current CCCS update)mantua_etal2010eaton_scheller1996isaak_etal2017mauger_etal2015mora_etal2013najafi_etal2017Existing items in
climatecollection to screen first19 items already there. Relevant temperature-side starters not to
re-add:
mora_etal2013,hersbach_etal2020,munoz_sabater_etal2021,isaak_etal2017,dierauer_etal2020,warkentin_etal2022,islam_etal2019, IPCC AR6 WGI/SYR. Link by existing item key, don'tduplicate.
Phases (mirror #53 task_plan)
NewGraphEnvironment/climateZotero collection — PDFs firstdata/rag/temperature_methodology.duckdbfindings.mdOut of scope