Federation v1

Federation verdict exchange — format v1 (spec; implementation pending)

Instances share resolved consensus verdicts (never raw votes) as signed JSON. Each importing instance ingests peer verdicts as source='federated' votes, subject to its own consensus thresholds and admin override. Instances export only locally-resolved consensus — never re-broadcast federated votes (no transitive trust / echo amplification).

Participation modes

Three roles, not one monolithic "federation" switch:

• SUBSCRIBER — read-only. Consumes peer verdict feeds (signature verification + import), emits nothing of its own. Zero trust configuration beyond the peer's pinned public key, zero Sybil surface — a subscriber can't poison anyone else's catalog, only choose (badly) what it trusts for its own display/search boost. The lowest-risk, most generically useful half of this whole program — see "Consumer component" below.
• PUBLISHER — emits signed verdicts (export command + keygen), consumes nothing. Requires the full vote/consensus/human-gate stack this fork already has (docs/features/printing-tags.md) — nothing new to build on the export side beyond signing and the file format itself.
• FULL PEER — both. The eventual steady state for a mature, mutually-trusting pair of instances, not a v1 target.

v1 launch posture for ProxyPrints: PUBLISHER-ONLY. We emit verdicts, we consume none. This proves the protocol out — a real signed export file, a real peer able to verify and read it — with zero catalog-integrity risk on our side: nothing a bad or buggy peer publishes can ever reach our own Card/vote tables, because we never import. Consuming is a strictly later, separate decision, gated on both having a peer worth trusting and fixing the gate issue documented below — not before either.

Expected onboarding path for any new participant: subscriber-first. A prospective peer should be able to point at our export feed, verify our signature, and get real value (badge display, search-boost, whatever their own instance does with imported verdicts) before ever standing up their own publish side. Publishing is the higher-trust, higher-effort commitment; nobody should have to build it just to find out whether federation is worth doing at all.

Consumer component — the upstream-shaped chunk

The subscriber half specifically — a verdict table keyed on content_hash (once the cross-instance join logic lands, see "Interchange keys" below), perceptual-hash tooling (Card.content_phash already exists locally), signature verification (ed25519, no dependency beyond what signing itself needs), and a display badge surfacing "N peer instances agree" — is deliberately dependency-free: no vote system, no consensus engine, no moderation stack required. Any mpc-autofill instance could subscribe to a verdict feed and show peer-agreement badges without adopting anything else this fork has built. That makes it the only plausibly upstream-shaped piece of the whole federation program — everything on the publisher side assumes the vote/consensus/moderation stack this fork built that upstream doesn't have. Tracked as a deferred entry (Tier 6) on docs/upstreaming/readiness-audit.md's ladder, gated on federation actually having a live peer to subscribe to — there's nothing real to extract or offer before that exists to prove the format against.

File shape

{
  "schema_version": 1,
  "instance": "<hostname>",
  "public_key": "<ed25519 pubkey, base64>",
  "generated_at": "<ISO 8601>",
  "game": "MTG",
  "verdicts": [
    {
      "image": {
        "drive_id": "<Google Drive file id — the join key>",
        "content_hash": null,          // perceptual hash (imagehash.phash, hash_size=8,
                                        // 64-bit) - now backed by Card.content_phash
                                        // (docs/features/printing-tags.md's hash-at-ingest
                                        // section, 2026-07-16); still v1 nullable, since not
                                        // every instance's backfill will be complete
        "name": "<card name, advisory only>"
      },
      "kind": "printing" | "artist" | "tag",
      "outcome": "scryfall:<uuid>" | "no_match"
                | "artist:<canonical artist name>" | "artist:unknown"
                | "tag:<tag name>:apply" | "tag:<tag name>:reject",
      "resolved_at": "<ISO 8601>",
      "vote_weight": <float — total weight behind the verdict>,
      "human_votes": <int — count of votes NOT from a machine-derived
                      source (VoteSource.DEDUCTION or VoteSource.OCR —
                      the single umbrella VoteSource.AI value this
                      interchange format was designed against was split
                      into these two 2026-07-15, same weight/gate
                      treatment; see cardpicker/models.py's VoteSource
                      docstring). Importers MUST treat human_votes >= 1
                      as the condition for the imported vote to be
                      human-backed for gate purposes>
    }
  ],
  "signature": "<ed25519 over canonical JSON (sorted keys, no whitespace)
                 of all fields above except signature>"
}

Interchange keys & stability contract

• Images join across instances by drive_id (Google Drive file id). content_hash is the planned upgrade path for surviving re-uploads - the field itself (Card.content_phash) and its own local consumer (two-threshold dedup clustering) now exist; the cross-instance join logic that would actually use it for federation is still unbuilt.
• Artists travel by canonical name; tags by Tag.name. Tag names are therefore a cross-instance contract: renaming a Tag is a breaking data migration, not an edit. Tag.name is the immutable interchange key; Tag.display_name is local presentation only and never federates.

Import rules (normative for future implementation)

• Verify signature against a pinned per-peer public key (out-of-band exchange; no open enrollment).
• One voice per peer per (image, kind[, tag]): re-import replaces that peer's prior vote, never stacks.
• Weight: settings.VOTE_FEDERATED_WEIGHT, per-peer override permitted.
• Skip verdicts whose artist/tag can't be matched locally.

Known gate issue (defensive default fixed 2026-07-19; full per-peer design still not built)

The bug (fixed): cardpicker/vote_consensus.py's is_human_backed_source() checks membership in _MACHINE_DERIVED_SOURCES — VoteSource.FEDERATED was not in that set, so is_human_backed_source(VoteSource.FEDERATED) returned True. Fixed: _MACHINE_DERIVED_SOURCES now includes VoteSource.FEDERATED (vote_consensus.py:38, verified directly against current code, 2026-07-19), so is_human_backed_source(VoteSource.FEDERATED) returns False — a federated vote can no longer singlehandedly clear the "at least one human-backed vote" resolution gate. This is the safe, defensive default; VoteTuple.is_human_backed is still caller-supplied per the existing design, so a real importer can still override this explicitly if a peer's own review process has already made a federated verdict genuinely human-backed. The per-peer-promotable design below remains the eventual real mechanism and is still not built.

Implicit-vote weight semantics (pinned 2026-07-22, not yet exported)

VoteSource.IMPLICIT (docs/features/printing-tags.md's implicit-vote section, owner-ratified 2026-07-22 vote-weight scenario matrix) is a new exported semantic that a future federation peer must know about before any importer consuming it exists — pinned here now per the matrix's own federation note, rather than left to be re-derived the day an importer first encounters an implicit-sourced verdict:

• Form shipped: low-weight + per-outcome-group cap, not the "share-only" alternative form the matrix's own drafting also considered and explicitly rejected (that form let implicit weight either break a genuine human tie or veto an otherwise quorum-valid human win, depending on the scenario — never shipped).
• Per-vote weight PRINTING_TAG_IMPLICIT_WEIGHT (default 0.25) counts toward BOTH quorum and share, but the SUM of implicit weight within a single (card, tag, polarity) outcome group is hard-capped at PRINTING_TAG_IMPLICIT_CAP (default 1.0, strictly below PRINTING_TAG_MIN_VOTES) — so no volume of implicit votes on one side can ever supply that side's quorum weight alone.
• is_human_backed=False always, same treatment as DEDUCTION/OCR — an importer must not treat an imported implicit-sourced contribution as human-backed, mirroring this doc's existing FEDERATED guidance above.
• resolve_weighted_consensus's D1/D4 mechanisms (see that function's own docstring, and docs/features/printing-tags.md's "Consensus" bullet) additionally guarantee implicit weight can never decide a live human-vs-human contest nor de-resolve an already-quorum-valid human winner — the same guarantee DEDUCTION/OCR/FEDERATED weight now gets.
• Not yet exported: no federation verdict currently carries an implicit-sourced contribution (implicit votes are a purely local /editor filter-chip signal today, cast via POST 2/castImplicitVote/). If/when a verdict export ever aggregates implicit weight into a vote_weight/human_votes figure, the exported verdict must carry enough information for an importer to reconstruct (or at minimum respect) the cap above under the peer's own thresholds — exporting a raw, uncapped implicit sum would let cross-peer share arithmetic diverge from what this instance itself would have resolved.

Future work: contributor nodes (design note, 2026-07-19 — NOT built)

The pieces already landing for local, non-federated reasons compose into something bigger than any one of them was designed for. Three Stage C/lazy-mode primitives, put together:

1. The per-card callable work unit (cardpicker/image_evidence.py's extract_card_evidence/persist_evidence split, task #145) — fetch → extract → evidence → discard, independent of the bulk runner by construction (FINAL POSTURE item 8a).
2. Manifest-mode segmentation (task #99, still deferred) — running the pipeline against a bounded, caller-supplied card set rather than the whole catalog.
3. Evidence keyed by content hash, not by who computed it (ImageEvidence's (card, content_hash) key) — the store doesn't care whether the hash/OCR/geometry for a given image came from our own harvest or from somewhere else, only that it's correctly keyed.

Together these describe a self-hosted contributor node: a user imports their own deck → the node fetches THEIR OWN images (their own IP, their own Google throttle budget, no shared quota, no API key of ours required — the exact "pull" mode task #161's lazy-identification design note already names) → runs the same extractors locally → phones home with evidence only (hashes, OCR text, geometry/quality classes — never image bytes, posture-clean in both directions, not just ours: the contributor's images never cross the wire either) → the federation verdict-exchange format above (once a subscriber side exists) is the natural transport for that evidence back to us. The phash-cache/evidence-exchange machinery already being built for peer federation doubles as this contributor node's bootstrap protocol — no second transport to design.

This is the lazy-mode principle (task #161: "identification capacity scales with usage, not hardware") taken one step further: identification capacity scales with USERS, not our hardware. Every deck import is a potential free extraction pass on cards we'd otherwise have to harvest ourselves, paced by real user traffic instead of a bulk job competing for our one shared Google quota.

Hardware floor: a Steam-Deck-class x86 Linux machine (real CPU, real Python/Tesseract/Pillow support) is a full contributor node, capable of the whole fetch→extract pipeline. A phone is not — it's a confirmation client only (views evidence, casts votes), not a compute contributor. Any pitch or implementation plan for this should account for that split rather than assuming uniform client capability.

One sentence for the pitch, next time it's edited: "the architecture already permits your users to be the compute."

Not built. Depends on: task #161 (lazy identification mode) landing first, a real subscriber-side federation implementation (this doc's "Consumer component" is currently spec-only), and its own dedicated design pass for node auth/trust (a contributor node is a much higher- Sybil-risk actor than a pinned-key peer instance — evidence from an anonymous contributor node cannot carry the same weight as our own harvest or a trusted peer's signed verdict without a real trust model, not sketched here).

The fix (design only, not implemented): route federated gate treatment through a settings-driven mode, FEDERATED_VOTE_GATE_MODE (default "suggestion" — contributes weight, does not count toward the human-backed gate; promotable to a gate-clearing mode later), mirroring Proposal G's AUTHED_VOTE_GATE_MODE idiom exactly: an env-driven flag plus a dedicated weight/treatment function, never a hand-coded branch scattered through the consensus resolvers (see docs/proposals/proposal-g-user-accounts-saved-decks.md §7 — verified current, not assumed: AUTHED_VOTE_GATE_MODE is actually shipped (resolved for v1 as "status_quo" default, a real setting routed through authed_vote_weight()), so this is a live pattern to mirror, not just a design precedent still waiting to land). Promotion should be per-peer, not one global switch: once a specific peer's verdicts have measured reliability — docs/theory.md's "Relation to Dawid-Skene reliability estimation" section already frames a federation peer as exactly the kind of noisy source that model applies to — that peer's federated votes could be promoted to gate-clearing while an unmeasured new peer stays suggestion-tier by default. Same "defaults off, config not migration" shape require_privileged and the proposed AUTHED_VOTE_GATE_MODE both already use.

Status: defensive default shipped (2026-07-19), full per-peer design not built. Consuming federated votes at all is gated on having a live peer in the first place (see "Participation modes" above) — the per-peer promotion mechanism needs to land before that happens, not before. Recorded here so it isn't rediscovered from scratch whenever import actually gets built.

Status: format committed ahead of code. Export/import commands, keygen, and the peer registry are future work; the schema stub (source='federated', peer field, weight setting, is_human_backed plumbing) ships now.