Problem
User feedback(2026-05-22 LINE/Claude Code session,inline 「順便改」note):
「有些 /ralph-loop 可以改成用 /goal」
IDD plugin 目前有 7 處 ralph-loop reference。Maintainer 需評估哪些可改用 /goal slash command(user 既有的 goal-tracking skill)。
7 處 ref 分類
概念級(3 處,描述「驅動機制」)— 可能可換 /goal
| File |
Line |
Context |
plugins/issue-driven-dev/MANIFESTO.md |
135 |
自動化 caller /loop / ralph-loop / 外部 CI — ralph-loop 作為例子列出 |
plugins/issue-driven-dev/README.md |
215, 223, 224, 228 |
install 指引 + Required for specific modes matrix |
plugins/issue-driven-dev/references/usecase-routing.md |
51 |
ralph-loop 自動驗-修迴圈 機制概念描述 |
Literal binary detect(4 處)— 不換,改了會破 detect 邏輯
| File |
Line |
Context |
plugins/issue-driven-dev/scripts/check-ralph-loop.sh |
full |
wrapper for backward-compat,argv literal ralph-loop |
plugins/issue-driven-dev/scripts/check-plugin-presence.sh |
8, 13, 48 |
usage example + comment reference |
plugins/issue-driven-dev/skills/idd-verify/SKILL.md |
80, 965-977 |
Step 0a fail-fast gate check-ralph-loop.sh |
plugins/issue-driven-dev/skills/idd-all/SKILL.md |
376-403 |
Step 0.6 graceful degrade gate check-ralph-loop.sh |
Open questions for maintainer
/goal 的 contract 是什麼?跟 ralph-loop 重疊到什麼程度?
- 是否
/goal 也能扮演 (PR, unattended) verify-fix loop driver?(若是 → idd-all Phase 0.6 應提 /goal 為 alternative)
- 或
/goal 是 higher-level 而 ralph-loop 是 inner driver?(關係互補,不是 substitution)
- 應該:(a) 概念級 3 處加
/goal 為 also-available alternative;(b) 全部 7 處 deprecate ralph-loop binary detect 改 /goal;(c) 不改,維持 ralph-loop 為唯一 canonical driver?
Type
enhancement / docs(plugin reference cleanup)
Priority
P3 — 影響文件 clarity 不影響 runtime behavior;等 #135 v3 implementation land 後一併評估 unattended-mode 驅動機制全景
Out of scope
本 issue 不 fold 進 #135 spectra change(terminology trust gap)— 兩條 axis 正交,避免 scope creep。
Refs #135 sister concern session
Problem
User feedback(2026-05-22 LINE/Claude Code session,inline 「順便改」note):
IDD plugin 目前有 7 處
ralph-loopreference。Maintainer 需評估哪些可改用/goalslash command(user 既有的 goal-tracking skill)。7 處 ref 分類
概念級(3 處,描述「驅動機制」)— 可能可換 /goal
plugins/issue-driven-dev/MANIFESTO.md自動化 caller /loop / ralph-loop / 外部 CI— ralph-loop 作為例子列出plugins/issue-driven-dev/README.mdplugins/issue-driven-dev/references/usecase-routing.mdralph-loop 自動驗-修迴圈機制概念描述Literal binary detect(4 處)— 不換,改了會破 detect 邏輯
plugins/issue-driven-dev/scripts/check-ralph-loop.shralph-loopplugins/issue-driven-dev/scripts/check-plugin-presence.shplugins/issue-driven-dev/skills/idd-verify/SKILL.mdcheck-ralph-loop.shplugins/issue-driven-dev/skills/idd-all/SKILL.mdcheck-ralph-loop.shOpen questions for maintainer
/goal的 contract 是什麼?跟 ralph-loop 重疊到什麼程度?/goal也能扮演(PR, unattended)verify-fix loop driver?(若是 → idd-all Phase 0.6 應提/goal為 alternative)/goal是 higher-level 而 ralph-loop 是 inner driver?(關係互補,不是 substitution)/goal為 also-available alternative;(b) 全部 7 處 deprecate ralph-loop binary detect 改/goal;(c) 不改,維持 ralph-loop 為唯一 canonical driver?Type
enhancement / docs(plugin reference cleanup)
Priority
P3 — 影響文件 clarity 不影響 runtime behavior;等 #135 v3 implementation land 後一併評估 unattended-mode 驅動機制全景
Out of scope
本 issue 不 fold 進 #135 spectra change(terminology trust gap)— 兩條 axis 正交,避免 scope creep。
Refs #135 sister concern session