ASTROLOGY_KILLER_TEST_RESULTS

Astrology Killer Test Results

Status: verified in the project .venv

Purpose

This report records the first dedicated adversarial astrology gauntlet for Moira.

These are not interpretive demonstrations. They are doctrine, boundary, policy, and public-path validation checks for:

• zodiac, house, aspect, and nakshatra boundary behavior
• antiscia, midpoint dial, and Arabic mansion seam behavior
• day/night lot reversal truth
• lot dependency-network determinism
• aspect semantic invariance under input permutation
• dignity sign-boundary discipline
• profection cycle, monthly lord, and activation behavior
• Vimshottari boundary and cycle-failure behavior
• Firdaria and Zodiacal Releasing containment and boundary behavior
• explicit sidereal electional evaluation support
• malformed doctrine-input failure behavior
• public chart vessel truth preservation across derived astrology layers

Proof files

• tests/unit/test_astrology_adversarial_gauntlet.py
• tests/unit/test_electional.py

Verification command

• python -m pytest tests/unit/test_astrology_adversarial_gauntlet.py -q
• python -m pytest tests/unit/test_electional.py -q

All listed commands passed on 2026-04-24.

---

1. Boundary Assassins

Measured surfaces:

Boundary	Assertion
Zodiac sign seam	29.999999999 Aries, 30.0 Taurus, 359.999999999 Pisces, 360.0 Aries
House cusp seam	Point just before cusp remains in prior house; exact cusp belongs to opening house
Aspect orb seam	Exact allowed-orb sextile is admitted; 0.000001 deg outside is rejected
Nakshatra seam	Final instant of first nakshatra remains index 0; exact boundary advances to index 1, pada 1
Arabic mansion seam	Final instant of first mansion remains mansion 1; exact boundary advances to mansion 2
Zodiac wrap	360.0 deg returns to first sign and first mansion

Interpretation:

• Core astrology arithmetic honors half-open interval doctrine at sign, house, aspect, and nakshatra boundaries.
• No off-by-one or wraparound bleed was observed in the tested seams.

---

2. Mirror And Dial Geometry

Measured surfaces:

Attack	Assertion
Antiscion round-trip	antiscion(antiscion(lon)) == lon mod 360 across seams
Contra-antiscion round-trip	contra(contra(lon)) == lon mod 360 across seams
Near-wrap antiscion contact	359.999999999 -> 180.000000001 detected inside 1e-6 deg
Midpoint seam	350/10 and 10/350 both midpoint to 0.0 deg
90-degree dial seam	90.0 deg folds to 0.0 deg; just-before value remains just before the dial seam

Interpretation:

• Hidden-point arithmetic is reversible where doctrine requires it.
• Dial folding and shorter-arc midpoint behavior remain coherent at the circular seam.

---

3. Lots Day/Night Reversal

Fixed synthetic chart:

Input	Value
Ascendant	100.0 deg
Sun	20.0 deg
Moon	80.0 deg

Measured doctrine:

Lot	Day formula result	Night formula result
Fortune	Asc + Moon - Sun = 160.0 deg	Asc + Sun - Moon = 40.0 deg
Spirit	Asc + Sun - Moon = 40.0 deg	Asc + Moon - Sun = 160.0 deg

Truth preservation:

• Day Fortune preserved effective_add_key == "Moon" and effective_sub_key == "Sun".
• Night Fortune preserved reversed_for_chart == True with effective_add_key == "Sun" and effective_sub_key == "Moon".

Interpretation:

• Fortune and Spirit reverse visibly by doctrine.
• The result vessel preserves the computational path rather than merely returning a longitude.

---

4. Lot Dependency-Network Determinism

Measured surface:

Attack	Assertion
Reversed planet input order	Same lot-network nodes, edges, isolated set, and most-connected set
Network node accounting	Incoming, outgoing, and reciprocal counts remain identical
Network edge accounting	Source, target, dependency role, and reciprocal/unilateral mode remain identical

Interpretation:

• Lot network truth is independent of caller mapping insertion order.
• Derived lot dependencies remain stable as a graph, not merely as isolated longitude results.

---

5. Aspect Permutation Attack

Measured surface:

Attack	Assertion
Reversed input insertion order	Same unordered body pairs, aspect names, and orbs
Graph profile	Node and edge accounting remains internally consistent
Harmonic profile	Chart total equals admitted aspect count; per-body totals match graph degree

Interpretation:

• Aspect semantics survive input permutation.
• The test intentionally does not require body1/body2 orientation to change; Moira currently preserves caller-discovery orientation in the result vessel.

---

6. Dignity Sign-Boundary Discipline

Measured surface:

Probe	Result
Sun at 149.999999999 deg	Leo, domicile
Moon at 150.0 deg	Virgo, not domicile

Interpretation:

• Essential dignity does not bleed across the Leo/Virgo boundary.
• Structured essential-truth metadata agrees with the visible sign.

---

7. Profection Cycle Attack

Measured surface:

Probe	Result
Age 0 and age 12	Same profected house, sign, lord, and monthly-lord sequence
Age 13	Advances to house 2, Taurus, Venus
Month 0 at age 13	Taurus / Venus
Month 11 at age 13	Aries / Mars
Activation seam	Body within 1e-6 deg of profected Asc is admitted; distant body is rejected

Interpretation:

• Annual profection preserves its 12-year cycle.
• Monthly lord sequence wraps correctly and does not smear activation across a loose boundary.

---

8. Vimshottari Doctrine Boundary

Measured surface:

Probe	Result
Moon just before nakshatra boundary	First Vimshottari lord
Moon exactly at boundary	Second Vimshottari lord
Exact-boundary first mahadasha	nakshatra_fraction == 0.0
Query before birth	Explicit ValueError
Unsupported year basis	Explicit ValueError

Interpretation:

• Dasha entry is boundary-honest.
• Doctrine settings fail explicitly rather than falling back to an ambient default.

---

9. Timelord Containment And Boundary Attack

Measured surface:

Probe	Result
Firdaria output	Public validator accepts generated hierarchy
Firdaria major sequence	Matches declared diurnal sequence
Firdaria total span	Major periods sum to 75.0 years
Exact first-major end	Active major advances to next major; half-open interval honored
End of 75-year cycle	Explicit ValueError
Zodiacal Releasing output	Public validator accepts level containment through level 3
Invalid ZR level	Explicit ValueError
Invalid lot name	Explicit ValueError

Interpretation:

• Time-lord hierarchies preserve containment and half-open boundary doctrine.
• Invalid symbolic doctrine requests fail explicitly.

---

10. Malformed Doctrine Inputs

Measured failures:

Malformation	Result
Incomplete house-cusp map for lots	Explicit ValueError
Strict unresolved-reference policy	Explicit ValueError
Invalid aspect policy orb factor	Explicit ValueError

Interpretation:

• Malformed doctrine inputs are rejected before silent substitution.
• Policy failure remains visible to callers.

---

11. Electional Sidereal Evaluation

Measured surface:

Probe	Result
Default tropical policy	Predicate still receives the legacy chart payload
Explicit sidereal policy	Predicate receives ElectionalEvaluation
Sidereal planet longitudes	Tropical chart longitudes are converted through declared ayanamsa
Sidereal node longitudes	Node longitude view is converted through the same policy
Sidereal house cusps	House-cusp view is converted without mutating the chart
Policy failures	Invalid frame, mode, or empty sidereal ayanamsa fail explicitly

Interpretation:

• Electional search is no longer tropical-only when the caller requests a sidereal evaluation frame.
• The underlying chart remains the astronomical truth carrier; sidereal electional work is exposed as an explicit evaluation view.

---

12. Public Chart Vessel Truth Preservation

Measured public path:

Derived layer	Assertion
Lots	Fortune recomputes from chart-carried Asc, Sun, Moon, and sect
Aspects	Motion state classification remains in the declared finite enum set
Dignities	Every chart-carried planet receives a dignity result
Lot network	Node and edge counts match their materialized vessels

Interpretation:

• Public chart assembly preserves lower-layer astrology truth.
• Derived layers consume the chart vessel without mutating or replacing its carried astronomical positions.

---

Summary Table

Challenge	Result	Evidence
Boundary assassins	Pass	Sign, house, aspect, and nakshatra seams behave cleanly
Mirror and dial geometry	Pass	Antiscia, midpoint, dial, and mansion seams behave coherently
Lots reversal truth	Pass	Fortune/Spirit day-night reversal and operand truth preserved
Lot network determinism	Pass	Dependency graph survives reversed input order
Aspect permutation attack	Pass	Semantic aspect set survives reversed input order
Dignity boundary discipline	Pass	Domicile does not bleed across Leo/Virgo seam
Profection cycle attack	Pass	12-year return, monthly wrap, and activation seam hold
Vimshottari boundary doctrine	Pass	Nakshatra lord transition and failure modes are explicit
Timelord containment attack	Pass	Firdaria and Zodiacal Releasing validate hierarchy and boundaries
Electional sidereal evaluation	Pass	Sidereal predicate view exists without mutating chart substrate
Malformed doctrine inputs	Pass	Bad policies and incomplete inputs fail visibly
Public chart truth preservation	Pass	Lots, aspects, dignities, and lot network stay coherent from chart vessel

Bottom line

Moira now has a dedicated adversarial astrology killer-test layer. It does not pretend interpretive doctrine is a physical oracle. It proves the appropriate thing: explicit doctrine, clean boundaries, visible policy, deterministic semantic behavior, and public-path truth preservation.