change Long Term status for certain unowned features to "scheduled for deletion"#12400
Merged
gxglass merged 2 commits intoapple:mainfrom Sep 29, 2025
Merged
Conversation
…ion" where applicable
gxglass
changed the title
gxglass
changed the title
Contributor
Result of foundationdb-pr-clang-ide on Linux RHEL 9
|
Contributor
Result of foundationdb-pr-macos-m1 on macOS Ventura 13.x
|
Contributor
Result of foundationdb-pr-clang-arm on Linux CentOS 7
|
Contributor
Result of foundationdb-pr-clang on Linux RHEL 9
|
Contributor
Result of foundationdb-pr on Linux RHEL 9
|
Contributor
Result of foundationdb-pr-cluster-tests on Linux RHEL 9
|
Contributor
|
Links to discussion on discord about this. |
dlambrig
approved these changes
Sep 27, 2025
Contributor
Author
|
Reopening. A rare "in the mood for classical" window. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uWnKMzAedK4 |
Contributor
Result of foundationdb-pr-clang-ide on Linux RHEL 9
|
Contributor
Result of foundationdb-pr-macos-m1 on macOS Ventura 13.x
|
Contributor
Result of foundationdb-pr-clang-arm on Linux CentOS 7
|
Contributor
Result of foundationdb-pr-macos on macOS Ventura 13.x
|
Contributor
Result of foundationdb-pr-cluster-tests on Linux RHEL 9
|
Contributor
Result of foundationdb-pr on Linux RHEL 9
|
Contributor
Result of foundationdb-pr-clang on Linux RHEL 9
|
saintstack
approved these changes
Sep 29, 2025
Contributor
Result of foundationdb-pr-clang-ide on Linux RHEL 9
|
Contributor
Result of foundationdb-pr-clang-arm on Linux CentOS 7
|
Contributor
Result of foundationdb-pr-cluster-tests on Linux RHEL 9
|
Contributor
Result of foundationdb-pr on Linux RHEL 9
|
Contributor
Result of foundationdb-pr-clang on Linux RHEL 9
|
gxglass
added a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Oct 13, 2025
This is the first experimental feature to be deleted in the list published at PR #12400. There is more code here than I anticipated. It is about 40,000 lines total, of which about three quarters are in dedicated files which I am deleting, and about one quarter is in shared files. That means about 10k lines in shared files, which is the stuff we tend to notice day to day (that plus the test failures on heretofore not-yet-disabled test cases, which I am now deleting). I ran 3 million simulations, mostly against 692df86 or very similar code (differing by one TraceEvent). This was prior to syncing with upstream/main, which had no conflicts and from which I don't expect problems. The number of failures in these runs was about 8. We looked at them and believe there is a high likelihood that these are existing issues not related to the changes in this PR. More details on these failures can be found in docs linked from here: https://quip-apple.com/MN7gAyXLjgyn * change Long Term status for unowned features for "scheduled for deletion" where applicable * Relax wording about scheduled for deletion features * Delete blob granule feature. WIP. Does not compile. * more incremental hacking to remove / comment out blob granule related code * more hacking to remove blob granule related code, e.g. blob manager and blob migrator roles * delete more blob granule stuff * more hacking * more hacking * more hacking * More changes to remove blob granule related code. IT COMPILES NOW * dont try to run AuthzSecurity tests as we have deleted that workload as part of this effort * delete more stuff that matches, abbreviates, or smells like blob granule related * EncryptKeyProxy: dont do blobMetadata stuff, because that is not used and support is being removed * delete more references to blob granule stuff * SimulationConfig::setEncryptionAtRestMode: always use DISABLED; also disable EncryptKeyProxyTest.toml * format code * manual update to bindings/java/src/tests.cmake to remove a deleted file * fix compile errors. I guess by default I dont build Java bindings * remove unneeded blob granule functions rather than #if..#endif them out * remove more code in #if..#endif * remove more code in #if 0..#endif * revert changes to fdb_c.h in preparation for marking removed API calls as removed * rework C API declarations to in preparation for marking blob granule APIs as removed * deprecate removed glob granule related API functions as of version 740 (and add a comment to request a justification of this convention) * make progress on broken ctests. E.g. 1) python does not need to do blob granule stuff. 2) authz tests seemingly not needed * remove blob granule stuff from Java and Python APIs and fix test runner stuff so that ctests pass * reformat comments to fix compile error. FIXME: why is this error not happening on the default compile commands we use * hacks all the way down to try to fix the Mac build * add pointed comment about the perceived pointlessness of the API deprecation scheme embodied in this source file * really serious about the C++ style comments, arent we * remove commented-out code from prior iterative efforts * put back undeleted code in original order * delete commented-out code * update feature-status.md to say blob granule is mostly deleted * upgrade `mostly deleted` to `has been deleted`
gxglass
added a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Oct 17, 2025
Continuing the deletions of unowned experimental features as listed in #12400. ChangeFeed is mostly contained in NativeAPI.actor.cpp and storageserver.actor.cpp, with a modest amount of code in dedicated files and a scattering of updates in misc other places where features tend to pile into. There are a few lingering TODOs for fine tuning of the additional removal, including a state machine in storageserver.actor.cpp. My preference is to checkpoint this diff before continuing with more experimental/risky fine grain surgery in close proximity to code which must remain. This PR nets -6000 lines, mostly in NativeAPI.actor.cpp and storageserver.actor.cpp, so benefits should accrue in terms of compile times and general "less unwanted code showing up on your screen" when working in these files. Ran overnight: 20251016-003236-gglass-46416fec30cddcb0 compressed=True data_size=38462735 duration=14586409 ended=310182 fail=10 fail_fast=10 max_runs=500000 pass=310172 priority=100 remaining=0 runtime=1:21:30 sanity=False started=314133 stopped=20251016-015406 submitted=20251016-003236 timeout=5400 username=gglass The 10 failures were in a specific recent unit test failure not related to this PR (link to details shared in Slack). Prior to this: 20251015-232157-gglass-46416fec30cddcb0 compressed=True data_size=38462735 duration=5241939 ended=99998 fail=2 fail_fast=10 max_runs=100000 pass=99996 priority=100 remaining=0 runtime=1:10:39 sanity=False started=100000 stopped=20251016-003236 submitted=20251015-232157 timeout=5400 username=gglass Those 2 failures were one existing bug (there is a radar for it) and one where amusingly Joshua decided to run a deleted BlobGranule test case, which I am just going to ignore. * Initiate deletion of changefeed feature. Probably does not compile * Checkpoint removal of changefeed reature. This set of changes compiles but is untested. * feature-status.md: ChangeFeed: status is now `has been deleted`. * Format code. This passed 100k simulations minus 2: one was, Joshua running a deleted test case (wtf?) and the second was a test case with an open radar
gxglass
added a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Dec 9, 2025
These features have been previously marked for deletion per PR #12400. This change necessarily affects a lot of files. In general I found it preferable to cut along the FDB <-> tenant boundary, rather than try to cut tenant into multiple pieces, stitch the Frankenstein tenant implementation back together with FDB, and generally remove the limbs one by one. So it is a single big deletion. Note that some tenant-related metadata has been written in a non-flag-controlled manner by prior releases and probably must be ignored indefinitely. Fortunately this is isolated to include/fdbclient/ClientLogEvents.h. (Details: deleting an Optional from a serialized struct results in deserialization of garbage in upgrade tests. The serialized nullopt to indicate "no Tenant" is formally part of FDB persistent metadata even in FDB clusters that never would have enabled the tenant feature.) During the course of testing these changes, many interesting bugs were encountered. I won't discuss details of them here. Causes range from flat out damage (by me) to production code in the course of removing tenant related bits (mainly in NativeAPI.actor.cpp and CommitProxy.actor.cpp), damage to various workload files (particularly FuzzApiCorrectness.actor.cpp, which is very sensitive to changes), and many toml files needing updated test flags/options. More testing details: https://quip-apple.com/Zr6VAycxoli9 20251209-012852-gglass-8ff850b772d868f2 compressed=True data_size=35311687 duration=21671404 ended=500000 fail_fast=1000 max_runs=500000 pass=500000 priority=100 remaining=0 runtime=2:31:30 sanity=False started=500000 stopped=20251209-040022 submitted=20251209-012852 timeout=5400 username=gglass * remove some unneeded tests, and remove mentions of deleted tests from tests/CmakeLists.txt * Initiate removal of metacluster. NOTE: this seems to also want removal of tenant. Consider removing them together. * work on removing metacluster * delete files with `Tenant` in the name, having reviewed them to ensure that they basically contain what the name implies * fdb_c.h: remove prototypes for C API methods which have been deleted (blob granule) or which are so long deprecated that they are outside any reasonable/documented support window * Surgical removal of tenant references from files in bindings/ top level directory. Compilation not yet attempted. * Surgical removal of tenant related stuff from fdbcli/ top level directory. Compilation not yet attempted. * Misc tenant code removal, and other stuff which I think may not be needed. Compilation still not attempted. * Remove more tenant or tenant-adjacent or blob-granule-adjacent stuff. Or at least stuff that looks adjacent to that stuff. Not compiled or tested. * Start removing Tenant stuff from fdbclient/. Far from complete. Compilation not attempted. * Remove tenant references from many source files. There are still about 7 principal fdbclient/ and fdbserver/ files with a lot of tenant logic left to delete. Also, all of fdbserver/workloads needs to be looked at. Still have not attempted compilation. * Remove tenant entanglement from watch functionality * Remove tenant stuff from fdbserver/tester.actor.cpp * Delete metacluster workloads * Remove tenant related stuff from workloads. Also taken the liberty of removing some functionality that appears unused or untestable by Apple. * Checkpoint tenant removal from FuzzApiCorrectness.actor.cpp * NativeAPI.actor.cpp: `Tenant` has left the building. * SimulatedCluster.actor.cpp: `Tenant` has left the building * DDShardTracker.actor.cpp: Tenant evicted * storageserver.actor.cpp: `tenant` has left the building. * fdbserver/workloads/FuzzApiCorrectness.actor.cpp: remove tenant references, but some lingering cleanup needed in `loadAndRun` * FileBackupAgent.actor.cpp: tenant has left the building * CommitProxyServer.actor.cpp: remove tenant * Remove more tenant references from misc files such as bindings tests, documentation, and some fdbserver headers I left earlier * Fix missing-file errors in CMakeLists.txt files. This is the first attempt to compile this stuff. * checkpoint misc changes to fix compile errors * checkpoint more compile fixes * StorageServerInterface.h: put back more verify() calls * More misc compile fixes * whole bunch of misc fixups including some code put-backs to address compile errors * More compile fixes * More compile fixes. Still does not compile. * incremental compile fixing * ... * ... * Checkpoint a bunch of compile fixes. Not quite there but getting closer * More compile fixes. There seem to be about 10 files left, mainly CommitProxyServer.actor.cpp and storageserver.actor.cpp * IT COMPILES NOW. THIS IS STILL ALL UNTESTED. Unsurprisingly, CommitProxyServer.actor.cpp and storageserver.actor.cpp took the most tweaking. The updates in CMakeLists.txt and workloads/UnitTests.actor.cpp are basically trivial and mainly reflect the ordering of dependencies -- that stuff didn't get attempted until all of fdbserver compiled. * Put back one block relating to encryption at rest mode. Simplify some TODO(gglass) instances. * Put back some encryption related knobs * remove `enable_tenants` from local_cluster.py to maybe fix some ctests * Remove tenant related options from toml files. * feature-status.md: add a line for encryption at rest, which seems to have been added for multi-tenant; status is now in doubt * Fix a pretty bad bug introduced in tenant deletion; ensure we dont attempt to construct a std::string of negative length * workloads/FuzzApiCorrectness.actor.cpp: avoid division by zero * flow/Platform.actor.cpp: add a try/catch wrapper around side threads; emit a better addr2line type command * NativeAPI.actor.cpp: fix a bug introduced in tenant removal relating to reporting conflicting keys under conflictingKeysRange * ReportConflictingKeys.actor.cpp: separate an ANDed assert into two asserts * SpecialKeySPaceCorrectness.actor.cpp: put back some logic removed with tenant removal. This test was failing due to a bug with conflict key range reporting. Fixed separately in NativeAPI.actor.cpp. * remove QuotaCommand.actor.cpp * Force disable tenant and encryption on disk in upgrade tests * Add back file I guess I deleted? who knows * put back another file * design/feature-status.md: update the new row for encryption at rest to firm up the claim that it is experimental, unowned, and scheduled for deletion * Remove EncryptKeyProxyTest since we do not use it * new file tests/slow/BulkDumpingS3WithChaos.toml: remove tenantModes setting * Undo damage to pushToBackupMutations() from removing tenant feature. This caused inverted_range errors and failed commits in backup related simulations. * tests/restarting/from_7.4.0/Snap*-1: ensure that tenantModes = disabled * Try again on workloads/FuzzApiCorrectness.actor.cpp * simplify tenant-free (mostly) FuzzApiCorrectness workload code * try harder to remove lingering tenant-related brokenness from FuzzApiCorrectness.actor.cpp * Explicitly specify tenantModes = ['disabled'] in all the -1 restart files * Remove tenantModes from 7.1-based upgrade tests as its an unknown option. Hopefully the code doesnt actually turn on tenant stuff * do not specify tenantModes in downgrade tests * Downgrade test to_7.4.5: dont say tenantModes * more tenantModes updates * Remove a legacy allowDefaultTenant that no longer is meaningful in downgrade to 8.0 * Put back empty Optional<TenantName> turdlets into serialized log events to avoid breaking ClientTransactionProfilingCorrectness upgrade tests (even with tenantMode = disabled) * disable encryption on a few more upgrade related test cases. That feature is slated for removal anyway * Remove unneeded workload files that have been subject to #if 0 for a while. Remove commented out block in ClusterRecovery * disable encryption in more upgrade tests * Remove choice four-letter words from commentary * Format 42 files * Try to fix a doc bug failing the CI build * More doc compilation error fixes * Delete more tenant junk from documentation * fix spelling mistake in comment * Remove deleted cross-references from documentation. This necessitated editing release 3.0.0 release notes, which is insane. * Remove more tenant stuff from bindings tests * Remove more tenant bits from design/ files * Remove more tenant related stuff * Delete more tenant references. Put back ten-ant spellings as tenant now that grep output is substantially reduced. * Put back some tenant stuff into apitester; its deletion seems to have introduced bugs. Also whine about comments some more, because, really, the comments deserve it. * Updates to workload files and one other thing based on review comments * de-actorify decodeKVPairs * format one source file * Restore transaction tagging doc * Restore throttle doc details in administration.rst * Restore fdbserver/workloads/GetEstimatedRangeSize.actor.cpp and associated toml file, minus tenant stuff * bindings/c/test/{shim related}: update comments and disable functionality that no longer works post-tenant * put the cli-throttle tag back in * bindingtester: fix python syntax errors * remove useless comment * Remove comment about useless comments, and remove the useless comments
gxglass
added a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Feb 5, 2026
Delete encryption at rest in accordance with plans circulated in PR #12400. Development of this PR was mostly straightforward. Several issues of note: Upgrade tests which use Redwood want to use the old "encrypt by 0xFF XOR" test-only encoding/encryption algorithm. I wanted to delete that in main and did so. Upgrade tests have been modified not to use Redwood (storage engine 3, mentioned in various storageEngineExcludeTypes test options updates). 7.1 did not define storageEngineExcludeTypes. After some discussion we have decided to delete 7.1-based upgrade tests. 7.3- and 7.4-based upgrade tests remain in place. Cross-version compatibility (such as it is, I assume in client library startup) remains super easy to break when deleting code. Tips: (A) removing unnecessary arguments to functions is bread and butter code editing when removing code, but if you find yourself removing arguments from a serializer() invocation, you might be breaking a protocol. (B) run ctest -R upgrade early and often. An implication of these changes is that we are going to rely on the community to make us aware of any {upgrade+Redwood}-specific bugs. In other words, we are declining to continue to go out of our way to test functionality that we have no plans to use. On the plus side this reclaims 15,000 more lines of code that we don't have to look at or think about, including in common areas such as commit proxy, backups, and generic storage server code. Testing: 20260129-230241-gglass-15694f5f80af6932 compressed=True data_size=34905446 duration=4335357 ended=100000 fail_fast=1000 max_runs=100000 pass=100000 priority=100 remaining=0 runtime=6:21:47 sanity=False started=100000 stopped=20260130-052428 submitted=20260129-230241 timeout=5400 username=gglass 20260202-214159-gglass-69b90c779cf8ec68 compressed=True data_size=35007141 duration=4612639 ended=100000 fail_fast=1000 max_runs=100000 pass=100000 priority=100 remaining=0 runtime=3:00:25 sanity=False started=100000 stopped=20260203-004224 submitted=20260202-214159 timeout=5400 username=gglass * Checkpoint file removals and code edits for removing encryption at rest. Have not tried to compile this yet. * Checkpoint some improvements. Still does not compile. * Merging with upstream changes in copyright updates resurrected previously deleted files, so delete them again * Checkpoint incremental progress towards getting this to compile * Checkpoint more intermediate changes getting encryption at rest deleted. Still doesnt compile but getting closer. * Changes sufficient to get things to compile with removal of encryption at rest. NOT TESTED. * Delete encryptModes from toml files run by current fdbserver binaries; restarting tests using <= 7.4 binaries do need encryptModes to say disabled * Avoid using MAX_ENCODING_VALUE for random purposes for which other solutions are more clear and generally better * Stop using XOREncryption_TestOnly because that no longer works. Also I see no need to support it as it requires unneeded interfaces and test fixtures in order to actually work. * Remove more page encryption stuff, and address some TODO(gglass) comments. * debugging redwood failures * Fix some misc simulation failures. Notably, disable storage engine type 3 (redwood) on upgrade tests, as it writes databases with encoding type 1 which is no longer supported * Add a comment discussion deprecation options for fields in persistent metadata, and explain why we are merely renaming the member as deprecated and nothing anything else. * Remove 7.1 upgrade tests. These tests enable Redwood and write databases with "0xFF XOR encryption" style encoding (encoding 1), which is removed in main. * Improve comments * Obligatory f3f commit. Format The Effin Source Files * Delete more unneeded encryption stuff * Put back about 1% of deleted code in a desperate attempt to unbreak broken protocol compatibility * formatting * Remove mentions of encryption at rest in backup related APIs * Address misc review comments. Remove --encrypt-files backup option.
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
5 participants
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
Efforts to reduce the file size of NativeAPI.actor.cpp are running into trouble due to a lot of shared code used by change feed and blob granule stuff. It is difficult to split that stuff out because of dependencies on templates and other stuff that needs to be contained within NativeAPI.actor.cpp.
At this point I think it would be easier to just delete a lot of this stuff -- change feed, blob granule related, and certain multitenancy related bits rather than move it out of NativeAPI.actor.cpp and then delete it only a short while later.
In general I really think there is no reason for us to continue to tolerate the costs associated with this abandoned code, so I think we should proceed immediately to deletion.
The costs include
Edit: we may want to add a few more items from the end of the table.