Skip to content

Messages from Stalwart are not delivered to chatmail servers #645

@TudbuT

Description

@TudbuT

This is almost certainly a chatmail issue since it is chatmail rejecting some parameters. However, it happened to me while using deltachat and I have not tested other chatmail clients (are there any?). If I should open an issue there instead after all, I can do so.

  • using nine.testrun.org
  • sending from a stalwart mail server

Expected behavior

An end-to-end encrypted chat is set up (using qr code)

Actual behavior

I received a mail delivery system error stating:

Failed to deliver message – Your message could not be delivered to the following recipients:

2grh8mqum@nine.testrun.org (host 'nine.testrun.org' rejected command 'RCPT TO:2grh8mqum@nine.testrun.org NOTIFY=DELAY,FAILURE' with code 555 (0.0.0) 'RCPT TO parameters not recognized or not implemented')

The issue is likely the NOTIFY=DELAY,FAILURE parameters. Stalwart uses only standard parameters, so this means chatmail is probably being non-conformant. I can send mail to all other kinds of servers

Steps to reproduce the problem

  1. Use a stalwart email server (or some others probably)
  2. Use deltachat on that and on a chatmail server
  3. Try to open a chat between the two accounts

Screenshots

Logs

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

No labels
No labels

Type

No type

Projects

No projects

Milestone

No milestone

Relationships

None yet

Development

No branches or pull requests

Issue actions