Record review of Astryx PR 5553
review loop: refresh operator page for 1.5.0
review loop: require user impact and evidence
Record review of Astryx PR 5547
Review-5570: probe theme all-axes page — approve with three nits, merged after fix round 1
Correct Review 5545 loop version
Record review 5516
Record review for PR 5545
Review-5567: record posted request-changes review
Review-5567: record Collapsible reveal review
Review-5478: record the CLI case-exact resolver review — approve, unposted (self-review block), merged
review: record PR 5513
Record review of PR 5515
Record review #5512
review loop: keep every pass in one agent
Record review of PR 5510
Record review for PR 5514
Ratify the LayoutHeader owner for PR 3938
Review-5508: approve (drafted) — Selector StyleX source-build fix, loop 1.4.0 / audit 1.12
Link the issue referenced by review 3938
Review-5543: publish round-2 visual evidence
Review PR 3938 round 3a — correct the obsolete round-3 criterion Rounds 2a and 3 asked jiunshinn to keep the template's marginTop:12 and marginBottom:-16 and remove only marginInline. That contradicts ruling 4, which says tabsRow must lose ALL its hand-written CSS and that nothing may be a hardcoded amount. Round 3's layout judgement is withdrawn; its unenforced-play block survives. Six arms driven on the real detail-page route: the retained -16 under-docks by 8px at header padding={6}, deleting tabsRow alone leaves the underline 15px off, a TabList-owned block dock moves the ghost -8px, and the zero-API Section seam fails at padding={6} too. LayoutHeader owning the edge holds 5/5 at both paddings. Whether LayoutHeader grows that surface is filed as ruling 12. Also corrects round 2a's '14px ghost lift on deleting tabsRow' — not reproducible; it belonged to that arm's vAlign flip.
review: append PR 5543 round 2
Sync current review presentation template
Mirror architecture cheat sheet in review wiki
Review-5454: round 2 at exact head e24ef4c — approve (drafted) All three round-1 blockers verified satisfied. One new note: the heading pin is scoped to the built-in heading, so a custom renderGroupHeader still loses its chevron when scrolled (byte-identical to the pre-fix frame). Three critic passes; the unguarded arm and the at-rest state were driven rather than cited.
Review PR 3938 round 3
Complete PR 5493 judgement gates
Record PR 5493 exact-head re-review
review: publish PR 4590 round 2 evidence