CockroachDB supports GENERATED ALWAYS AS IDENTITY columns, and information_schema.columns correctly reports is_identity = 'YES' and identity_generation = 'ALWAYS' for these columns.
However, the dialect's get_columns() does not include identity information in the returned column dict. It returns default: nextval('..._seq') but identity is absent from the result.
This causes Alembic autogenerate to emit a spurious AlterColumnOp on every run for any Identity column — it sees Identity(always=True) in the model but no Identity in the reflected column, and tries to add it.
Reproduction
from sqlalchemy import create_engine, inspect, text
engine = create_engine("cockroachdb://...")
# Create a table with an Identity column
with engine.begin() as conn:
conn.execute(text("CREATE TABLE IF NOT EXISTS identity_test (id BIGINT GENERATED ALWAYS AS IDENTITY PRIMARY KEY)"))
# Reflect it
inspector = inspect(engine)
cols = inspector.get_columns("identity_test")
for col in cols:
print(col)
# Expected: {..., 'identity': {'always': True, ...}, ...}
# Actual: {'name': 'id', 'type': INTEGER(), 'nullable': False, 'default': "nextval('public.identity_test_id_seq'::REGCLASS)", 'autoincrement': True, ...}
# 'identity' key is absent
# Cleanup
with engine.begin() as conn:
conn.execute(text("DROP TABLE IF EXISTS identity_test"))
Expected: The identity key should be populated when the column uses GENERATED ALWAYS AS IDENTITY.
Actual: The identity key is absent. The underlying sequence is reported as a plain default.
CockroachDB supports
GENERATED ALWAYS AS IDENTITYcolumns, andinformation_schema.columnscorrectly reportsis_identity = 'YES'andidentity_generation = 'ALWAYS'for these columns.However, the dialect's
get_columns()does not include identity information in the returned column dict. It returnsdefault: nextval('..._seq')butidentityis absent from the result.This causes Alembic autogenerate to emit a spurious
AlterColumnOpon every run for any Identity column — it seesIdentity(always=True)in the model but no Identity in the reflected column, and tries to add it.Reproduction
Expected: The
identitykey should be populated when the column usesGENERATED ALWAYS AS IDENTITY.Actual: The
identitykey is absent. The underlying sequence is reported as a plaindefault.