Skip to content

History / Lesson Validation Methodology

Revisions

  • ingest: Analysis-of-Wiki-Push-Race-Pattern + reclassify Multi-Agent-Write-Protocol New type: analysis page filed in response to a 2026-06-12 production collision in wiki/web_forager.wiki/ (3-4 human+agent teams; Csweet1 push rejected after Omegaice advanced remote by 20 commits in the interim; conflict on log_web_forager.md from same-date entries from both authors; ~3 minute manual rebase recovery). The Multi-Agent-Write-Protocol prototype at scripts/multi-agent-write-protocol-proto/ (shipped in PR #11; 9/9 CI scenarios green on ubuntu-latest + macos-latest) handles exactly this collision shape automatically via wiki_push's mechanical union-merge for log_* files. The prototype is implemented but not wired into any agent overlay; the only callers are the 9 CI scenarios. Reclassification: the Multi-Agent-Write-Protocol banner is rewritten from "design + prototype only, not yet wired" to "design + prototype shipped, production wiring is the gap." Implementation-Status's row is updated to name the wiring (not the design) as the specific gap and to outline what a wiring PR should contain. Second type: analysis page filed (after Analysis-of-model_fusion- Recommendations earlier today). Both acknowledge the SCHEMA violation that PR #29 closes. Cross-references: Multi-Agent-Write-Protocol gains See-also entry to the new page; Analysis-of-model_fusion-Recommendations and Lesson-Validation-Methodology gain back-refs as sister/related pages. Index updated under Applied examples (after the sister analysis page). Home updated per PR #32's category-level rule: the page is significant enough to warrant a Home entry, not just an Index entry. Wiki-Corrections-Log entry appended for the receipt. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

    @chrissweet chrissweet committed Jun 12, 2026
  • lint: refresh Lessons-Learned-From-model_fusion to HEAD 88f4624 Page declared verification against fc2472a (2026-06-04), an unresolvable fork-local SHA. Refreshed against actual current HEAD 88f4624 (2026-06-12). Three commits between the original snapshot and HEAD touch the field report's 12 recommendations: - PR #14 / 2018186: scripts/kg/ (KG pipeline shipped, rdflib + pyshacl) - PR #16 / b86c9e4: wiki/Edge-Types.md.template (inverse-edge vocabulary) - PR #25 / 88f4624: scripts/instantiate.sh --dev-self (recursive bootstrap fix shipped) Page updates: - Headline tally refreshed: 0 fully addressed / 3 partial / 9 missing, plus recursive-bootstrap RESOLVED. - Table row 9 refined: inverse vocabulary shipped but not yet wired into init-wiki.sh page-type list; PostToolUse does not enforce. - Body #9(a) rewritten to reference the shipped vocabulary and KG pipeline rather than designed-but-pending. - "The recursive bootstrap problem" section flipped to "RESOLVED in PR #25" with --dev-self behavior enumerated. - Provenance path corrected (/TCF/ -> /CRS_research/, the only real checkout) and the unresolvable fc2472a flagged as fork-local. 5 bidirectional back-references added on the high-value related: entries (sister page + three lessons + one limitation). The other 5 (Verification -Gate, Discipline-Gates, Three-Operations, PostToolUse-Hook, Implementation -Status) left one-way per the morning's heavily-linked roll-up rule. Wiki-Corrections-Log appended with the second-pass entry. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

    @chrissweet chrissweet committed Jun 12, 2026
  • lint: KG aspirational -> implemented; bidirectional back-references; example cleanup Stale-claim correction: PR #14 shipped scripts/kg/ (rdflib + pyshacl in-process KG pipeline) to template main, but nine wiki pages still described the pipeline as aspirational. Reclassified Knowledge-Graph- Pipeline to implemented; corrected architecture from Fuseki to rdflib + pyshacl; flagged the distribution gap (scripts/kg/ not yet in ALWAYS_FILES, likely to ship as features/kg/ under RFC #13). Updated Implementation-Status, Wiki-LLM-Pattern, Three-Operations, Typed-Edges- and-Frontmatter, SCHEMA, Limitation-Inverse-Edges-Missing, Sync-Flow, and the index to match. Example cleanup: Wiki-LLM-Pattern line 23 used the placeholder example [Markov-Chain-v5c2](Markov-Chain-v5c2). Replaced with a real wiki page name so lint and the KG see a valid edge. Bidirectional back-references added for the high-value concept <-> lesson / limitation pairs (Verification-Gate, Discipline-Gates, Lesson- Validation-Methodology, Lesson-Parallel-File-Drift, Template-vs-Derived- Projects, PostToolUse-Hook, Agent-Overlays). Index/log roll-ups (Implementation-Status, Wiki-Corrections-Log) intentionally left one-way. Wiki-Corrections-Log entry appended with the receipt. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

    @chrissweet chrissweet committed Jun 12, 2026
  • Initialize wiki: scaffold + first ingest of template knowledge Scaffolded SCHEMA, Home, index, log, and Home.md redirect to match the canonical create-mode output of wiki/init-wiki.sh. Authored 18 content pages across five categories (foundation, mechanisms, lessons, limitations, applied examples) capturing the wiki-llm pattern, the template's structure, the contents of PR #1 (discipline gates, verification gate, PostToolUse hook) and PR #4 (log entry attribution), the parallel-file-drift / hook-type / validation-method lessons surfaced by PR review, and the three open limitations (prompt-injection residual, missing edge inverses per issue #3, untested non-Claude-Code overlays). Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

    @chrissweet chrissweet committed May 20, 2026